« Previous Post | Show Tracker Home | Next Post »

'American Idol' recap: Top 12 'ladies' take their turns

MB1_9117 "Ladies' night" on "American Idol" was a surprisingly low-voltage affair, paling in comparison with the overwhelmingly electric men's performances the night before. But it wasn't clear what to attribute the energy dip to: Was it just a day-two semifinals slump? Was the sound mixed in a way that made the voices seem subdued? Were the unrelentingly positive judge comments flattening the proceedings?

Or were we -– and perhaps the contestants -- just pacing ourselves for the long haul ahead, despite the fact that the judges did their best to boost the stakes at the outset by noting that the women would need to sing, as Steven Tyler put it, "like there's no tomorrow ... like they're going to the moon."

Some of the singers seemed as remote as the moon on a cloudy night. But several managed to break through the mist to emerge as clear favorites. They stood, they sang, they conquered. One small step for women, one giant leap for "Idol"-kind.

Or something like that.

One thing is certain -– now that they're launched, the contestants this year are going to have to navigate without much direction from the judges. Jennifer Lopez pronounced what felt like nearly every performance to be "amazing." Steven returned frequently to the adjective "beautiful," which he also uses as an adverb. And Randy Jackson just doesn't seem to have the vocabulary to carry out the role of critical judge, reverting back to his not very descriptive "I don't know, dawg," "For me, it was just OK," and "That's how you do it!" repertoire.

At one point, I confess, I actually felt a little sorry for Randy, who has been tasked with ensuring continuity at the judges' table but who seems to have decided that the best way to do that is to continually compare performers -– favorably or unfavorably -– to "Idol" singers past. After he told one singer, whom the other judges praised, that her song choice did nothing for her, he even pleaded with host Ryan Seacrest for help. "The judges are disagreeing, Ryan," he said. Ryan, dawg, anyone? A little backup?

So who are my picks to continue to the next round (only sort of in order of preference -– with very little distinction between numbered and wild-card picks)? They are ...

1. Pia Toscano: Where did she even come from? Barely on my radar before, Toscano, who was given the night's final "pimp" spot, is squarely on it now. She sang the Pretenders' "I'll Stand By You" with full-throated confidence, earning a standing ovation and high praise from the judges, who honestly seemed as startled by her sudden, powerful break from the back of the pack as I was. (Did you see it coming?)

2. Karen Rodriguez: Her English-Spanish version of Mariah Carey's "Hero" was not my favorite performance from her. (The song was a little schleppy, though her voice came across as controlled and strong and she made navigating the notes sound like no sweat.) But I've liked her since the beginning, and her call-out to her mom as she wrapped up her performance was pretty cute. I'd like to see her move on to the next round so we can see what else she's capable of.

3. Lauren Alaina: I responded to her charisma during the auditions, but this is the first time I really believed that the judges might be right in pegging her early as a potential winner. She did feel like a natural onstage as she sang Reba McEntire's "Turn on the Radio." But I think it's time for her to turn down the flirting. Ryan was not as receptive to the teasy advances of a 16-year-old as Steven, which make us like Ryan a little more and Lauren a little less.

4. Ashton Jones: On this night, her stage presence and killer looks were on display. Her voice, less so. But she's shown us before (on "I Am Telling You" during Hollywood Week) that she has the vocal chops to go with what the judges apparently see as her "diva" destiny. Like the judges say, she could go bigger, or, as Jennifer put it, "You're Diana Ross, baby." Next time, I'm hoping for something a little more ... supreme.

5. Naima Adedapo: I cannot get that image of Naima Adedapo cleaning toilets and dreaming of stardom out of my head. And so, whenever she dresses up in one of her brightly colored gowns and sings so soulfully in her smoky voice, I feel like I'm seeing Cinderella waltz with the prince at the ball. I don't want the clock to strike midnight for her just yet. I hope America gives her the chance to keep her carriage from turning into a pumpkin for at least one more dance.

Wild-card picks: Lauren Turner and Thia Megia: I don't know if Lauren Turner reminds me, as she apparently does Jennifer, of a young Bette Midler, but I know I like her and her no-nonsense, sellin'-it energy.   also liked the way she warned us that she was sarcastic -– and sounded so sincere about it! I'd love to see more of her.

Thia Megia's "Out Here on My Own" from "Fame" is the number that's stuck with me the day after, which maybe means I should have moved her higher up on the list. (Though how was it any less Broadway than Rachel Zevita's song?) My gripe with Thia is that she almost sounds too polished. Her performances lack suspense. "Sometimes a person's pitch can be so perfect, it doesn't matter what song they sing," Steven said. But I don't know, somehow I think it should matter.

And you? What do you think? Do you agree/disagree with my picks? Which women do you think should go through, and which ... not so much?

-- Amy Reiter

Photo: Pia Toscano performs on "American Idol" Wednesday. Credit: Michael Becker / Fox

Comments () | Archives (10)

Pia Toscano & Thia Megia were the only standouts in this pack for me.

I don't understand the fuss over Lauren Alaina or Karen Rodriguez. Lauren Alaina tries to seduce on stage but it's kind of hard to overlook her weight issue.

How I judge the contestants is whether or not I would want to hear their voice come through the radio and only Pia's & Thia's would make me not want to immediately switch to another station.

Great choices, although I probably would not have Karen Rodriguez in my top 5. Her moment was the epitome of everything that was unfortunate about "girls night" (and, in turn, what was thrilling about "boys night"). In the men we have at least 10 performers that far outshine last year's "winner." In the women we have yet one more crop of Idol wannabes. Pia's performance was spectacular indeed but then every season has its Fantasia "Summertime" moment. I enjoyed every single performance by the guys on Tuesday, but was mostly distracted and bored by the gals - including Thia, whose performance was tailor-made for greatness but wound up being for me (forgive me) "just a'ight."

My favorite was Pia and Thia, Great singers , I would like to see more of their performances. I hope they make it to the top.

What about Hailey....she was hands down the most awsome performance of the night. I got so sick of the majority of them sounding like lounge acts. They all have good voices but none of them were standing out for me.

First of all, I don't think that there were five girls deserving of being picked. I would choose three and you did not even choose one of them. All of the rest of the women...while granted they had decent voices...were tired and boring. They sounded like second-class lounge singers. However, Pia, Lauren Alaina, and Haley stood out from the crowd and you didn't even choose Haley.

I also don't know why a little flirting seems to bother you so much. You have consistently complained about Steven Tyler in your reviews and I thought that Lauren Alaina's attempt at flirting was cute. I thought people from LA were supposed to be a little more open-minded, but you make this conservative Southern Baptist republican feel like a liberal.

First of all, I think the judges without Simon are much better this year. All three are pro singers/musicians. Simon was an A&R guy. To me Randy takes on the task of being honest about pitches and lackluster performances that the other judges might not want to discuss.

Next, the last thing we need is another R&B diva, so none of those singers impressed me.

The last three, Thia(a cap pella singing), Lauren Alaina(pro stage presence and performance), and Pia(great take on Pretenders song) were my favorites. Also Lauren Turner's bluesy singing.

I hope they don't end up picking a boring white guy again as the winner.

My top 7 is Lauren Alaina, Haley, Naima, Lauren T, Ashton, Pia and Thia though not all of them performed to the best of their ability or sang the right song (Haley/Naima/Thia) I think there's more there.

Narrowing it to the 5 I would say. Lauren A, Pia, Ashton, Haley, Thia and wild card Naima and Lauren T

The best performance was from Lauren Alaina. Rachel has a unique voice but it was way too broadway last night.

I agree with Randy that they should choose songs that show what kind of artist they want to be and not necessarily if they like a song a not. Just cause you like a song doesn't mean you can do it justice.

As much as I love Lauren Alaina her I kind of get your point there is a touch of annoyance but i don't think its her being flirty. That said I do like her bubbly personality.

Based solely on the nights performances my top 5 would be:

1. Pia (agree with everything you said).
2. Lauren T. (very strong performance, confident and unique)
3. Lauren A. (did herself a favor singing a country song)
4. Thia Megia (the most quietly impactful performance...unfamiliar song works against her but she still was different enough to stand out).
5. Tie between Naima and Karen (Naima's performance was solid and different and I agree her back story makes her memorable...Karen's performance was pretty and the Spanish lyrics help shore up an important demographic for her, the reason I put her last was the song was so cliche and it seemed a little like a pageant performance).

Not feeling Ashton based on the evenings performance. It was a pitchy and unconfident performance and she did herself no favors constantly responding to the judges critique. Not that she was disagreeing but it never pays to say anything other than one thank you at the very end of the judges critique.

The women did not wow as nearly as much as the men, but there were some standouts.

Pia Toscano nailed that song. It will be interesting to watch which way she progressess from here. I have a feeling that could have been her "moment". I hope she didn't just peak!

Lauren Alaina. I finally saw what the judges have seen all along. The girl owns the stage. She is very natural and has a great voice. When she sings her big slow number, we will all probably be left speechless.

Lauren Turner. She has a great voice. I look forward to hearing her every week.

Hailey. Where did she come from? I look forward to more.

Breathtaking to look at. Stunning. Sounded pretty awesome too. This season seems to be shaping up nicely


Recommended on Facebook

In Case You Missed It...


Tweets and retweets from L.A. Times staff writers.




Get Alerts on Your Mobile Phone

Sign me up for the following lists: