24 Frames

Movies: Past, present and future

Category: Battle: Los Angeles

Critical Mass: 'Battle: Los Angeles'

March 11, 2011 |  1:30 pm


There's nothing like a terrible science-fiction action flick to bring out the creative writing skills in a film critic. Whether they hated it or merely tolerated it, the paper-thin plot and familiar images of "Battle: Los Angeles" gave critics plenty to laugh at, tear down or otherwise sneer at. Bad it is. Boring it is not. The movie is about an invading alien force destroying the City of Angels, something we've seen countless times in everything from "War of the Worlds" to "Independence Day" to last fall's "Skyline."

The Times' Betsy Sharkey opens her tepid review calling for a moment of silence for "for all the brick and mortar that made the ultimate sacrifice for 'Battle: Los Angeles.' Sob. Let me just grab a tissue. Sorry."

It's so bad it even inspires some decidedly impure thoughts in the mind of Christianity Today reviewer Brett McCracken, who admits, "It's not a good sign when, at the end of an alien invasion movie, you're disappointed that the aliens have not emerged victorious."

Continue reading »

Skyline shows effects don't have to break the bank

November 12, 2010 |  1:09 pm

Colin and Greg Strause worry that filmmaking, especially for stories requiring elaborate visual effects, has become prohibitive. "I think movies cost too much," says Greg, 35, two years older than brother Colin.

But there are profound discounts when you can do the work yourself, and the do-it-yourself evidence is this weekend's "Skyline."

The brothers, who run the Santa Monica visual effects house Hydraulx, shot their self-financed alien invasion film for about $1 million, and then added some $9 million in visual effects. Had they sold the same effect shots to a studio paying market rates, the brothers (who also directed 2007's "AVPR: Aliens vs. Predator--Requiem" for 20th Century Fox) estimate the job would have cost as much as $30 million. "But we're doing it all in house," Colin says, "so it's much cheaper."

Early reviews for the film have not been kind, with several of the movie's earliest notices slamming "Skyline's" screenplay and acting. But the comments for the Strause brothers' effects have been noticeably kinder.

One Australian reviewer, in an otherwise caustic smackdown, said: "Luckily, 'Skyline'  offers enough of a visual spectacular in the decimation of LA and the array of alien creatures and hardware to keep audiences entertained." The Hollywood Reporter, which was equally hard on the film, pointed out that "Skyline" does have "some occasionally inspired imagery." Glenn Kenny, writing for MSN Movies, said, "the brothers ARE pretty good with the tentacled, stomping, brain-ingesting, blowing-stuff-up aspects of the visuals, which get even more fun as they grow cheesier."

"Skyline" opens just as Sony Pictures released a new trailer for "Battle Los Angeles," another alien attack film set for next March on which Hydraulx did effects work. Sony complained -- but did not file a lawsuit alleging -- that some of "Skyline" may have been lifted from "Battle Los Angeles," but the brothers dispute the suggestion. "Nobody has a monopoly on a genre," Greg says. Adds Colin: "And they're totally different."

--John Horn

Photo of Donalad Faison, left, and Eric Balfour in "Skyline." Credit: Hydraulx/Rogue






Recommended on Facebook


In Case You Missed It...




Get Alerts on Your Mobile Phone

Sign me up for the following lists: