'The Good Wife': Suspicious Minds

“The Good Wife” keeps getting better with each episode. For a few weeks I wasn’t entirely convinced that the drama’s split personality was going to work, but the show is proving me wrong. Last night’s episode was -- dare I say it -- downright riveting. And for the first time, its themes tied together in a way that seemed organic rather than forced.

After last week’s adventures in horticulture and homicide, Alicia was put to work on a class-action lawsuit against a big pharmaceutical company. In the courtroom, eager beaver Cary scrambles through some deposition boxes, and in this rush, doesn’t notice a small piece of paper that falls to the floor. But guess who does? Alicia, mom that she is, picks up the mess. Lucky for her — and us — it just so happens to indicate that one of the jurors has been bribed. I like that the entire plot of this episode hinges on Cary’s relentless brown-nosing, but it takes Alicia’s keen observation to actually do something with the clue that literally falls at her feet. 

Alicia and Kalinda investigate two suspect jurors and try to decide who seems the most susceptible to the bribe. They meet with their firm’s high-paid jury consultant, who shares with them such questionable wisdom like “as an African American, he is more likely to be resistant to authority.” Kalinda’s not having it, and asks the consultant to leave. I have no idea if this would fly in the real world, but I enjoyed the scene. It made a point without getting all “Crash” on us. Plus, it set up the key question of this episode: Who can be bought? (This episode was called “Fixed” after all.)

In the course of their investigation, Kalinda has to pull some ethically questionable moves — like lying to a maintenance man in order to get into a juror’s apartment and rifle through his bank statements. Alicia is clearly uncomfortable with some of these methods, and it makes sense. There’s an obvious parallel between Alicia’s own situation — her private life turned into cable news fodder — and that of the juror. Alicia even says, “I don’t like prying,” to which Kalinda responds, “I don’t mind.” Point taken. So it’s interesting when Alicia calls Kalinda at home, and another woman answers. Alicia asks Kalinda about the mystery woman, but she brushes her off, saying only “That’s Donna.” Maybe I am being crazy, but are we supposed to think she is a lesbian? Or maybe that’s the point — that we’re all obsessively worried about one another's private lives?

Speaking of which, on the home front Alicia is becoming increasingly suspicious of  Peter. His lawyer, Daniel Golden, hounds Alicia for information that might help in his defense. In particular, he asks Alicia to dig up any correspondence between Peter and a shady real estate developer named Tony Rezko ... I mean Gerald Koztco. (Surely, the similarity is coincidental). This sends Alicia rummaging through more painful memories. More importantly, it makes her increasingly doubtful of her husband’s innocence, especially as Golden tries to bribe her with giant ham hocks and promises of private school scholarships for her kids. So by the end of the episode, when Peter asks Alicia to testify on his behalf, her disdain for him is palpable.

The episode had a jaw-dropping surprise ending: Turns out Alicia’s seemingly sweet and innocent clients had actually been the ones who bribed the juror. I definitely didn’t see this coming but I loved that the show pulled not one, not two, but three switcheroos on us: First we suspected one juror, then another, then it turns out the nice guys were actually crooks.

I am still a little confused about one thing, though. Did Alicia’s clients know the scrap of paper was left in the deposition box? Or was it just an accident? 

Did you love this episode as much as I did? Did you see the surprise ending coming? Is Kalinda a lesbian? Should we care? Is Alicia going to testify on Peter’s behalf?

-- Meredith Blake

Related

Television Review: 'The Good Wife'

Complete coverage of 'The Good Wife' coverage on Show Tracker

CBS orders full seasons for two new dramas

Photo: John Paul Filo / CBS

Comments

[Candi Ahto]

I like "The Good Wife," too, but perhaps some one can tell me how you can bibe just one juror to return a verdict on your behalf? The plaintiff can only win if a majority of the jury agrres with the suit's claims, and bribing only one would not assure this.

cob1545

[Bettye]

Horribly boring show. They need to take courtroom lessons from the greats. Margolis puts me to sleep. No animation from these characters. Bland. The story lines fair to midlin. Won't watch this again. Cannot hold a candle to Raising the Bar or the old Boston Legal.

[Bill]

I suspected the client of bribing the juror when Alicia sat with her on the bench in the courthouse and the client talked about feeling pressure to win for all the others in the class action; at the end, Alicia gave her a long, steadied stare. A sure giveaway.

But this bribing doesn't make sense. The plaintiff paid $3500 for only one juror's vote, but it takes 12 jurors to win. It would have been logical for the defendant to bribe one juror because one juror can defeat the plaintiff. But one juror cannot win it for the plaintiff.

[sfphoto94114]

I liked this episode but annoyed that the surprise ending is very similar to Sunday's finale of Drop Dead Diva. In both cases (spoiler alert) the plaintiffs were not so innocent and left the star lawyer in a questionable predicament. Totally coincidental Im sure. Im also not sure how one juror can bend the case?

That said, totally enjoying the show. Happy its doing well.

[PrettyPaula]

LOVE the show...I really enjoy Alicia's relationship with her boss. I look forward to seeing that develop....I hope she doesnn't testify for her husband but I think she will.

[TV Obsessed]

The Good Wife continues to be the best new drama this season without a doubt. The legal cases are compelling but still allow for plenty of scenes devoted to the rest of Alicia's life. It'll be interesting to see if she can continue to cope with her situation at work, and deal with her husbands trial. Full review of the episode.

http://th3tvobsessed.blogspot.com/2009/10/review-good-wife-season-1-episode-4.html