The Big Picture

Patrick Goldstein and James Rainey
on entertainment and media

« Previous Post | The Big Picture Home | Next Post »

Is 'The Town' really an Oscar contender? Or just a really fine thriller?

Ben_affleck It's not even the end of September and Oscar hype is already out of hand, with Deadline's Pete Hammond, who is surely the king of Oscar hype, enthusiastically touting "The Social Network" while the Hollywood Reporter's Gregg Kilday has a piece  today headlined: "How 'The Town' became an Oscar contender."

You might say the headline is misleading for two reasons: first because Kilday never says anywhere in the piece that the film is actually an Oscar contender and second because the film, for all its merits, isn't a contender at all. (What Kilday says is that "the debate has begun over whether the movie will develop the momentum that will take it into Oscar season," which is a far cry from declaring it an actual contender.)

But September is the silly season for Academy Awards hype, when Oscar pundits, champing at the bit to prognosticate and eager to get hits for their websites, start making all sorts of outlandish predictions about possible Oscar glory for films that have no shot at ever making it to the finish line. I'm already on record as being a big fan of "The Town," which is a terrific crime genre piece set in working-class Boston and loaded with gifted actors doing great work. But crime pictures (unless they have an eminence grise like Clint Eastwood or Martin Scorsese at the helm) rarely end up getting any serious Oscar consideration. The academy is partial to weighty dramas and historical fare. Genre pictures have about as good a chance as comedies at earning best picture nods.

I'm glad to see Warner Bros. marketing chief Sue Kroll get some props in the Reporter, since she's been on an incredible hot streak lately. But its something of a stretch for the Reporter to make it appear as if Kroll invented a whole new marketing approach for "The Town," which went to the Venice and Toronto film festivals before it debuted nationwide last weekend. Kilday writes: "The trick was to concoct a dual-track campaign, wooing critics on one hand while staging an aggressive consumer campaign with the other."

Geez, why does that sound so familiar? Oh, maybe it's because that's exactly what Kroll did a year ago with Steven Soderbergh's "The Informant!," which also was promoted with a dual-track campaign, playing the Toronto Film Festival right before it opened on almost exactly the same date as "The Town" did this year. In fact, it's virtually the same strategy Sony used two years ago with "Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist." When you have a movie that plays for both critics and mass audiences, you'd be crazy not to use a two-track strategy. But is it news? Not really. And does that make "The Town" a serious Oscar contender? Let's just say that I'll believe it when I see it.  

Photo: Ben Affleck meeting with fans at the Dublin premiere of his film "The Town." Credit: Julien Behal / Associated Press

Comments () | Archives (3)

The comments to this entry are closed.

The point is, Patrick, you have no idea what you're talking about either. It's so easy for you to play this game - year after year - but the truth is that you really don't know. No one does. There isn't really Oscar hype - there is hype for movies period. The hype exists whether we write about it or not. I can say to them "I have no idea" until I'm blue in the fingertips but they still want to know what they think I know, which is pretty much nothing - I know what I think is really good and what SHOULD get recognition but I have no idea what will.

You know how the game is played, though, right? People say this stuff early in hopes of being the one the studios turn to as ground zero for that buzz. Last year a blogger came out of a screening saying so and so was going to win Best Actor. Maybe everyone would have eventually thought the same thing if they'd seen it. But since he was first, he gets known as the person with the power to start the ball rolling. If you're first and you turn out to be right you can say you were the first person who said such and such. Last year, Pete was out front with The Blind Side as a Best Picture contender. Everyone laughed at him much like you are now. But Pete was right, as it turns out.

But he'll have to fight out a few others if he plans on taking credit should The Town be nominated.

It is about positioning -- nothing more. It isn't really about website traffic. If you want traffic write about Kristen Stewart, Nicole Kidman or gays in the military. Oscar? Not so much. Most people really don't care.

And if you hate the hype so much you really ought not to read it. Life is too short to suffer so.

The Town is good, but not on the same order as the Departed. It could squeeze in as one of the top 10. It's certainly one of the best and top 3 of the year so far.

Now that Oscar time has finally come around, we get to judge these old Oscar predictions. Turns out that the Academy didn't go to Town on this one... (rimshot!) But, seriously, no chance that it was going to, and it didn't. As predicted. Not a contender at all.


Recommended on Facebook


In Case You Missed It...

Stay Connected:

About the Bloggers



Get Alerts on Your Mobile Phone

Sign me up for the following lists: