| Main |

Hillary Clinton needs a history lesson

Hillary Clinton's exuberance about Ohio is perfectly understandable; her convincing win there on Tuesday propped her back on her feet in the hunt for the Democratic presidential nomination. Still, she's gotten a little carried away in touting the state's political importance.

In her victory speech in Columbus, she rightfully characterized it as "a bellwether state ... a battleground state." Then she sent us scurrying to the history books with this claim: "And no candidate in recent history, Democrat or Republican, has won the White House without winning the Ohio primary."

Well, it depends on what your definition of "recent history" is.

In Ohio's 1960 primary (Clinton was 12 at the time), the man who won the White House later that year, John Kennedy, took a pass on the contest. Instead, the Democratic delegates initially were pledged to a favorite son, then-Gov. Michael DiSalle.

Similarly, favorite sons in both the Democratic and Republican primaries won in 1964 and 1968 (a time line creeping ever closer to "recent history").

Since then, it appears Clinton was correct -- but in a very technical way. As Andrew Cayton, a history professor ...

at Miami University in Ohio, noted to the Washington Post, the state's primaries typically have been held at a point in the process where the likely nominee has surfaced in each party (and not so long ago, most expected that would be the case this year).

Clinton, in her round of stops today at the various morning news shows, continued to promote Ohio as having out-sized influence. "If you cannot win in Ohio, you cannot win the presidency," she said in one interview.

True enough for Republicans -- as virtually every political reporter knows by heart, since the GOP was founded in the 1850s, not one of its nominees has ever won the White House without carrying Ohio.

Among Democrats, however, Kennedy ended up taking the inaugural oath despite losing Ohio to Richard Nixon, and Franklin D. Roosevelt won his fourth -- and final term -- in 1944 despite losing the state to Thomas Dewey.

Those are the only two times since 1900 that Ohio found itself in the wrong column in a presidential race -- an impressive record, to be sure.

But the same could be said for Missouri, which over that time frame backed a presidential loser only in 1900 (opting for Democrat William Jennings Bryan instead of the Republican incumbent, William McKinley) and in 1956 (favoring Democrat Adlai Stevenson over another GOP incumbent, Dwight Eisenhower).

Spotlighting Missouri's prowess wouldn't serve Clinton's purposes, though, since Barack Obama narrowly won its primary on Feb. 5.

Enough with Ohio, anyway; soon we'll be hearing how Pennsylvania is renowned for its sagacity.

-- Don Frederick

 

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c630a53ef00e550b125d78834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Hillary Clinton needs a history lesson:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

You guys do not give Hillary a break. Your biased reporting is now boring and not useful.


(How many times we got to say this? This isn't always reporting. It's a blog. We mix up a lot of things. So don't look for objectivity here.)

I Can not support a candidate that.

1. Touts gender as a factor.
2. Is under investigation for illegal campaing finances: Paul vs Clinton
3. Supported Goldwater.
4. Involved in Whitewater controversy.
5. Claims vast right wing conspiracies.
6. Wont release their tax returns.
7. Was for NAFTA before they were against it.
8. Mandates Health Care and fines those who cant afford it.
9. Uses Republican tactics and then complains about so called tactics.
10. Has a split personality and is nothing more than a Machiavellian!
11. Did not read the intelligence reports and then authorized the war
12: WALMART where she was nothing but UNION BUSTING CORP. LEGAL W**rE!
(too many more to continue…)

Way back when--I'm talking four months ago--I would've been perfectly happy with Obama, Clinton, or Edwards as the nominee. But Obama was choice #1. At this point, I despise Hillary Clinton. She is selfish and short-sighted. She has no morals to speak of.

Post a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In







Follow us on ... »

Follow @latimestot for political news and backgrounders sent direct to your Twitter page or mobile device.
Our Bloggers

Andrew MalcolmAndrew Malcolm's immigrant parents repeatedly stressed the importance of active participation in a democracy. Early lessons included learning the alphabetical list of states by watching televised roll calls of national political conventions. That childhood exposure led to a lifelong fascination with politics, including 40-plus years of covering them and a brief stint practicing them as press secretary to Laura Bush in 1999-2000. A veteran foreign and national correspondent, Malcolm served on the Times Editorial Board and was a Pulitzer finalist in 2004. He is the author of 10 nonfiction books and father of four.

Johanna NeumanJohanna Neuman is a veteran Washington correspondent for both The Los Angeles Times and USA Today, having covered presidents and politics as far back as Ronald Reagan. A former president of the White House Correspondents Assn., she authored a book on media and foreign policy, “Lights, Camera, Wars.” Most recently she was co-author of the Countdown to Crawford blog here at The Times.
The daily destination for breaking news from The Times and other top political sources on the Web.
Political blog from the Chicago Tribune.

All L.A. Times Blogs

All The Rage
American Idol Tracker
Angels Unplugged
Babylon & Beyond
Big Picture
Booster Shots
California Consumer
Comments Blog
Company Town
Culture Monster
Daily Dish
Daily Mirror
Daily Travel & Deal Blog
Dish Rag
Dodger Thoughts
Fabulous Forum
Gold Derby
Greenspace
Hero Complex
Homicide Report
Jacket Copy
L.A. at Home
L.A. Land
L.A. Now
L.A. Unleashed
La Plaza
Lakers
Money & Co.
Movable Buffet
Opinion L.A.
Outposts
Pop & Hiss
Readers' Representative Journal
Show Tracker
Technology
Ticket to Vancouver
Top of the Ticket
Up to Speed
Varsity Times Insider
Categories