Sports Now

Sports news from Los Angeles and beyond

« Previous Post | Sports Now Home | Next Post »

Question of the day: Who will win the Preakness? [Updated]

May 19, 2011 | 10:27 am

Photo: Exercise rider Carlos Rosas takes Preakness entrant Astrology over the track at Pimlico Race Course on Thursday. Credit: Rob Carr / Getty Images. Writers from around Tribune Co. discuss the topic. Check back throughout the day for more responses and feel free to weigh in with a comment of your own.

John Cherwa, Los Angeles Times

The best horse in the Preakness is Animal Kingdom, the impressive winner of the Kentucky Derby.  But the Derby lacked the expected early speed that would benefit the traditional deep-stretch closers. The Preakness should be very different with Flashpoint forcing a strong early pace. Now, it’s easy to pick the 2-1 favorite, but Animal Kingdom is an underlay at that price. I suspect he’ll win but he’s not the smart choice. I’m going to take a shot on Mucho Macho Man, trained by Kathy Ritvo. He’s never been off the board in nine starts and showed a decent finish in the Derby. Underneath, you’ve have Animal Kingdom and Dialed In, who should benefit from a fast pace. As for a horse to throw in the exotics for a price, I like Dance City, who finished third in the Arkansas Derby.

[Updated at 12:12 p.m.

Neil Milbert, Chicago Tribune

Granted, Animal Kingdom outran a relatively weak field when he made his dirt-racing field and won the Kentucky Derby as a 20-1 long shot. Going into the Derby with six weeks of rest, he proved to be much the best and raced the final quarter in a razor-sharp :24.55. All of that suggests the well-bred colt is capable of a comparable performance at Pimlico -- where he will be facing an even weaker field than the one he dominated at Churchill Downs.

Don't count out my Derby pick, Dialed In. After encountering traffic problems at the start, he made a belated stretch move to finish eighth as the 5.20-1 favorite. The winner of the Holy Bull and Florida Derby at Pimlico's sister track, Gulfstream Park, will hit a $5.5-million three-race bonus jackpot if he wins the Preakness for owner Robert LaPenta and trainer Nick Zito. Bettor beware.]

[Updated at 12:41

Tom Jicha, South Florida Sun Sentinel

Almost every major 3-year-old race, including the Kentucky Derby, has produced an upset. Animal Kingdom’s Derby triumph was visually scintillating. However, the race was slowly run with leisurely early fractions. Theoretically, this makes Animal Kingdom’s come-from-behind surge more impressive. But slow races often produce strange results because it keeps lesser talent in contention. With more early speed, the Preakness fractions should be lively. If Animal Kingdom has to run faster early to stay in touch, will he have the same kick? If so, he probably wins again. But Dialed In, who always drops back to last, ran a faster final half-mile. Alas, the field didn’t come back to him, as happens when the pace is quick. Given the likely odds, Dialed In is a better bet than a short-priced Animal Kingdom.]

Photo: Exercise rider Carlos Rosas takes Preakness entrant Astrology over the track at Pimlico Race Course on Thursday. Credit: Rob Carr / Getty Images