Southern California -- this just in

« Previous Post | L.A. NOW Home | Next Post »

'Phonehenge West' builder sentenced to jail

December 21, 2012 |  5:47 pm

Photo: Alan Kimble Fahey in front of his Phonehenge West monument before it was torn down by the county in 2011. Credit: Reed Saxon / Associated Press

An Acton man convicted of building-code violations who failed to repay thousands of dollars he owed Los Angeles County for demolishing the elaborate structure he dubbed “Phonehenge West,” was sentenced this week to almost 18 months in jail.

The jailing of Alan Kimble Fahey marked the end of a more than 20-year saga that pitted the retired phone technician against county code enforcement officials and led him in and out of court for the past five years.

Prosecutors argued that Fahey showed a deliberate disregard for authority and had no one but himself to blame for his fate. But Fahey’s supporters insisted that he was  unfairly punished for what they described as a “victimless crime.”

Fahey, who failed to obtain the proper building permits to construct Phonehenge, was facing six years in jail for 12 misdemeanor counts of building code violations, according to Sandi Gibbons, a spokeswoman for the L.A. County district attorney’s office. But on Wednesday, L.A. County Superior Court Judge Daviann L. Mitchell sentenced Fahey to 539 days in jail.

Pleading financial hardship, Fahey had repaid only $1,250 of the $83,488 he owed the county. Mitchell questioned Fahey’s inability to pay, charging that he had made false statements to the court about his financial status and had “knowingly and willfully disobeyed” the terms of his probation, Gibbons said.

Restitution to the county would now have to be resolved in civil court because the criminal case was over, Gibbons said.

Fahey's attorney, Jerry E. Lennon, said given the nonviolent nature of his client’s offense and his documented heart condition, Fahey would probably be eligible for early release.

Fahey spent about 30 years erecting Phongehenge—a 20,000-square-foot labyrinth of interconnected structures, some made from telephone poles. County code enforcement officers argued that the creation wasn't structurally sound and was a fire and earthquake risk, and therefore had to come down.

But Fahey’s supporters called Phonehenge “a work of art” worthy of  preservation. Many accused county officials of being too aggressive in its code enforcement practices and of  “stifling creativity.”

“It’s very difficult because your chances of winning against them are very slim,” said Fahey’s wife, Pat. “People will look at us and say I’m not going to take a chance.”


A man's castle, under code enforcement siege

'Phonehenge' builder ordered to repay county thousands

'Phonehenge West' builder is sent to jail over unpaid fines

--Ann M. Simmons

Photo: Alan Kimble Fahey in front of his Phonehenge West monument before it was torn down by the county in 2011. Credit: Reed Saxon / Associated Press