Laguna Beach animal welfare advocate Judie Mancuso spent a year and a half trying to get the state Legislature to pass a law requiring that pets be sterilized. A week ago, the bill, AB 1634 -- alternately reviled and cheered -- was finally rejected in the state Senate.
On the tortured road to its death, the bill was amended almost a dozen times, watered down and even name-changed. Breeders and opposition groups howled in protest and said legislators were taking away their rights to handle their animals as they saw fit.
But in the end, says Mancuso, the bill's defeat came down to friction and squabbles in the Legislature and -- the final blow -- what she called a surprise vote a week ago in the Senate, where it was trounced 27 to 5.
"The bill could have said the sky is blue and the ocean is deep, and they would have voted against it," said Mancuso, 45, as she and her husband packed up her Sacramento apartment, the command center for the citizen coalition she spearheaded to convince the public and lawmakers that this was the right thing to do.
Mancuso, whose voice sounds as though it belongs to a plucky girl
cartoon character, had created the original proposal along with Los
Angeles city staffers and L.A. Animal Services general manager Ed Boks.
Assemblyman Lloyd Levine (D-Van Nuys) became the bill's author and
legislative torchbearer. The goal was to stem the euthanasia of
hundreds of thousands of animals in the state's shelters annually by
mandating people alter their pets. Fewer animals being born meant fewer
strays and owner-surrendered pets being housed in the shelters, Mancuso
and company contended. "You're just trying to prevent animals coming in
the front door," said Mancuso, pictured here smooching a pooch in the
Central Valley SPCA shelter in Fresno.