« Previous Post | Show Tracker Home | Next Post »

'Brothers & Sisters': Will Kitty's cancer boost the show?

B&S_kitty Yes, they went there. Taking a cue from fellow ABC drama "Grey's Anatomy," "Brothers & Sisters" gave one of its lead characters cancer.

Last night, Kitty got the news that she has non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, a type of cancer that affects the lymph nodes. It was brought on quite suddenly, and we were thankfully spared from anything overly dramatic such as hallucinations of past lovers. Like "Grey's," it seems the C-card was pulled to not only give Kitty the renewed perspective and purpose to either save or scrap her current situation, but to give the show's fourth season a much-needed boost.

Kitty and Robert's marriage is heading down the drain, and it's becoming increasingly more difficult to root for them as a couple. Nora really hasn't much to do; Tommy's gone; Sarah's still away; and frankly, Justin's and Rebecca's story just hasn't been doing it for me lately. Scotty and Kevin have baby issues that they'll continue to deal with, and Ryan is back with what looks like another shady secret, but all that is hardly enough to keep one from changing the channel.

The show needs something because unlike "Grey's," "Brothers & Sisters" doesn't have heart-pumping emergency room action to counterbalance the emotional drama. It must instead rely on the Walker family's humor and comedic timing, which once upon a time served as the show's driving force. The aggravating arguments and tense scenes were always equally balanced with one of the character's funny foibles or the siblings' quirky way of communicating. That comedic magic has been lacking for most of the third season — I don't quite remember the last time I was charmed by an episode, though I'm sure it involved Sarah —so the fourth desperately needs to lighten things up. Will Kitty getting cancer help achieve that? I'm not sure.

Something so serious as a cancer story line can come off as either heart-tugging or downright depressing, and I hope the show aims for the former. First, Rachel Griffiths needs to come back from maternity leave and inject some spirit back into the show. Then we need to see the Walkers bond again. The focus has been so on their individual dramas that it'll be nice to witness the siblings share moments together that don't involve migraine-inducing arguments (we also have a reason for Nora to revisit her marijuana habit!). Justin's and Rebecca's impending wedding also has the potential for comedy, and even Kitty's treatment can be dealt with grace and humor.

Now that the show has led Kitty down an irreversible path, it has nowhere else to go but up. Bring the humor back, "Brothers & Sisters," and make us believe in the Walkers again.

Time for your thoughts, readers. What was your reaction to Kitty's diagnosis? Do you think the show needs to bring back the funny? Feel free to discuss in the comments.

— Enid Portuguez

Photo: Calista Flockhart as Kitty McAllister. Credit: ABC

Comments () | Archives (23)

Honestly, I've never lost charm for the show. The only thing I hated about last season was the Kitty/Robert drama. This plot twist is definitely going to help their marriage, but hopefully Robert isn't only doing this BECAUSE she's sick, rather because he realized he couldn't live without her. The show is only going to gain momentum now, because Sarah is coming back, Gilles Marini is guest starring, and the preview I just saw seemed like it was very lighthearted. The thing about this show is that it has amazing balance. They have the perfect amount of drama, comedy, and lighthearted moments. I can't stop watching it, I'm addicted...not to mention the acting is impeccable. =)

I am surprised no one had mentioned the twist on the research angle? The writers gently start to go down the pathway and expose the "politics" involved with clinical trials ....now IF the writers head down this path they MAY have a hook.

Doesn't anyone wonder that we have invested Billions of Dollars into Cancer Research and yet we are still using the same standard treatments? Where does that money really go?

Just wondering out loud.......

love it, love Sally fields. just so real,like any mother would act if she loved her kids. Don't change a thing. Just one thing who could " the silver fox be any ideas?

« | 1 2


Recommended on Facebook

In Case You Missed It...


Tweets and retweets from L.A. Times staff writers.




Get Alerts on Your Mobile Phone

Sign me up for the following lists: