PETA to USA Network: don't air Westminster!

We told you last month about the BBC's announcement that it won't air the Crufts Dog Show (the UK's answer to Westminster), citing concerns raised by a BBC documentary, "Pedigree Dogs Exposed," over the health of dogs bred for the show ring.  The BBC reported:

The programme...says dogs suffering from genetic illness are not prevented from competing in dog shows and have gone on to win "best in breed," despite their poor health.

It says physical traits required by the Kennel Club's breed standards, such as short faces, wrinkling, screw-tails and dwarfism, have inherent health problems.

Other problems occur because of exaggerations bred into dogs by breeders trying to win rosettes, it adds.

Now PETA is asking the USA Network, which airs the Westminster show every February, to follow suit.  In a letter to USA's president Bonnie Hammer, PETA founder and president Ingrid Newkirk writes, "Since dog breeders routinely use incestuous inbreeding and genetic manipulation...it's not surprising that as many as one in four purebred dogs is plagued with a serious genetic problem." 

Beagles like last year's Westminster winner, Uno, are susceptible to a wide variety of genetic health problems like hypothyroidism, epilepsy and demodectic mange, according to PETA.

"Countless dogs suffer painful cosmetic surgeries and millions of wonderful dogs die in animal shelters because of the AKC's inhumane policies...USA Network can take a stand against the cruel treatment of animals simply by denying air time to the Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show," said PETA Vice President Daphna Nachminovitch.  And PETA blogger Amy Elizabeth chimes in:

So USA, how about being a good network? Sit. Listen. Roll over. And fetch a few reruns of Law and Order to replace that dastardly dog show…

What do you think -- is PETA right on or out of line?  Will you be watching Westminster this year?  Let us know in the comments.

-- Lindsay Barnett

Photo: Uno, a 15-inch beagle, won Best in Show at the 132nd Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show last year.  Seth Wenig/Associated Press.

Comments

[Ellen Perlson]

Peta LOVES to spread completly untrue lies about responsible breeding. I breed and show champion showdogs. This year marks my third generation and fourth time to show in westminster. The dogs I breed go to loving homes. They are raised with complete love and attention and I do all the genetic testing to breed healthy animals. My puppies are NOT in shelters. the same is true for so many responsible show dog breeders in all breeds. The dogs that are at westminster are completly loved animals tjhat certainly eat alot better than most peta people. My showdogs sleep in my bedroom in my bed. I wish the AR folks could just see the difference. You are going after the wrong group of people. Leave the dedicated hobby breeders alone. They deserve a hearty thank you not a boycott of a sport that millions of people enjoy watching.
STOP SPREADING LIES!!!!!!

[Madeline Cohen]

I'm a labour and delivery nurse and a dog breeder and I will tell you that at least in controlled animal breeding good breeders use genetic manipulation to produce the best, healthiest dog possible for loving families. Yes some breeds have gone off the deep end, but not most. The KC's need to step in and review breed standards and put a stop to surgical art forms in purebred dogs. They also need to raise $ to fund research so that good breeders have more tools and tests to work with in breeding the wonderful dogs that have been at man's side since the beginning of time.

As for humans, well they just breed indiscriminately and apparently don't think twice about contributing their own genetic junk to the human gene pool. Ask me, I work with the deformed and sick results every day. Children who are the offspring of people with mild to debilitating genetic conditions who intentionally 'roll the dice' and don't lose any sleep over it for the most part because, well, there's health insurance to take care of it, right?

[Deanna]

It’s unbelievable that groups like PETA who only have a personal agenda are allowed to spread lies like they do. “One in four purebred dogs have genetic problems”, where do they get off telling lies like that. The fact is that dog you see in an AKC show is there because they are the best of the best.
Legitimate dog breeders go through many test to make sure that all sires and dams being breed are of the highest quality. Purebred dogs are tested for hip dysphasia, genetic eye problems, and other genetic problems before they are ever bred.
The fact that our animal shelters are over crowded and there are unwanted dogs in this country is due to the backyard breeder and the puppy mills that only care about making a buck and produce the worst of the worst.
Spend some time on an AKC or UKC website. There are instructions given to each perspective new puppy home on questions they should ask a breeder before you get a new puppy. Education is what we all need not the ignorance that PETA spews. The general public needs to be informed and ask questions and quit being a instant gratification society.
Impulse buying is the reason or shelters are so full not the AKC or any dog show you might see on TV.

[Valerie Weston]

I find it very offensive that your news paper chose to use a picture of a FABULIS HEALTHY dog who is just shaking his head as all dogs do, this picture was made to look like there is somthing wrong with this dog, I think there somthing wrong here all right and it"s not with the dog but with the editor.

[CES]

Ingrid Newkirk's letter is full of out right lies, half truths and exaggerations. I will not buy into her dribble. PETA is trying to take away our rights to own pets. I for one will be front and center watching USA's coverage of Westminster! Keep up the coverage Ms. Hammer!!

I'm in favor of buying dogs from breeders AND I'm in favor of adopting from shelters. Neither option takes away from the other. Shelter dogs are being put there by irresponsible pet owners, not because breeders are producing puppies.

Have any of you that want breeders to stop breeding ever considered that if there were no purebred dogs there would be no mixed breeds? If all breeding stops, where will your next pet come from? If you stop breeding, dogs (and cats) will cease to exist.

I personally can't imagine a world without dogs and cats.

[Judy Warling]

The show on the Westminster Dog show has also done a lot of good as it also promotes dogs in shelters, service dogs, and other venues of the dog world. What PETA does not understand they want to get rid of or try to twist to their way of thinking. GOOD BREEDERS try to improve on each breeding they do. Line breeding is not a bad thing if the breeder has a good background. Most of the bad health come from the back yard breeders or puppy mills that are only in it for the money.
Most GOOD BREEDERS rarely make money on a litter of puppies.
If you look at all the expenses a GOOD BREEDER goes through to welp and raise a litter of puppies they are lucky if they make any money at all.
Peta should look in its own back yard before they say anything. I had some one from PETA come to one show and try to but Anti-Freeze in my dogs water. That's really ethical treatment for animals, isn't it

[Michele Kasten]

So far we've only heard from owners of dogs, now lets's hear from the dog!

My boy is ABSOLUTELY CRAZY when I start packing for a dog show. If I get out his airplane carrier he HAS to sit in it and I have to take him for a walk or ride in the car. HE LOVES TO SHOW, SHOW OFF AND TRAVEL! If this is abuse then I hope ALL dogs are abused this way!

He is in superb condition, both genetically, physically and mentally. If he were deficient in any of these he would not show at all and would not enjoy it.

How many of these pro-PETA folks spend as much time with their dogs, (if they even have any,) as we show breeders and exhibitors do?

I qualified for Westminster this year and I will be there and I certainly hope that USA airs the show, all dog lovers deserve it.

[Don]

PETA's ultimate goal is to see the banning of ALL domestic pets- so all you people going on about shelter dogs- and adopting from a shelter- if PETA gets its way, then eventually, there will be NO dogs, no cats, no hamsters, no birds, no.... no PETS of any kind, allowed. Period. Get a grip on reality.
The reason there are so many dogs in shelters is because there are so many irresponsible OWNERS who don't (or won't) take responsibility for the appropriate training and care of their pets. (kinda like how people don't take responsibility for the appropriate raising of their kids). Go after the irresponsible OWNERS.

[Susan]

For anyone who still isn't convinced about the true agenda of the the PETA-people, here is the latest state bill they're behind which would provide for seizure and destruction of all "pitt bulls" (Rufus -- don't visit Montana!!).

from the AKC website: "Alert - Montana Bill Will Seek to Ban and Euthanize Some Terriers!

[Tuesday, January 06, 2009]
The American Kennel Club’s Government Relations Department is expecting legislation in Montana that will seek to prohibit the ownership, harboring, or keeping of dogs described as "pit bulls." The legislation defines "pit bulls" to include Staffordshire Bull Terriers, American Staffordshire Terriers, and "any dog that has the physical characteristics that substantially conform to the standards established for those breeds by the American Kennel Club." If the bill is passed and signed into law, all such dogs would be seized and euthanized. ...."

[Shelly]

What does airing a purebred dog show have anything to do with cross bred dogs in animal shelters? All the cross bred dogs in animal shelters are not there because of responsible purebred breeders. Why should good responsible breeders have to take all the slack because of a bunch of irresponsible dog owners! Air the dam dog show and let us all enjoy watching it. Those dogs are well bred, well loved and treated far better than many children are in the USA. Drop all the Peta crap and and find something more useful to talk about and do a segment on, like child abuse, or starvation and abuse in 3rd worlds countries! Now there's a thought!

[Susanne]

I see PETA as the most preposterous group of people who’s assumptions on the way dogs and cats should or shouldn’t live in this country. Don’t forget that this is a D%*M FREE country. They advertise to collect people money to help save the animals. Since they are the one who are killing them left and right. Like one said: Better dead then fed. YEAH, I say they are saving them.
PETA needs not to point fingers at the American Kennel Club. The AKC is a registry of purebred dogs, beside AKC is losing money because of all the animals be registered with bogus kennel clubs, which by the way is a spam registry. They don’t even ask to see a pedigree to registry. AKC have no control over the people who breed them, only if they have violated rules and regulations in breeding, then they will loss all rights with AKC, where do these people go to register their dogs, no other than the bogus kennel clubs, such as C K C
But I think PETA is trying to target the public not watch the show so that the public won’t buy from breeders who breed just because the new FAD is in. I bet people were flying out of their house just to go buy a Beagle, because of Uno winning last year, just like when Kirby won in 98. I am a long time supporter of the SPORT Purebred dogs. I support my local club and my parent club. I have conformation, obedience, therapy and performance dogs. I support the OFA health testing,( not just a vet okayed), in ALL breeding dogs and cats before breeding. No animal should be breed before 2 years old.
There are three types of Breeders: The Puppy Mills, who produce in quality not quantity and sell to pet stores, dealers and wholesalers. No health testing on animals, no guarantees. Backyard Breeders, (BYB), the occasionally breeder who just have two unaltered dogs in there backyard or opps breedings, they do no health testing on animals, and no guarantees. And there is the Ethical Breeder, who is considered the serious breeder and for the betterment of the breed. They do health testing, want to know you and your family, keep in contact, have guarantees, return policies and normally have contracts. PETA needs to get a grip and needs to slow down. The people they need to target are the Puppy Millers by pushing more laws to limit how many breeding animals they should have, licenses too bred and license on each animal bred, mandated inspections, proper paper work on every animal. This will cut down a lot to Puppy Millers and BYBer’s. Remember the Ethical Breeder take back what they produce. The dogs that end up in the shelters and the streets, which are causing the overpopulation, are from the Puppy Millers, Careless Owners and BYBer’s. The public doesn’t do their research on what breed is best from them and their family and the lack of understanding and training the breed and the dog in general. Owning a pet is a huge responsible just like a child, you have to feed, water, shelter, love and care for these animals. Beside to get what you pay. I rather be on a waiting list to know that I’m getting a much better quality animal than an shoot crap animal. If you can’t afford a well-bred animal, sorry you don’t deserve owning a dog or cat. Besides what makes you think you will be able to pay for the vet bills after buying a Puppy Mill puppy or a Backyard Breeders? YES, 90 percent of all puppies in that window are from BYBer’s and Puppy Mills.

[LCE]

Perhaps one should give up on watching the Kentucky Derby- after all fine Thoroughbred bloodstock is based on generations of line breeding, perhaps we should stop having ANYTHING to do with cows since beef stock is also based on even tighter line breeding than dogs or horses, maybe we should ban all references to royalty since that too is based on many generations of line breeding.

People CHOOSE to watch these events, people CHOOSE to wear leather and eat beef, people CHOOSE whom they marry- perhaps freedom to CHOOSE to turn the dial is a more fair way to allow people to CHOOSE what they see rather than dictating to them what they can or cannot see.

LCE

[chris]

As to England being progressive and the USA resisting this, take note that England allows SHIARA LAW which takes the rights of women away. No one can tell me any Muslim woman can have any rights when they are downtrodden and England is so progressive that they allow Shiara courts. They say the woman can choose but you tell me what oppressed woman has a choice.
What about the designer dogs - doodle this and doole that. Those breeder get big $$ and don't do any testing. Any AKC purebred has a standard that demands testing and breeding only stock that is free of defects. We want heathly dogs!!!!!! If you take away the purebreds, you get mutts that you will never know what you are up against with regards to health and temperment.

[Tamzin]

Open your eyes and see PETA for what they really are.
Terrorists.
Don't be snowed by their lies.
Lies
Lies
Lies
Lies
Lies
Lies
All they do is lie.
They don't care about dogs, cats, chickens. horses, cows, pigs, goats ... they want them DEAD so you can't own them.

Ethical breeders do NOT cause shelter population probelms ... the ignorant public does by believing PETA's lies. Ethical breeders(WKC exhibitors) have a market for their dogs ... those dogs do NOT end up in shelters!

What do you think will happen if there are no more shelter dogs(because they all get sterlized)? One generation and voila ... no more pets.

Shelter dogs are primarily backyard bred MUTTS. abandoned by ignorant, uninformed, materialistic, instant gratification, pet shop buyers. Why are you attacking ethical breeders? It's totally nonsensical.

Open your eyes.
Is the USA Network controlled by TERRORISTS?
Is the LA Times controlled by TERRORISTS?
Next we'll have HSUS requesting WKC not be aired ... I won't faint if that happens ... they are just as evil as PETA.

[PETA Sucks]

I'm terribly sorry but when it comes to PETA I cannot think of anything intelligent to say. I think the fact they they do indeed "Suck" days it all.

[JacquelineG]

I cannot believe the ignorant people commenting here. If you knew what PETA stood for and what PETA was all about you would not be making the comments that you are. In PETA's eyes if you take medication (which has come from animal testing) you are wrong, if you own a pet of any kind you are wrong. They are for total animal liberation. Basically letting animals be able to run free, fight, starve, and die. PETA's head quarters kills over 93% of what animal they take in. They have lied to numerous shelters and then killed the animals PETA said they would help the same day they arrive from a shelter. They fund terrorism (a bomber). Ingrid Newkirk has been quoted to say that she does not feel for animals. Do your homework before you back something up. Until then I will be watching the dog show.

[Eileen Gust]

Well wow IGNORANCE it happens everyday around you. #1 people breathe in thier surroundings like a cold. Even if it is toxic they believe it. PETA is NOT for you they are against every domesticated dog & cat out there. They want you to euthenize all animals & they do not want any more on this earth that is there goal. WAKE up people.
Go face to face witht he president of PETA & HSUS (humane society of the united states) All they want is your money to put demesticated animals all down because they (he) thinks that there shoudl nto be any. HE believes it is wrong dirty & disgusting. So when you breathe in these toxins remember you were ignorant enough to belive them blame yourself not others.
USA run Westminister show the good stuff show the non-ignorant people it would be about time you did. They are the ones fighting for the REAL animal rights. Why would you not run the show? You run every other smut show & life movie that is full of toxic ignorance.
I prefer to be one of the people who support good breeding. people wake up. smell the toxic waste around you & move out if it before it is too late.

[Beth]

PETA is absolutely ludicrous in the incorrect information they spread and in trying to eliminate the airing of Westminster! Westminster is an enjoyable and educational show. The breeders who produce the 'best of the best' showcased at Westminster dedicate their lives and finances to producing happy, healthy dogs for specific purposes (hunting, tracking, herding, etc) just as our ancesters did. They and the Kennel Clubs that they are members of donate hundreds of thousands of dollars each year to research into illnesses and medical conditions that dogs can suffer, in hopes that these can be erradicated thru careful breeding practices. They ensure as much as is humanly possible, that any dogs with genetic problems, never reproduce. The puppies that they produce are carefully placed in loving homes that must pass screenings that often equal those of human adoptions. Puppies are placed on spay/neuter contracts (wonder if PETA feels those are barberic surgeries) to family's who are looking for a good companion and VERY few people prove responsible enough for a show breeder to allow them to have control of an intact puppy. These are NOT the dogs that end up in shelters or produce puppies who end up in shelters. These breeders spend endless hours educating the public on characteristics of specific types of dogs to make sure that the type is a good fit for a family's needs along with educating the public on responsible ownership, training, etc. When a dog passes on, they cry and moarn their passing along with the families that loved and cared for them. Millions of families and individuals eagerly watch Westminster each year. How many children (young and old) didn't cheer for Uno while they were thinking of Snoopy? Yes, I will watch Westminster again this year as I have done every year that it's been aired, unless I was there in person. If USA succumbs to PETA's strong arm tactices, I will watch Westminster and other AKC dog competitions on any channel that pick them up! Now I'm going to get my mistreated show dogs off my couch so that we can go for a walk in the park together... I hope that all the animal lovers out there who are being mislead by PETA and other animal rights organizations will take a long look at the facts.

[Michelle]

PETA and those involved with PETA are INSANE and anyone who does not realize this needs a good shrink

[Lori]

Lets face it, todays generation is the 'throw away gen'
people are not responsible as they once were. People buy and aquire things on a whim. When you get a dog you are supposed to care for that dog for it's entire life., not toss it away because you find you don't have the time...it's not the people producing the dogs that are the problem.......its our totally irresponsible ways of thinking today.....it's far too easy to dump a pet......that is why our shelters are so full. I'ts the general public that purchases these animals not giving consideration to taking responsiblity for that dogs entire life......peta you are down right dangerous, and transparent putting blame on the wrong people.........if people were responsible there woudl be hardly any shelter dogs!

[JacquelineG]

Are you kidding people? This letter is the one your backing. If this was the case no would have any pet. EVERY species including humans have some sort of health problems associated wuth them as they get older including mutt (your precious shelter dogs). Here is a letter that was written to the USA Network from PETA.
"December 26, 2008
Bonnie Hammer, President
USA Network
2 pages via fax
Dear Ms. Hammer:
We hope this letter finds you well. On behalf of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals and our more than 2 million members and supporters, I am writing in the hope that you will meet with us briefly regarding an urgent matter: the USA Network’s February airing of the controversial Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show. As you may know, the British Broadcasting Company (BBC) has just announced that it will no longer televise Britain’s Crufts dog show, based on the British Kennel Club’s refusal to exclude from the dog show’s main competitions at least 12 breeds—including the basset hound, the mastiff, the Rottweiler, and the German shepherd—classified as “at risk” (by the Kennel Club itself) for dangerous, often painful physical conditions attributed to overbreeding, as well as the intentional breeding of these dogs purely for looks versus temperament and good health. The British Kennel Club has now pledged to review and revise breeding standards for more than 200 breeds in the U.K. and has already informed Pekingese breeders that it is no longer acceptable to breed dogs with flat faces,as this intentionally bred-in trait causes many dogs to suffer breathing distress and difficulties that can even be fatal. The British Kennel Club’s American counterpart, the American Kennel Club (AKC), has done nothing to help reduce the physical problems that plague “purebreds,” despite the American Veterinary Medical Association’s (AVMA) public release of its new policy against cropping the ears and docking the tails of dogs for cosmetic purposes. The AVMA specifically encourages altering breed standards to eliminate these two now-common practices, citing the pain, blood loss, and infection that these surgical mutilations commonly cause dogs to endure. Since dog breeders routinely use incestuous inbreeding and genetic manipulation to achieve a certain “desired” trait like a slanted back or a concertina face, it’s not surprising that as many as one in four purebred dogs is plagued with a serious genetic problem. Beagles like Uno, last year’s winner of the AKC’s “Best in Show” category, have a significantly higher risk of hypothyroidism, demodectic mange (a condition that occurs when a dog’s immune system cannot combat the proliferation of mites living in the dog’s hair follicles), epilepsy, and hip dysplasia. Poodles, like contestants Vikki and Remmy, who were just edged out by Uno in the competition, are prone to cataracts, progressive retinal atrophy, allergies, and ear infections; Labrador retrievers—America’s most popular dog—are prone to bone disease, hemophilia, and retinal degeneration; Dalmatians are often deaf; and Great Danes are bred to be so large that their hearts give out early. The list goes on and on, and all the problems stem from deliberate genetic manipulation. You can join the BBC in sending the message that manipulating dogs in order to create a look that negatively affects their health, temperament, and quality of life is unacceptable. I would be glad to meet with you. We hope to inform our members that you will decide not to televise Westminster’s annual dog show. Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Daphna Nachminovitch, Vice President
Cruelty Investigations Department"

[Bruce]

Does anyone notice a distinct difference between the ranting, uninformed, inexperienced, irrational opinions of the PETA supporters versus the calm, explanatory, educated, rational supporters of the responsible breeding of purebreds. There is no reasoning with these zealots, as the overwhelming majority of them are followers with not an original thought in their heads. Unfortunately, they can't be mearly swatted away. It is important to be vigilant of their goings on because there ARE some smart, although misdirected, people at the top of the PETA echelon and, if nothing else, they are diligent in their pursuits of controlling other's lives... Big Brother of one of the worst kind. People need to pay attention to legislation in their states in regard to any domesticated animals, not just dogs and cats. Very insidious stuff going on. Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness... oh, and then there's PETA.
Bruce

[Marie Richmond]

So the USA has the same problem as us over here, ours is the RSPCA, which banned hunting with dogs in the UK. Now they want dogs bred FIT FOR PURPOSE, hello! We can't test our dogs against any prey, talk about having your cake and eating it. if you're out walking your dog in the woods and it chases a squirrel, hope to god nobody see's it you could end up with a criminal record. For the last 23years I have owned Pharaoh Hounds, some say they've been about for 7 millennia others say 800 years, I've had no health problems and they've all live to ripe old ages. Heres the rub they've been isolated on Malta and Gozo, tiny islands in the Mediterainian for those 800 years, so that's a lot of "in breeding" The Breed has not changed since they left Egypt. Only the best hunters are kept on Malta and Gozo, so not all pedigree dogs are criples. If you have a family tree, which after all is only a list of those who went before you, are you then inbred because that's all a pedigree is a list of ancesters. Keep fighting these idiots, the RSPCA is out of control. Political but caring for animals they've lost their way.

[Shirley Newby-Tate]

I can not believe that you would want to have the Westministher Dog show cancelled on TV. There are so many good breeders who carefully screen their dogs for all known genetic problems before they are even bred. They pour their hearts & souls into their dogs and their new puppies carefully screening homes so that the puppies are placed in loving caring forever homes to make sure that they are not dumped at shelters across the country. Any breeder with a grain of salt will take back their dogs for any reason the people could not keep them they are not dumped in Shelters like Peta wishes you to believe. Peta only wants to see that dogs are totally eliminated from our lives and to be wild. We as breeders have a right to see our sport on tv the same as the horse set loves to watch thier horses and riders do their thing. I am sure Peta will want to stop anything to do with animals. Please please do not fall for Peta's scare tactics they are the bad guy not the good breeders of the world. And there are good breeders. Believe me being a 3rd generation dog show home I know how well our dogs are cared for they want for nothing and they are lavished with attention by owners and us alike. We have a right to see our sport televised the same as hockey is telievised and why then not stop showing all sporting events if you cancel Westminister. Wonder how well that would go down you would be bankrupt in no time with no one watching your airwaves.

Lets do away with the puppy mills where you don't get a history of your dogs background you wil however get a history from good breeders like myself who cares 24/7 through out the whole year they are never neglected nor are they ever to run loose so that harm could come to them. We are always with our dogs to make sure they are heappy and healthy.

We want Westminister. Please thing carefully about this. Beyond a shadow of doubt we love our animals as much as they can be loved an they return it ten fold. So lets sit down in February and maybe have a few breeders showcased so we can prove to the world that the creme de le creme has risen to the top and they will hold our interest throuh two nights of Westminsiter. Don't be a follower and go the way of the BBC. STand up and take a stand and show to Peta that we are not going to roll over and play dead. Breeders are as mad as hell and we are not going to take it anymore.. Just like in the movie we will stand up for our dogs our family as our dogs are familly first , showdogs second and if and that is a big if they are good enough and have had all their genetic testing resulting in clear dogs , will they ever be bred. Not all showdogs are bred. People are out there just to have fun with their dogs and if you don't believe me you should be at my house when I am heading off to a show and leaving one or two left at home and they are raring to go to the shows as they loved it too. They see the crates go in to the van and they all want to go no mattter where it is but they all loved showing. So I am hoping that I will be watching Westminishter this FEbruaty because your stations can also stand up to Peta too. And let the chips fall where they lay. But I know I will be happy to be watching WEstminister this February!

Yours in dogs
Shirley Newby-Tate

[Bianca]

"As long as 3 to 4 million perfectly wonderful animals are being euthanized in our shelters year after year for lack of good homes, there is no excuse for breeding more animals."

I have a rescued poodle and a poodle from an excellent breeder. I love both my dogs, but there is no comparison. The rescue probably came from a puppy mill. The dog that came from a highly-regarded breeder is smarter, has much better conformation, a lovely gait, and is a much better example of its breed. The dogs that end up in shelters are NOT coming from the reputable breeders who do the health and genetic testing needed to ensure quality dogs. Let's support the knowledgeable breeders and the buyers of those quality dogs, instead of trying to give preference to the unfortunate mixed-breeds with unknown health and behavioral problems that end up in shelters.

I love Westminster and Crufts because those shows illustrate to the public what the best examples of the breeds should be. It's baloney that they have "genetic health conditions." These well-bred, beautifully raised and trained dogs are the cream of the crop. I will be petitioning USA to keep this show, and will write BBC to urge that the re-instate the Crufts show.

[Susan Burnett]

Please!
PETA is not about pet protection!
Responsible pure breed dog breeders are NOT loading up the cages at the Humane Society. We have a segment of our society that are irresponsible in all they do, including the care and production of their own families. Please let us protect responsible pet owners
and breeders who celebrate the health and beauty of the wonderful and well cared for dogs at Westminster.
PETA needs to be exposed by the LA Times for what it really is........A group of fanatical anti pet people who are willing to spread untruths for their own gain.
Step up LA TIMES. It might increase your numbers!
The truth is always more enjoyable to read and support!

[Chariity]

Responsible breeders do not CHURN out dogs and they do everything possible to screen for genetic issues. As it was stated in the post that if breeders did not selectively breed that there would be no domestic dogs, you have hit at the heart of what PETA wants, NO DOMESTIC ANIMALS WHATSOEVER! Responsible breeders even take back dogs that cannot be kept or develop health issues (in fact they ususally DEMAND this condition in the contract that they make with people who they sell the dogs do). People have the right to purchase from a breeder or to adopt as they choose. I am not against mixed breeds, however 95% of the time mixed breeds are the result of accidental breeding or someone who thinks that if they just breed a litter of puppies (who cares what they are) they will make $. People who go to shows like Westminster and participate in other AKC (and other dog association) activities usually lost tons of money on what they do. The only reason they (we) do it is that they are interested in the preservation and well being of their dogs for future generations.

[Michelle]

In response to Eric: "Breeders need to know their place and stop ruining the adoption chances of the 4 million unadopted cats and dogs who have to be killed in U.S. animal shelters every year. They urge people to BUY dogs that are breed on purpose instead of urging people to go out and adopt a dog that has their life depending on being adopted. Thumbs down to Westminster. Two thumbs up to PETA. Will definetly be boycotting the show on the USA Network this year."

Have you ever stopped to consider that a shelter dog may not be for everyone?? Responsible breeders breed for health and temperament #1. I am not going to trust a typical middle aged Shepherd mix from a shelter with my small children. Sorry. If I am going to the grocery store to buy vegetables, I am not going to come home with twinkies instead.

Just because there are lots of starving, dying children in Africa, doesn't mean everyone should stop having children. Responsible breeders are not to blame for animals ending up in shelters, certainly Westminster is not.

Yes, I will be watching Westminster, and I am disgusted by the LA Times for this article, especially the picture of Uno. We all know he's a gorgeous, healthy, happy Beagle. Some photographers are just money hungry to go and sell a picture like this to help PETA and their BS.

[Deb E]

In Massachusetts the shelters actually have gone to Puerto Rico to import dogs because there are so few dogs turned in. Guess some places aren't euthanising millions of animals.
PETA directly, clearly, simply, kills animals turned over to it.
WKC & the AKC devote money & time to health, rescue & proper breeding & placement of dogs. Purebred dog owners & breeders work on health & rescue.
I wonder who truly has the welfare of dogs at heart?

[Kelly]

As long as there are 'throw away' dogs in shelters the promotion of purebred dogs should cease. If this includes stopping the Westmister show from being aired, then let it be dropped from the TV lineup. It is downright irrepsonsible to keep breedings dogs when so many lovely dogs are killed each year. The current overpopulation of dogs is a worldwide travesty. It is not their fault. They are all the innocent victims of people's greed.

[Jacqueline]

Whether Westminister Dog Show is aired or not will not make the difference for the millions of dogs in shelters to find a home.
Why are the general public NOT going to shelters to purchase and save the shelter dogs ?
Why do the general public go to puppy mills to purchase many "purebred" dogs ?

The breeders do not make people buy their beautiful purebred dogs, the shelter dogs are just as beautiful and cost less and are often spayed and neutered and have had their vaccinations.
Its lack of knowledge and education on the general publics part.
A reputable breeder's permises are clean with no smell, the dogs are friendly and well groomed and buyers can meet the mother and other related dogs. Often the sire of the pups is not on the premises because breeders seek out the best stud dogs for their puppies.
Puppy mills are often dirty and smelly and the dogs are not well groomed. Too often the parents and related dogs cannot be seen. The puppies are shy and frightened all things that should send a red flag up to the potential buyer NOT to buy.
Pet shops encourage impulse buying and reputable breeders never sell to pet shops. Most of these puppies come from puppy mills.

I look forward to watching the Westminister Show but also hope they do a segment on shelter dogs and the plight of dogs in pet shops & puppy mills.

[L. Landis]

"Does anyone even listen to PETA anymore after watching the videos of them kill healthy animals in a van? Why don't you show a picture of that instead of a weird picture of this pretty beagle? Your personal agenda is showing and it's not pretty.

Yes unfortunately the 'masses' listen quite well to PETA and to H$U$...Why? Because MONEY TALKS. These two organizations are not stupid, they put their MONEY where they need to in order to get the biggest reaction and MORE MONEY. They put it into Hollywood and OPRAH. And if they fool them (and they have), then more fools jump on board. It's rare for them to make a public appearance or statement without doing it in High Profile. No PETA and H$U$ are not stupid, in face H$U$ is perhaps the 3rd or 4th richest corporation in existence, seems to me I read that just last week in some article.

But if sheep want to follow, then market to sheep. This is exactly what they have done, by taking their message to Hollywood.

I will not deny that there is the occasional good deed here, but if you just bother to read their charter, or financials which are public, you better be in for a good cry. And Ingrid? I'm sorry, but can we just say the word COMMITTED has more than one meaning? She may BE committed, however she needs to BE COMMITTED!

[KETKA]

I'm sorry the unknowing, uneducated public is falling for the PETA and HSUS agenda. I'm probably going to to say the same as many others have said already.

PETA and the HSUS are organizations that feel animal ownership should be outlawed. They're idea of a *good pet* is none at all. Their agenda is to rid the world of human *domination* over animals.... ALL animals.

Now let's give that fact alone a long thought. Do you eat meat? Fish? Fowl? Eggs? Milk? If you are a 100% vegetarian this is for you! Personally, I enjoy a nice meal out at the local burger joint. And that is just on the food front. What about conservation? Endangered species? If you think long and hard the list could go on forever.

To remove Westminster from the Networks would be absurd. If it is removed then I should say that boxing and other *extreme* sports be removed!! They're horrible, violent, even bloody at times!!

No dogs.... no boxing!
No football! No wrestling!

PETA founder and president Ingrid Newkirk writes, "Since dog breeders routinely use incestuous inbreeding and genetic manipulation...it's not surprising that as many as one in four purebred dogs is plagued with a serious genetic problem."

Not true.

A QUALITY breeder is very up-to-date on genetic problems facing their breed. They test for some and have to work around others and still maintain the quality (type) and temperament for their breed. Do you really think that we could afford one out of every four pups to be *seriously defective*?? Now how would that play out with my puppy buyers?

*Genetic manipulation*.... study cattle. Go to a topnotch dairy farm and study their pedigrees. Dairymen cannot afford poor quality, poor milk/meat producing herds. It's quite clear that the PETA folks have no idea what they are talking about. Without the proper education on genetics one can see how they are able to successfully push their agenda on the unsuspecting public.

"Countless dogs suffer painful cosmetic surgeries and millions of wonderful dogs die in animal shelters because of the AKC's inhumane policies" said PETA Vice President Daphna Nachminovitch.

"HUH??" Is this person actually saying that sow dogs are cosmetically altered? Wrong again PETA.

Yes, millions of dogs are euthanized in shelters annually. It's also true that PETAs own small shelter euthanizes close to 100% of their dogs and cats annually. Remember the PETA employee dumping dead dogs and cats in a public area??

And, by the way, AKC has NOTHING to do with the care or breeding of dogs. They are simply a registering body. The concerned fanciers urged AKC to do record inspections of Commercial Puppy Mills. AKC listened and now they do just that. You want to know how the Commercial Puppy Millers responded to the now mandatory DNA profiles and inspections AKC does? They created their OWN REGISTRY! Yes sir, they created the now popular APRI (America's Pet Registry Inc) APRI says right on it's website that they were *Created for the Industry by the Industry*. They now can *register* their pups and not be under the AKCs thumb and do things right! So clever, eh?!

Dear public. Don't be duped into believing PETA and it's affiliates. They have more money than ever given to them by animal lovers around the globe. They can afford to be in the public eye as much as they wish. On every level of animal ownership. Advertising works, especially when it involves beautiful dogs, cats and other helpless animals. We, the breeders, do not have the financial means to fight them on the same level. We are using our money to care, nurture and love the purebred dog you and your family enjoy. And often, we are the ones that take in what the POOR breeders (backyard breeders, puppy mills) leave behind. We pick up that bill... not the PETA.

Ethical they are not!!

Thank you for reading.

[Laura]

How sad that people who profess to be intelligent fall for such a outlandish lie! PETA is a Extreme Activist group just like ALF who burns buildings and kills animals. PETA in fact has been known to kill most puppies or kittens it receives in it's hands. Is this what you would support? no one having any pet at all? The odd thing is PETA never ever goes after the Puppy Mills but instead targets Breeders who do health tests. the BBC did a injustice in what it reported.The story was focused on just a few dogs and not the actual truth. Shame on any of you who believe PETA cares for animals as in fact the opposite is true.

[C. Clark]

As a ground worker in a dog rescue, I can say that PeTA has done us no favors. They do NO real rescue work, they'd rather see dogs put down in shelters (or do the dirty work themselves) rather than have them find good homes. If anything, they do harm, by taking money from donors and doing nothing but political posturing and silly protests with it, when that money could be used actually HELPING animals in need. They serve as the Sinn Fein-style mouthpiece to the IRA of the animal rights terrorists.
Anyone mentioned the animal-derived insulin that Ingrid Newkirk uses? So much for "ethics". Complete hypocrisy, if you ask me.
Maybe since the Beeb isn't showing Crufts, one of our networks can cover it and show it here? I hope USA continues with Westminster, and Animal Planet does so with the IAMS/Eukanuba series.

[Karen]

Yeah right ..how many PETA members are genetically "unsound" I'd say probably 100%...PLEASE be for real its a friggin dog show..get over it and get a real life!!

[Phoenix]

PETA needs to get a life. If I know when the show is on I will watch. I know the people in my breeds ring and I know they test for health issues so have no reason not to support their ventures in the show ring!

I do agree some breeds have a horrible standard and couldn't before tasks they were bred for originally but there should be no reason those few make the entire show go under.

[Susanne]

Don't be brainwashed by PETA!! Animals are not their real agenda, they want to take away your rights as Americans!
Your right to own property, your right to eat what you want, your right to own a pet!!! And it has been proven that there is not an overabundance of dogs in shelters, there is actually a shortage, not enough for people to adopt, why most shelters have to actually SHIP DOGS IN from other locations! That is just a myth that groups like PETA try to perpetuate.
Responsible breeders spend thousands of dollars on health clearances to make sure they are breeding healthy dogs. They utilize the latest DNA health screening tests. The other big myth is that mixed breeds are healthier than purebreds, NOT TRUE! In fact it is the other way around. Don't listen to PETA, they are just a fascist terrorist group and are UNAMERICAN!!!!!!! DOWN WITH PETA! And let the show go on!

[Jenn]

#1 - Go ahead and drop it USA. Some other network will pick it up and take in all those advertising dollars. You don't all really think they will give up that cash do you?

#2 - You all boycotting dog shows on tv should also not watch any sort of sports program - Olympics, Hockey SUPERBOWL - and instead should tune into some program featuring starving children in Africa.

Give me a break people, get off your high horses and look around you. Worry about the babies starving to death and the families living in poverty in your backyard.
Jump on a bandwagon that needs you.

From a RESPONSIBLE breeder.

[Veronica]

Yes! Let's have a show on adorable shelter dogs instead...so we can promote the breeding of dogs for the purpose of landing in a shelter!! What a great idea!
The dogs at Westminster are put there by evil, selfish, money-hungry breeders. The dogs at the shelter are poor helpless creatures put on earth by an act of God. ...and if you believe that I've got some property to sell you...and you should do a little homework before you form opinions.

[cait]

I SHOW DOGS. and PETA PEOPLE ARE CRAZY. they dont know what they are talking about.

[Carol Barnet]

I think Peta is a dangerous organization, they do not want people to own dogs...if there is no breeding of dogs there will be no dogs in the next generation. I for one WILL watch Westminster!!!

[Patricia Deimler]

I have just read an article about PETA wanting the Westminster Dog show removed from your station. I enjoy this dog show, I look forward to it every year. Breeders have worked hard for years to breed good dogs. Peta only tells the public about the bad, not about the good. If USA removes the Westminster Dog Show, then I want all sports removed. Peta is accusing breeders of bad breeding practices and poor quality dogs. Athletes take steriods and drugs, then they should be banned from being televised also. FAIR IS FAIR Please continue to air the Westminster Dog Show.

[Sarah J.]

I do agree with PETA on some things, but this is absurd. They need to stop getting into other people's business and trying to run this country when it comes to anmials. They have lost it.
It really annoys me that groups like the ASAP do not get government funding, but these wack jobs do. They do not do anything to save anmials, but open big mouths and come out with comments and complaints like these.
So, saying what I have said, I WILL BE WATCHING THE DOG SHOW!!
PETA needs to be destroyed!

[Nicole]

Wow.....First off, it's not the responsible breeders adding to overpopulation. It's the morons of the world that want to have "just one litter" cause this was such a nice pet we want another just like them (don't they realize the chances of that happening are less than a million to one?) or we wanted the "kids to experience the miracle of life" (and then proceed to dump these litters into shelters.

Worse yet, all those that see responsible breeders charging a pretty penny for a certain breed (because it cost at least that much if not more per puppy to ensure sound, healthy, good tempered dogs- Breeders don't usually make ANY money on a litter, but actually LOSE money) and then jump on the band wagon and throw any two dogs together they can find in the neighborhood. They give them some fancy name if they are mixed breeds or brag how pure-bred they are if they happened upon two of the same breed with absolute NO REGARD for the health testing or money it takes to provide for a litter, never mind the extensive research that is put in to ensure there are no hidden health or temperament issues that could pop up from generations back. I'm sure they've never met any of the parents or grandparents of either of the dogs they put together, let alone know what they are carrying.

Many times they'll just let the dog have her pups tied to a doghouse in the backyard and then try to sell these puppies for money and when they can't, they dump them. Responsible breeders NEVER dump their puppies and many go through great measure to get a dog they've bred back should it fall into an unfortunate situation. Responsible breeders will take back ANY dog they've produced for the LIFE of the dog. Selfish, greedy, money hungry people breeding just to try to make a buck and pet stores won't do this. Go ahead ask them. THAT my friends is where the overpopulation problems come from. If breeding were regulated and forced to adhere to the standards that these reputable breeders uphold for themselves, there would be NO overpopulation issue, but since people are selfish and greedy we will always have this problem. Taking the dog show off the air is NOT the answer. EDUCATION is the answer to at least minimize this problem. I'm beginning to see more and more now though, that many times, you just can't fix stupid.....but it's still worth a try.

[Linda]

I watch dog shows and own animals. PETA you are interferring with my rights! In America we have the right to purse happiness as well as live the way we individually see fit. If PETA members don't want to watch shows or have animals thats also your right. But don't mess with my rights, your way over the top!

[SVShelly]

If PETA and H$U$ have their way NOBODY would own any animal, shelter dog or purebred. Please people, wake up and support Westminster. Everybody should have the right to own a dog or cat. It doesn't matter if it is from a shelter or from a breeder, it is our right. I'm sick and tired of PETA and H$U$ shoving their agendas down my throat. When we start deciding what is right for everyone then we all loose. In the past I have sometimes watched the show but this year you can be sure I'll be watching! Please USA, don't bend to PETA. Remember the words of Sir Winston Churchhill: An appeaser is the one who feeds a crocodile, hoping that it will eat him last.

[Lance]

One more attempt by PETA to try and rid our lives of ALL domestic animals. PETA proposes that all animals be sat free and that none be kept in captivity. Imagine how that would affect the world we live in. Not only that they are one of the most hypocritical organizations out there. There are reports that they killed over 11,000 dogs that they had taken into their shelters last year. Lastly Ingrid Newkirk is a "freak" who wants her skin removed and made into a coat when she dies. Do we really want to listen to someone like that. I am all for animals being treated humanely, but to give them equal footing with humans when it comes to feelings and emotions is ludicrous. This is just one more attempt by an extremist right-wing group to control the actions of the majority. If USA Network chooses to no longer air Westminster because of this I will NEVER watch another show on that Network again, just like I haven't eaten Baskin and Robbins ice cream in over 12 years, since I found out they were the largest corporate sponsor of PETA (Hello where did they think milk to make ice cream comes from) !!

[Sarah]

PETA is out of their minds.

Yes, millions of homeless animals die in shelters every year but I'd say a fraction of a percentage of those animals come from show breeders who are dedicated to their puppies for the LIFETIME of their puppies! The reason that animals die in shelters is because people don't do their homework and learn about the animal they are buying and they generally buy animals from irresponsible breeders who breed only to make a quick buck!

Pedigree runs a fabulous campaign for shelter dogs and runs commercials all during Westminster encouraging people to adopt shelter dogs who need homes.

Westminster is a fabulous show and PETA is trying to send dogs into extinction. If no one buys from breeders and everyone buys shelter dogs and spays and neuters EVERYTHING as to PETA's wishes, there will be no more dogs!

As a side note, breeding animals with common ancestors can bring out genetic problems, yes, but it can also erase them. Breeding related animals to each other who both do not have genetic defects for things such as hip dysplasia, PRA, etc etc will yield puppies who will not only not have these diseases, but will be better equipped to not pass them on, even if bred to an affected animal.

[Sue]

First I support RESCUE thats number one second I will continue to watch Westminster for as long as USA will show it ! As a pet lover I can not and will not support
PETA in any way , PETA is NOT about helping dogs! PETA does not run a single shelter, and actually has euthanized most of the dogs they have "rescued"! PETA's
true goal is to eliminate all domestic animals....period.

I PERSONAL KNOW that Uno's kennel 100% supports us in rescue , I will continue to watch Westminster and pray that someday the public will see through PETA'S mask of money.