'I am not a racist,' ex-President Bill Clinton asserts
Former presidents get a whole lot of leeway in what they say in public. But former President Bill Clinton just violated one of the prime rules of political communications: Never say what you are not.
"I am not a crook," said Richard Nixon, which, of course, raised or confirmed the issue in the minds of millions during the long-running Watergate scandal that forced him from office. And provided a historic sound bite.
Clinton, who is supposed to be a major surrogate campaigner for Barack Obama this fall and speak at the Democrat
ic National Convention later this month, gave a fascinating and revealing exclusive interview to ABC News in Monrovia, Liberia, over the weekend.
Under some prodding and questioning, he showed an edginess that belied his denial of holding any anger about anything.
His jaw, his body language and lack of that warm, winning campaign smile added to the impression. Clinton spoke about several things, including his role in his wife's presidential primary campaign and what he regretted about it.
Asked if Obama was ready to become president, a readiness point Hillary Clinton hammered hard throughout the campaign, Bill Clinton clearly dodged the question, saying he doubted....
... anyone was ever ready for that job, that he had learned a few things in his early White House weeks in 1993.
Then he added, Obama "is smarter than a whip, so there's nothing he can't learn."
Asked about regrets over his sometimes polarizing role in his wife's unsuccessful campaign, he first said he wasn't going to talk about it, then proceeded to do so. "I got bad press," Clinton said. "Why? Because I told the truth that there was a different standard applied to the finest candidate I ever supported."
Asked specifically about his role in Sen. Clinton's campaign, he suggested the media check the voting results where he had campaigned in places like South Carolina, Pennsylvania and West Virginia, implying the results were positive for her where he had campaigned.
Then he added, "There are things that I wish I'd urged her to do. Things I wish I'd said. Things I wish I hadn't said. But I am not a racist. I've never made a racist comment and I never attacked [Obama] personally."
At one point the reporter referred to Rep. James Clyburn, who remained neutral in the primary struggle before jumping to Obama. She called Clyburn a longtime friend of Clinton's. "Used to be," snapped the ex-president.
"I'm not and never was mad at Sen. Obama," Clinton told the reporter. "You know he hit her hard a couple of times and they hit us a few times a week before she ever responded in kind. The only thing I ever got mad about was people in your line of work pretending that she somehow started the negative stuff. It's a contact sport."
The interview was broadcast on "Good Morning America." You can watch the entire video here. On a scale of four, we give it three Ticket punches.
Oh, and, by the way, Politico.com reports Sen. Clinton will be flying solo -- no Barack, no Bill -- when she campaigns for Obama in Nevada on Friday.
--Andrew Malcolm
Photo credit: Associated Press
Johanna Neuman is a veteran Washington correspondent for both The Los Angeles Times and USA Today, having covered presidents and politics as far back as Ronald Reagan. A former president of the White House Correspondents Assn., she authored a book on media and foreign policy, “Lights, Camera, Wars.” Most recently she was co-author of the
Rude and Insulting..... He's Not!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
LA Times,
Stick to what you are.... Throw-away pop stars drinking under age stories.... Not telling the complete truth about everything.....
Posted by: Dane | August 05, 2008 at 04:39 AM
Why don't you leave Bill alone. They asked questions he answered. Clybourn was not a supporter of Hillary or Bill in the primary. He sat on the sidelines then went with Obama, so Bill was right in saying he wasn't a supporter. After Clyburon tried to call bill out I wouldnt be friends with him anymore. Stop disecting bill everyword, where thes article on the work bill is doing in African, arent Obama's big ego and john's comedic ads enough for you to report on?
Posted by: rachel | August 05, 2008 at 04:42 AM
Any time someone has to comment on what they are not, ity is typically because they are... get over it Bill you are what you are.
Posted by: chris | August 05, 2008 at 04:57 AM
Bill is coming unglued. Time inevitably in different venues communicates the true character one is made of.
Posted by: Kroeze | August 05, 2008 at 05:09 AM
You can't win with the PC folks. Either you are or your not. But they decide what shade to give you. I could vote for Colin Powell as he is a man of integrity but , I can't vote for 'O' as he is not focused and flip-flops. I think McCains time has come and gone. The best canidate? Hillary!
The 'O' folks will play the race card but it ain't going to work.
Posted by: Gary Holbrook | August 05, 2008 at 05:12 AM
How can you trust a man that admits to smoking joints but " never" inhaled. Yes Bill tell us another bedtime story.
Posted by: johng | August 05, 2008 at 05:30 AM
Bill Clinton is full of it.
anyone remember Bill's comments on Obama for the ad he ran against Hillary taking money from oil companies and Bill's response was "Next we will see ads that say, vote for me I don't steal cars"
Posted by: JEFO | August 05, 2008 at 05:31 AM
The former President seems a little edgy. Personally, I believe he considered his zeal for Hillary as penance for another famous quote "I did not have sex with that woman, Ms. Lewinsky" (the 20 year old intern). A noted psychologist recenlty wrote that she felt Bill unconsciously wanted to undermine Hillary's with his idiotic statements during the campaign, really wanting her to fail to secure his own place in history. Still, there is another view shared by an old Italian fisherman in a coffee shop recently; "Bill Clinton's gettin' a little dingy; he must be makin' too many u-turns under the sheets during his road trips for 'charity'." Whatever, Obama is bigger than both Clinton's because, I believe, his is a movement, and movement politics can overcome the greatest of obstacles. He defeated two Clintons, and now his eye must be trained on the defeating the larger demons in our society. McCain is just a flea nibbling at his ankles along with the parasite advising his campaign, all part of Bush's "brain" trust.
Posted by: John | August 05, 2008 at 06:07 AM
A non-story.
Posted by: Almost Angeleno | August 05, 2008 at 06:56 AM
After warching the video clip, its obvious the reporter was goading Clinton into a "hatcha' moment.
Shoddy journalism.
Posted by: Almost Angeleno | August 05, 2008 at 07:03 AM
The damage Bill Clinton did to his own reputation during Hillary's campaign will always be there. His anger and defensiveness are obvious. His complete lack of self-awareness is astonishing.
President Obama must know to never, ever trust the Clintons. They will do anything in their power to destroy him. They will do it in a sneaky, secret way -- just as they are right now by undermining him and encouraging their supporters to do likewise.
In his own eyes, Bill probably told the truth when he said, "I am not a racist", however he never promised not to use other people's racism at every opportunity in order to win.
Posted by: Casey | August 05, 2008 at 07:07 AM
Clintonian triangulation- say something and blame the other guy for saying it first. The Clintons spoke in racial code- You know it and I know it- They knew the message they wanted their audience to "get" and they expressed themselves in the time-honored language of racial code. That's what they did. They did it to achieve a result. That's what they've done before. Only this time Camp Obama called them on it. Want proof? consider this- Each time the Obama camp called Camp Clinton on their use of racial code, Camp Clinton never used that particular code again. Hillary said "hardworking Americans, white Americans only once. She told the Bosnia lie at least 4 times. The Clintons used racial code in an attempt to sway voters. I don't think the Clintons are racist, however, the utter contempt in which they hold the American voter is clear. Bill and Hillary both repeatedly created cartoon caricatures of themselves deliberately designed to appeal to the worst tendencies of the voters they were performing for. They could have gone before those people and talked policy but they chose to do what they did, and then blame Sen. Obama for responding. They've done it before. they did it in '92 and in '96. When Mr. Clinton said he'd seen the memos that Obama was planning to respond that way all along, that's probably true. Camp Obama would not have been very astute if they had not studied how the Clinton machine had operated in past elections and been ready to respond to the most ugly and hateful attacks from Camp Clinton.
Posted by: david in WHFD | August 05, 2008 at 07:16 AM
Who cares?
It's about Obama now.
Posted by: CC | August 05, 2008 at 07:18 AM
It's always interesting to see the gap between the characterization of an interview by the corporate media and character of the interview itself. Reading the characterization, I expected something completely different. What I saw instead was a very calm, rational, and pleasant former president fielding questions blaming him for Hillary's loss.
Posted by: Andrew Austin | August 05, 2008 at 08:03 AM
Of course Hillary started it. Last July she started with the Obama is naive and irresponsible comment. Obama was always very careful and polite with Hillary. She was always quite to attack and then very thin-skinned when anyone said anything about her. I do feel she played the poor me gender card too readily and that just strengthened the negative stereotype many had about her in their minds. I think Hillary's big mistake was underestimating how strong that negative stereotype was in some people's mind. When she attacked, that just confirmed it. I really do think Hillary would have won if she and Bill had not attacked Obama so fiercely. And not complained so much when the press pointed that out. McCain is following in Hillary's footsteps and he had better watch out.
Posted by: Goldie | August 05, 2008 at 08:11 AM
Hey the hat trick ! Got a gal in every port. To bad the first
black pres.did not spend the whole campaign in Africa and allow the gracious lady from New York to win the
nomination.Barak better keep verbose Bill off the hustings
or face finishing in second place...wich aint bad.
Posted by: Monica,Monrovia and Liberia | August 05, 2008 at 08:15 AM
He just gave the world another way to further associate himself with Nixon. "I am not a ______"
Posted by: Will Hicks | August 05, 2008 at 08:43 AM
Once Bill Clinton (who was called our first black president by one sharp comedian) has to defend himself against being cast as a racist, then you know political correctness has gone too far. I support Obama, and one thing I'm hoping he can fix is the black community playing the race card everytime it's culture is questioned or pushed back on. Let's face it - lots of things are broken about black culture - glorifying violence (listen to some rap if you don't agree), the black crime rate, the idea that appearance (the bling aesthetic) matters more than substance (like education). Time to wake up black America and listen to your wise elders, like Bill Cosby, instead of your leeches, like Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson. Getting defensive and playing the race card isn't going to get you anywhere.
Posted by: mark | August 05, 2008 at 09:00 AM
Bill Clinton is "dead on" about the media perpetuating what Barack started... using the "race" card during the Primary.
Now we are left with a "eunuch" of a candidate in Obama! They should have appreciated what they had in Hillary. The DNC has found another way to lose.
I pick McCain over Obama, as the lesser of two evils.
Posted by: BJ | August 05, 2008 at 09:29 AM
Bill Clinton may have said and done a few questionable things in the heat of his wife's campaign, but if you look at his entire record, I don't think he is a racist. In fact, he has done a lot for African American's over the years. I think it is a mistake to throw around the racist label too lightly, because in those cases where someone is truly a racist, the label becomes meaningless. Unfortunately, the Carl Rove approach of "label" politics seems to have spread to the press. I wish the press would stop focusing on whether someone is a "flip-flopper," or a "arrogant" or "grumpy" or "racist" and just report on what the candidates do. Let the people make up in their own minds what adjectives apply.
Posted by: bb | August 05, 2008 at 09:38 AM
Interesting how so many want to jump on the bandwagon attacking Clinton, yet no one (including the comments above) has given an example.
Bill Clinton was applauded for years for his work with the black community and then without provocation he is attacked. It is a shame that he should have to defend himself.
How out of line with my thoughts of the Clintons that I would come to their defense, but reason demands it.
Posted by: Chuck | August 05, 2008 at 10:05 AM
Clinton has every right to be angry. I am still upset on how they both were treated. I am a whole-hearted democrat, union person and liberal. I lived thru the Clinton administration and he did alot for the blacks and the country. And now they want to say he is racist? So far I have not forgiven the democratic party, Obama, or the biased media for what they have done to Hillary and Bill. Nadar will probably get my vote. Obama has no depth. There is something in there, an instinct or a feeling, that I just can't trust Obama. I keep waiting for him to change my mind.
Posted by: Cindy | August 05, 2008 at 10:24 AM
Bill is not a "RACIST". Bill is Bill. he did what he had to do to make sure that Hillary Soprano lost to Obama. Bill we do what he has to do make sure that Obama loses to McCain.
You see Bill does not want to give up the title "KING OF THE DEMOC"RAT"IC PARTY.
VJ Machiavelli
http://www.vjmachiavelli.blogspot.com
ps "APPEASEMENT ONE", and "WITHDRAWAL TWO" the official airplanes of Obama and the Democ"rat"ic Party
Posted by: VJ Machiavelli | August 05, 2008 at 10:31 AM
I am an Obama supporter, and I have even got annoyed at President Clinton several times during the campaign.
Having said that, based on his record, it's not fair to characterize Clinton as a racist.
I think we need to let calmer heads prevail here.
As far as Clinton goes, it had to be personally devesating for him to see his wife lose a nomination that everybody predicted she would easily garner. Alas, what is predicted is not always what transpires.
For the sake of his legacy, for the sake of the future of the Democratic Party and our government, Clinton needs to lick his wounds and do what he can to prevent a McCain presidency.
I believe he will.
I also do not understand how some can't understand that this was a very personal loss for the man. Not being in his shoes, it is easy to cast aspersions upon him. We would all be better off to cut him some slack and mover forward.
Besides, who's to say, in an Obama presidency, Hillary Clinton would not become the next Chief Justice on the Supreme Court. THAT would be an amazing way to cap her career.
Posted by: scootmandubious | August 05, 2008 at 10:37 AM
Andy Malcom writes about the Clinrons AGAIN!. Big suprise.
Posted by: N.E. BodybutHillary | August 05, 2008 at 10:50 AM
Billy-Boy just CAN'T STAND BE IGNORED BY 'THE PRESS'! ! !. Of course he's a RACIST! ! ! He's been play the 'ole boy game' of PANDERING TO THE BALCKS FOR VOTES ever since I can remember! ! ! And he's VERY UPSET WITH MAIA ANGELOU who said that when she made her statement in 1994...it was only because she thought, that CLINTON, BEING A DEMOCRAT...would give MORE MONEY TO HER THATN THE REPUBLICANS! ! ! POOR BILLY-BOY...I can't remember the last time I saw him in a 'white church on Sundays...I guess he must now be setting a new 'talk show' with the Rev. Jeremiah Wright...one of his old crony councelors when Monica showed up with the 'BLUE DRESS'! ! ! The truth is that Hillary could possibly have made it it this guy wasn't SUCH A CLOWN! ! !
Posted by: margaret | August 05, 2008 at 10:53 AM
No president in history has done so much for the Black community... so don't be silly and call him racist.
This anti-Bill Clinton says when you play politics, it'll come back and bite you... this time it came back w/Obama's politics biting Clinton. I actually feel bad for him, but I guess what goes around comes around. Even the folks who worked for him (who doesn't like him now)... will say he is NOT racist... so don't be an Obama and say whatever you want to get the votes.
Posted by: Kim | August 05, 2008 at 10:53 AM
Bill Clinton is a has-been, a non factor, a failed leader just like his buddies George H.W. and George W.
Posted by: Chris | August 05, 2008 at 10:55 AM
No president in history has done so much for the Black community... so don't be silly and call him racist.
This anti-Bill Clinton says when you play politics, it'll come back and bite you... this time it came back w/Obama's politics biting Clinton. I actually feel bad for him, but I guess what goes around comes around. Even the folks who worked for him (who doesn't like him now)... will say he is NOT racist... so don't be an Obama and say whatever you want to get the votes.
Posted by: Kim | August 05, 2008 at 10:56 AM
The President and Senator have a lot of supporters.
Posted by: JP | August 05, 2008 at 11:01 AM
The true racist is Sen. Obama. He does not respect humanity diversity. Instead, he wants to make all variety of humanity one. Here is a quote from his Berlin speech I am talking about:
"The walls between races and tribes, natives and immigrants, Christians and Muslims and Jews cannot stand."
Posted by: John Smith | August 05, 2008 at 11:02 AM
Bill's been stepping up his drinking. Look at that nose.
.
Posted by: Josh Geller | August 05, 2008 at 11:05 AM
Obama this, Clinton that, McCain there.
Politicians Lie, some are just better at it than others.
As far as Former President Clinton and his statement about "I never had sex with that woman." He isn't the one that was legally lieing. The Special Prosecuter set the definition of "sex" for the terms of that questioning as "vaginal intercourse." President Clinton didn't set the stage, and even if the Senate impeached him (its called being indicted to the rest of us) he wasn't convicted. Why would a body of which 41% were lawyers not convict, because they understand legally he didn't lie about his answer to the prosecuter.
As far as playing the race card, Obama has done it since the days he started into politics in Chicago. He acts Black now, because he has decided he looks black. But he NEVER lived the life of a Black person in the US until he chose to do so for political reasons. And truthfully and LEGALLY he isn't BLACK, he is of MIXED RACIAL background. I can say I am German, because my family name came from German decent. But that doesn't make me German when both of my father's parents were of American Indian decent, my mother's family was from England and Scotland. It makes me a person of Mixed decent, just like about 90% of the people in this country. So if you want to say someone is a racist, tell the truth based upon actions and admit that Obama is. He is playing Black because it suits his present needs. If he wanted to be white again, he would use his mother's decent instead of his father's.
Posted by: Eb Jeb | August 05, 2008 at 11:07 AM
Why is it surprising to anyone that Bill ran smear ads against Barack Obama? Thanks what you're supposed to do in a political campaign. It's about the Democrats learned how to do that.
All I know is that when Bill was President - this country was THRIVING!
Posted by: Marcello Del Carlo | August 05, 2008 at 11:09 AM
Why would anyone NOT expect some sore spots to remain after such an abrasive campaign ? And, with Bill's record of unstinting support for African-American aspirations, who but a Clinton hater would accuse him of racism ? If he didn't feel disappointed at his wife's loss of the nomination the neocons would probably attack him for THAT too.
Posted by: Henry Landis | August 05, 2008 at 11:16 AM
chris, your logic defies logic.
Time to end the embarrassing travels of Barack Obama and hold a real vote at Denver so Hillary can be the nominee. The European trip was Barack Obama's waterloo.
Time for a Do over in Denver.
http://www.POSTCARD-BRIGADE.com
http://www.PROTEST-POSTCARDS.com
http://www.CAUCUSCHEATING.com
Posted by: Alessandro Machi | August 05, 2008 at 11:25 AM
He is angry. And he has every right to be. The ugly truth of this story is that it was the Obama campaign that sent out Press Releases creating this issue and started the fire. Their outrage created the Media response. Then once the fire started, acting as if they never did. Obama giving speeches on Hope while he plays dirty tricks. Just like an Addict who steals your money and then helps you look for it.
And the Media joined in 100% -- creating the perception that the Clintons played the race card (when it was Obama who made it an issue sending out Press Releases).
Granted, the Clintons (ungracefully - but truthfully) referred to historical events (Bill referred to Jesse Jackson's win, and Hillary referred to LBJ's role in the civil rights movement). But racist? This mixed Native American/Hispanic/Caucasian American from the Civil Rights south knows racism and it still exists deeply in this country -- but these were inconveniently worded remarks blown into a bomb, but not racist.
Get real. In NYC, it's an age old principle of politics that usually the one who starts accusing others of "racism" is the one playing the race card -- the one who smelt it dealt it!
Obama playing these dubious tactics while supported by the media is the hidden real story behind this campaign. He out-Clintoned the Clintons! This will be what the documentarys are about 20 years from now. (I will vote for him nonetheless, because I hope he is actually a Democrat.) But the 'damage' is done -- Bill was charged with, and prosecuted by the media -- of something that is simply false if you take an honest look at the facts.
So, I'd be angry too.
This "reporter" conveniently ignores that Clinton became upset because he was discussing being betrayed by an old friend -- Conyers -- and was visibly upset and hurt. Give me a break, only Jesus and Buddha and Ekhart Tolle don't get angry when they are treated this way.
But it makes for good copy. It was nice when Media tried to be objective.
Since the run up to the Iraq war, those days seem to be long over. Ever since the Clintons came to Washington, the Media has tried to bring them down. Then they pumped the Iraq War and War on Terror... and so now they pump Obama??
I'm afraid to dig deeper.
Posted by: Mel | August 05, 2008 at 11:42 AM
So why did he equate BO's success to that of J.Jackson
and why would he admit his racism any more than he
ever admitted his other shocking sins ? A classic case of
megalomania.
Posted by: Disbarred for purgery ? | August 05, 2008 at 03:10 PM
The day the Obama campaign called Bill Clinton a racist was when they lost me. I could never vote for Obama after that. They found out early that playing the race card worked, so they used it often. They are not getting away with it with John McCain.
Barack Obama is a lightweight who is not ready to be President. I hope the superdelegates are paying attention to how he is falling in the polls. He can't get traction no matter what he does, because people are finally starting to see that he is not THE ONE. Perhaps it's not too late. Nominate Hillary in Denver!!
PUMA!
TheDenverGroup.blogspot.com
Posted by: ccinatl | August 05, 2008 at 04:36 PM
Of course Bill is upset. Why shouldn't he be. For someone who is the least racist of any President ever to be tagged with that label by the media and Obamabots is inconceivable. Just one more reason why I, a lifelong Democrat, will vote for McCain in November. Obama and company need to "grow up" and behave as thought they might possibly have the knowledge and intentions to deserve the Presidency. ( Boy would that be a joke.)
Posted by: Lynn | August 05, 2008 at 04:54 PM
I can't wait until we get the real story from Bill about what happened in this election. Even his worst enemies admit he is not a racist (the 1st black pres). I think it was terrible what the Obama campaign did to him and Hillary (her MLK remark and his fairy tale remark). Even though the media knew these were not racist comments, the media still pushed the idea they were. Cnn and MSNBC pretty much spewed Obamas talking points daily. I was so happy to see McCain call Obama out on using the race card, they were starting to use the same strategy on him, painting him as a racist, in order to deflect Obamas real problems, lack of experience and policy knowledge. Good for Bill for standing up for himself, I wish he would have done it a long time ago. In their ignorance, The Obama supporters constantly tried to tell Hillary supporters they were racist, Most of them had not done their homework and did not realize Hillary was the true progressive with the experience, record, knowledge and ability to push her platform through. They are starting to see now however, what a fraud Obama is. No wonder the PUMA movement is growing.
Posted by: rrowing | August 05, 2008 at 06:58 PM
I think it is such a shame to call Bill Clinton a racist...Obama, his surrogates, and Obama-Media behaved absolutely disgraceful. The dem party big tops never said a word to defend the only dem president in 1/2 a century who served two terms in the White House. It's disgusting.
Obama and his band of mean-spirited villains knew that they needed to DESTROY Bill Clinton's relationship with black people, and oh yes, they did everything in their power to do so. I paid attention to the entire primary season very closely, and it is ATROCIOUS how the Obama camp treated Hillary and Bill.
I will never dare reward Obama's actions with a vote.
EVER.
Posted by: kat in your hat PUMA | August 05, 2008 at 08:55 PM
Talk about one-sided reporting. Why was Clinton in Liberia? He's on a trip designed to eliminate AIDS in Africa. That's a racist? Come on. After the way Bill has been treated, after the way every one who has the audacity to question Obama has been treated, I respect Bill even more for refusing to fawn over the selectee.
Posted by: Heather in Florida | August 06, 2008 at 06:44 AM
Disbarred for perjury -
Bill did not equate Obama's success with J. Jackson's, but he did note that J. Jackson won in S. Carolina, and he expected a tough fight for S. Carolina against Obama whose campaign manager is J Jackson Jr!!!! Get the facts before you draw conclusions.
Posted by: Heather in Florida | August 06, 2008 at 06:48 AM
Who is Bill Clinton?
Posted by: Apple | August 07, 2008 at 06:04 PM