Show Tracker

What you're watching

« Previous Post | Show Tracker Home | Next Post »

'American Idol' results: Haley Reinhart eliminated, leaving Scotty and Lauren as top two

May 19, 2011 |  7:09 pm


At the end of the day and after 95 million votes had rolled in -– the highest tally at this point in the competition in any season -– only two contestants could move on to the finale to vie for the "American Idol" crown. Sadly –- very sadly -- Haley Reinhart will not be one of them.

"This is the biggest platform any girl -- anybody -- can ask for," Haley said after learning that Scotty McCreery and Lauren Alaina would move on to the final stage without her. "And I rocked it out and I had a blast. And this is only the beginning. Thank you all so very much."

When Ryan Seacrest invited Haley to rock it out again one last time, she did, singing the song that turned the tide that had appeared destined to sweep her from the competition much earlier: Elton John's "Bennie and the Jets."

If that wasn't the song that made Steven Tyler utter the memorable words "You … sing … sexy" (who can remember?), it might have prompted him to say them this time around. Haley smashed it the way we've grown used to seeing her do these last few weeks, hitting the words "stick around" with particular emphasis.

She made what has now become the requisite visit to the judges' table, singing to each and every one, incorporating their names into the song, and then moved into the audience to sing to the many "Idol" Top 13 contestants she'd managed to outlast (including, yes, a very encouraging Casey Abrams).

Then she turned to us, the viewers who had kept her around far longer than her detractors -– and probably many of her fans -– would ever have predicted.

"This ain't the end of this thing," she growled. "See you later."

Then she hugged her folks -– her mom and her guitar-shredding dad, who, just the night before, she'd given the dream of playing before the TV-watching masses.

And Ryan swung our attention back to the two kids still standing in this competition.

Scotty and Lauren, those wholesome country kids, who had been thrown together several times to sing duets, their voices blending beautifully, would be duking it out on the final performance show in what would be "the youngest match-up in "Idol" history."

Ultimately, I suppose, the results shouldn't have come as much of a surprise. Scotty and Lauren have long been among the judges' favorites. Jimmy Iovine predicted at the top of Thursday's results show that Scotty would make it through to the finale, and Randy Jackson and Jennifer Lopez looked mighty pleased when Jimmy's prediction proved true.

Only Steven Tyler looked a bit disappointed to learn that one of his girls would be going home; but I'm guessing it must have offered him some satisfaction to learn that the one who'd be sticking around to take her shot at the "Idol" title was the one he'd dubbed "the one" back in auditions. To borrow (or bend) one of Steven's own favorite phrases: He'd loved Lauren from the moment she first laid eyes on him.

And you? Are you sad to see Haley go? Pleased that Lauren and Scotty will get their shot at the "Idol" crown? And which one of the remaining two has your vote? Please weigh in.

American Idol' recap: The final three vie for the glory

'American Idol' Top 3 greeted as hometown heroes

'American Idol' results: James Durbin eliminated

'American Idol' recap: What do the judges have against Haley?

Full Show Tracker coverage of 'American Idol'

-- Amy Reiter

Photo: The final three on "American Idol," from left, Haley Reinhart, Scotty McCreery and Lauren Alaina.

Credit: Michael Becker / Fox