American Idol: Carly Smithson shocker in the Idoldome
Absolute shock and pandemonium in the Idoldome tonight as the great Carly Smithson's Idol journey came to an end. Carly fell as part of the most unfair bottom two in Idol history. Outside, feelings ranged from anger at some of the surviving contestants to confusion.
I'll have more thoughts later tonight, but please use the comments section to say goodbye to the singer I have called the most electrifying Idol contestant ever. Let's all try and get some closure on this together!
- Richard Rushfield