Idol Tracker: The tour comes to the Staples Center

A few very long months ago, these nine singers shared hotel rooms on the other side of downtown with a couple hundred other aspiring superstars summoned for the semifinal round of "American Idol" auditions known as Hollywood Week.  Half a year later, the 10 who emerged from those masses touched down momentarily in the filled-to-the-rafters Staples Center to entertain an ecstatic audience that greeted the returning champions like gods falling to Earth as the "Idols Live" tour came home to Los Angeles.

The most frequent criticism a professional "Idol" watcher hears of the show is the "this is not real stardom" saw, that these singers did not rise organically through the grassroots along our mythical (and, largely, no longer existent) path for superstars, playing tiny bars to a handful of drunks in Butte, Mont., rising to a capacity-40 nightclub in Boise until suddenly -- and untainted by the touch of the professional music industry -- they force their way onto a radio station and instantaneously charm the millions.  By contrast, the grudge goes, "American Idol" stars are "invented" TV show confections who have not paid their dues, and their rise is forever tainted by their corporate overlords and sponsors.

Seen through that prism, Monday night at Staples would no doubt have taken on a bit of a Disneyland glow --  a stadium full of people willing themselves to believe that these are actual stars and this is an actual rock concert, mistaking fame for talent, etc. etc. etc.

Unabashed "American Idol" apologist though I am, I can only say that if this was mass delusion, it was a thoroughly satisfying one that left the crowd grinning like Cheshire cats from a concert whose sheer fun topped that of any musical event I've been to lately.  Wherever they came from -- from the votes of the American people or from the executive suites of Rupert Murdoch -- these 10 singers singing three songs each (and four for David Archuleta, five for David Cook) proved that each of them had the showmanship to, in their brief concert time, hold a giant arena in their thrall. 

Having seen the first two concerts on the tour, which were epic in their way, the Staples show felt like the night when the Idols became entirely comfortable in their place on the massive stage.  Five shows into the tour, the nerves had been worked out and they each -- singing now with no threat of nasty comments from Simon Cowell or a visit from Angel of Death Seacrest -- were at last giving themselves over completely to what I know from my conversations with them is the great obsession of each of their lives -- creating music.

It should also be said in this niche-ified age that it is hard to think of another concert that pleases such a broad age range of the American populace.  Eight-year-olds were there to screech their lungs out for David Archuleta, while their grandmothers nodded approvingly and their parents thrilled to the powerful rock renditions of Michael Johns and Carly Smithson.  Teenagers thrilled to champion David Cook's hard-rock numbers.  Tie-dyed hippies prowled the floor awaiting Jason Castro.  Kristy Lee Cook spoke for the urban cowboys in the crowd.  A tribe of pop princesses with low-hanging bangs in imitation of Ramiele Mulabay were on the loose. Chikeze and Syesha Mercado's uplifted the proceedings with uplifting R&B numbers. Brooke White brought quirky indie pop to the people.  And each managed to make his or her genre that least street-cred worthy of words, "accessible," to all the other audiences in the house.   

Throughout the season, as they were forced week after week to jump through thematic hoops, the question was constantly posed to each: What sort of singer would you be?  At the concert, we at last saw their best shot at answering that question. Here, then, a brief rundown of the acts, as well as a final tribute to each as the tour moves on and they head out across America and then, ultimately, on to their post-"Idol" careers.

- Chikeze: He had the unenviable task of opening the show, but the singer whose elimination now seems so long ago brought the crowd to a very quick crescendo with his version of "So High." The often-serious Inglewood native often seemed in a different universe from his brethren during the season, but he showed at Staples that, as a singer, he is a talent to be reckoned with.

- Ramiele Mulaby: The pixie-like singer made the clearest shot for a traditional pop career of any, featuring songs by Taylor Dayne, Rhianna and opening with a Jackson 5 number that featured the only synchronized dance steps of the night.  Throughout the season, Ramiele brought a spirit of fun and youthful mischief to the show that made her unforgettable even after her early departure.

- Michael Johns: Ah, the injustice. The thought of what might have been, had the Duende From Down Under survived longer on the show.  Seeing him on the Staples stage, however, it is clear from both his classic rock numbers ("We Are the Champions" and "Dream On") and his soulful rendition of "It's So Wrong," that this is a talent for grown-ups, almost too smoldering to allow kids to be exposed to (although the ones near me seemed to love him). Those characteristics should serve him well as he goes down the road, but they may not have worked in his favor with the "Idol" voting base.

- Kristy Lee Cook:  More than either of her blond "Idol" country singer predecessors (Carrie Underwood and Kellie Pickler) Kristy Lee shows a capacity to perform rocking country music, pushing her down-home girlness to the farthest Shania reaches of tough-girlness that country will allow.  Her tomboyish qualities should serve her well in the country world.  She even used her first "Idol" mad money to buy a bow and arrow.

-  Carly Smithson.  The greatest singer in Idol history. I challenged those who doubted this to look me in the eye and tell me it was not so after the Staples show.  None would dare.  An amazing story. An electrifying singer. Her opening number (Evanescence's "Bring Me to Life") was like a million-volt wake-up call to the crowd, transforming the vast arena like some sort of otherworldly call to prayer.  Greatness awaits.

- Brooke White.  With her deep voice and girlie blond manner, Brooke has a natural ability to take melodic quirky indie tunes (she sang Coldplay's "Yellow" and Feist's "1234") and make them read to children, country fans and everyone else in between. One of the kindest, most pure-natured people ever to step on the "Idol" stage, her connection with the joyful innocence of music will guide her way.

- Jason Castro. The Dreadhead mafia was out in force at Staples.  It is very difficult not to smile when Jason is on stage.  His goofy, good-natured attitude permeates his music, his wardrobe and his smile.  He very pleasingly performed his crowd-winners from the season ("Over the Rainbow" and "Daydream") as well as Gnarls Barkley's "Crazy." Jason's good humor was one of the highlights of the season, as was his occasionally shocking ability to steal a night with one of his seemingly laid-back numbers. 

- Syesha Mercado:  The stealth candidate of the year who dodged bullet after bullet to end up finishing at the very highest ranks. At Staples she proved this was no fluke.  After opening with a crowd-pleasing version of "Umbrella" and then bringing it down with Alicia Keys' "If I Ain't Got You," she absolutely brought down the house with a death-defying power spectacular, Whitney-worthy rendition of "Listen."

- David Archuleta.  The youngest "Idol" star has become as much a phenomenon as a singer.  The screeching starts with the first allusion to his name and continues through his four-song set.  Nonetheless, the juxtaposition of this awkward boy who has such a hard time expressing himself through the nervous giggles when he speaks and the absolutely assured confident singer who steps up when the song start is fairly incredible. Watching how David grows and matures now that he is in the spotlight to stay will be a fascinating journey.

- David Cook. Without question, a rock star.  A spectacular set that had the crowd on its feet throughout.  More than Chris Daughtry ever could, David Cook has the ability to put a likable, charismatic face on hard rock while being entirely genuine and true to himself.  His rise from the back benches to dominate the show and ultimately unseat the huge favorite to win will forever be one of the great "American Idol" stories.  And his ability to connect with young people in a very authentic way should provide a shot of fresh blood into the franchise.  It's a new era, with David Cook as champion and how that will change next season will be fascinating to watch. (Auditions start next week.)

After the show, the 10 greeted fans at a backstage party, posing for pictures and signing autographs long after the lights went up.  Those with Southern California-based families said their goodbyes as they prepared to ride off tonight to San Jose and to America beyond (five cities down, 48 to go).

For one who has been watching them since the season's beginning, it is hard to imagine that a new crop can take their place.  Season 7 contestants, in their professionalism, diversity of talents, good natures and high spirits, seemed a special group. But the world has met them now and the next step will be to watch where they go with this moment. An "Idol"-watcher may wish it could last forever, but now, the real battle awaits.   

These proud warriors of song have battled well and battled hard for these last few months and created something that for tens of millions was a special experience, the rare chance for families to come together in front of a television and the closest thing we have to a national epic. Before the final struggle begins to claim their permanent place in  public life, one great victory lap of America is well deserved and well enjoyed.

-- Richard Rushfield

(Photos courtesy Richard Rushfield)

Comments

[Amy]

Ok I love most of your review. But Cook better than Daughtry, you lost me on that one. Cook is Daughtry 2.0 and will be lucky to sell half of what Chris Daughtry did or garnish half the number 1 hits and half the awards. I like Cook, actually voted for him and Jason, but Daughtry blows them both away vocally, stage presence wise and with star quality.

[Les]

This is your third review of the same show, and it still is entertaining! Thanks, Richard!

[Keith]

Great review! But no one ever mentions the band. They're awesome, especially the drummer. They play with more fire than the band on the T.V. show.

[Charles]

Thank you Richard Rushfield for yet another review of what sounds like a great show. I will find out tonight, as I am attending the show at HP Pavilion at San Jose this evening. To put is simply, Carly Smithson is the draw for me. I've watched this show for seven years and Mrs. Smithson is the person that compelled me to buy my first Idols Live ticket.

[Ethan, California]

Hey Richard,
You just insulted the rest of David Archuleta's fanbase. Where did you learn that his fanbase is "eight-year-olds and grandmothers"? From Simon Cowell? Please do a little research.
I'm a 26 y/o guy just so you know.

[Ethan, California]

"Eight-year-olds and grandmothers"? Stop telling yourself that. You are rude.

[Debbie Williams]

Great article Richard....... wish I could have gone to the concert, but work got in the way. This batch was my fave for so many reasons and it would have made me smile to see them up there doing so well and becoming performers. Glad you wrote this...made me miss them a bit.

[Bestillmysoul]

Mr. Rushfield,
Are you sure you were there yesterday at the show? I didn't see many 8 year olds screaming for Archuleta. You still don't get it, do you? His fans are many teens along with 20's, 30's, 40's and above. If you happen to visit some of his fan websites, you will see variety of age groups (including male fans). His vocal is exceptional and fans don't mind if he doesn't show any pretentious showmanship. He is just 17 year old, and his innocence and humility never gets anyone tired. Just pure talent .....

[Fresh Maker]

Dude, you kill me like whoa. The beginning of your review reads like a Tenacious D song. From the bowels of Mt. Olympus, they were delivered to you, the singing gods and goddesses of America, except for Ramiele. She really sucked and I went to the snack bar during her set.

And dude, Carly isn't even the best girl singer in the tour. Hello-that's Brooke.

[Ames]

Richard, why do you assume all of David A's fans are 8? All of my friends and I are in our 20s and are all David A fans fyi...we're mature enough to understand true talent

[Anne]

I'm in my 40's and a huge David Archuleta fan. When are people going to get it through their heads that his fans are not 8 year olds, tweens and grandmothers? That was a stupid comment and soooo untrue!

[HZ]

Hahah you just eliminated about 70% of Archuleta's fans with that 8 yr old comment and grandma comment. I thought the LA Times would do more research than that...I guess journalism is really eroding these days.

[Annie]

Richard, I'll save you some time here. If you want to understand why DA's fans are a MUCH broader demographic than eight-year olds and grandmothers, delve into this site I found recently: www.notingdavid.com . The writer there, rascal, definitely explains what I'm feeling in words almost as inspired as David's singing.

[Charles]

I went to the show at Staples and let me tell you that Archuleta's voice is one of the best I've ever heard, and I've been to many, many concerts. Dude. Can. Sing.

[Ryan]

I also couldn't agree more with those commenting on how you seem to have swallowed the "David Archuleta only has the teen girls and grandmothers for fans" accessment. I for one am 45 and will be a DJA fan for life.

[Val F]

Great review. Very elegant and gracious, except for the reference to 8-year-olds screaming for David Archuleta. From all the reports from other media about the amazing response to Archie, arguably bigger than anyone else's, one can assume it would take a real army of tweens to accomplish that! Come on! Is it so hard to do your homework before actually writing this review? Some of the sites for David A's fanbase have posts displaying such sophistication of style and awareness of music that would probably teach you a thing or two. Do you think tweens write them? Sorry, maybe it was unintended but we're just tired of this sort of contemptuous attitude to Archie.

[arlene]

hey,, i"m not a 8yr old ,, boy u do nd t do sme research ,, hello ,, i lstn t david archuleta ,which by the way ,is the best singer t ever go on ai ,, from all season yes, including carrie underwood which i luv ,, so stop trying t deminsh david ,, or hold him back with all yr stupid ugliness ,, get it right i" way older thn 8.. and i lstn everyday ,, & replay all of david a sngs luv daivi he is a true artist ,, mre thn u can prblably grasp,, but try !!!!

[BJ]

I feel compelled to comment. I am no 8 year old girl nor an I an 80 year old grandmother either. More like a 40 year old businessman who is a big fan of David Archuleta. What a voice. What a great kid. Hope he makes the big time.

[nicole M.]

um im definately not 8 and im most definately not a grandmother im 16 and a huge fan of David Archuleta. "Teenagers thrilled to champion David Cook's hard-rock numbers" um this is pretty inaccurate to cuz im not a fan of cook's songs/singing voice it just to raspy and i have friends that agree with me who are teenagers.
before you write a piece make sure your demographics are right.

[KirkKing]

Ah, Richard, to be 8 again. You still haven't got Archuleta yet, buddy. And awkward and nervous giggles have been disappearing at light speed. Did you go to the concert last night?

[David]

Before you get paid to publish your opinion, you should at least get your facts straight. Archie's fans come in all ages, nationalities, and genders. I'm a thirtysomething guy, and know lots of other folks my age that prefer Archuleta over all the others. It's insulting to suggest that only 8 year olds like his music, as if somehow by saying that over and over you can diminish the respect he deserves. At least you didn't repeat the misguided assertion that David Cook's fans are all "cougars" and lonely housewives. Yes, I'm sure among that demographic, he is the most popular contestant. But his fans also run the gamut of ages and gender, and their enthusiasm cannot just be chalked up to female hormones. I wonder why you didn't make that mistake with Cook?

[Kat]

Hello? David Archuleta's fans are not limited to 8 year olds and nannies. Please......... do some research and if you were in the concert, I think you need glasses to see who his fans really are.

[L]

Your right on with DC! 5 stars! He's the best ever!

[audry]

Richard...You definitely did not do any research on DA. You obviously have heard Simon Cowell
about Teens and Tweens... I'm telling you right now....Your fact is incomplete.'' There are a lot
of us who did not fall in those age category.... and Oh... He is also very popular on the other side
of the world...This amazing lad has pure voice that move your deepest emotion like you wouldn't believe. at least for me....That is the experience I get whenever he do ballad song. He also have
a unique personality, often misunderstood as boring, a 12 year old , no stage presence etc....
I would encourage you to look at his fansites... It is amazing what you will find.

[Melanie]

Simply: AMERICAN IDOL TOUR 2008 ROCKS!!! It was an incredible show loaded with serious talent! They put their hearts out there and gave it their all! They have worked hard and are only deserving of all positive feedback! My seat was directly next to the stage and it was quite breathtaking and a once in a lifetime experience! It left me in tears! Buy the best seat in the house you won't regret it!

[audry]

Richard.....You are insulting a lot of ppl with your comment about David Archuleta...
I can't believe you said that!... Did you just rush this review because of deadline?
Gosh!

[Karen]

Richard, Richard. What planet are you living on? David Archuleta's fans are 8 year old girls and grannies? Not hardly. The facts from a recent poll: 30% of David's fans are male, 70% are female; age breakdown: 30% are 17 and under, 28% are 18-30 years of age, 42% are 30+. Almost as many fans are 18-30 as are 17 and under. Do a little research before putting your foot in your mouth. You are really insulting a lot of adults out here like me who are rabid David Archuleta fans.

I've never been a fan of any musician or celebrity before. Not remotely interested. I actually stopped listening to popular music for 20+ years--until I heard David sing. I YouTubed him then and watched the 27 videos of his there. (There are 19,000+ now.) That was it. I turned on a dime. I decided that if there was beauty like THAT in the world and I wasn't listening, I was a fool. No longer. I now listen to David nearly 24/7, but when I can't get him, I listen to popular music and love it. I enjoy a lot of the artists he follows--Natasha Bedingfield, Jon Mayer, Sara Bareilles, Eva Cassidy, Jason Mraz, and others I've found. Music is back in my life thanks to David.

David Archuleta is the best vocalist to come along in ages, and the way he connects with a song and his audience is unreal. There are a number of his songs that I can't listen to without getting teary-eyed EVERY time I listen to them. I am over the moon for this kid, and I have a LOT of company of ALL ages. He is gonna be HUGE! His exquisitely beautiful, soaring, emotive voice and unique musicality are unbelievable. He'll be as big a household name as Celine Dion in five years, trust me on this!

[Richard Rushfield]

Hi folks,

Just want to respond to all the Archuleta fans who think I was putting him down with the 8 year old and their grandmothers comment. For the record- I did mean to say that was the entirety of David's fanbase. Just as there are plenty of non-hippies who enjoy Jason Castro and plenty of non-teens who liked David Cook and plenty of grandmothers who like Carly Smithson. However, if you were at the concert and at the show tapings before that, the young girls and their elder escorts are an incredibly visible sector of David's support - more visible than not only his other supporters but more visible than the support groups for any other singer there. I dont mean this at all as a putdown, its just something that stands out incredibly if you are at the shows and everyone who I talked to commented on it. Its an exciting thing. For the record - I think David is an incredible talent, truly a great and I greatly look forward to seeing lots more of him in the coming years as I have no doubt we will. And offstage, to the extent I've talked to him, he is a super super nice, sincere really sweet humble kid that no one could dislike for a second. ANd as I said, I find the contrast between his conversational persona and his musical one very great and interesting. As he himself would be the first to tell you and he did tell me as reported last week:

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/showtracker/2008/07/idol-tracker-li.html

But there are lots of eight year olds and nannies who love him! Its not everyone who loves him, but there are lots of them.

So no hate, people! We all love David and we're all on the same side here!

Thanks for reading!
Richard

[Karen]

Richard, you might want to do some homework before you put your foot in your mouth. A recent poll on David Archuleta's fans reveals that 30% are male, 70% are female. The age breakdown is 30% aged 17 and under, 28% are 18-30, and 42% are 30+ years of age. Not quite the 8 year old girls and grannies only that you claimed. You're insulting a lot of rabid adult fans of David's out here including me.

I stopped listening to popular music 20+ years ago--until I heard David sing on the first week of Idol. I went to YouTube and watched the 27 videos of his there (19,000+ now) and that was it. I was a totally besotted fan. I decided if there was beauty in the world like THAT and I wasn't listening, I was a FOOL. No longer. I'm listening to popular music now and loving it, all thanks to David. Admittedly, 95% of it is David, but I'm also enjoying others like Natasha Bedingfield, Sara Bareilles, Jon Mayer, Jason Mraz, Eva Cassidy, and others I've found.

David Archuleta has the most exquisite vocals I've ever heard, and he connects with his songs and his audience in a very unreal way. He's going to be HUGE! In five years time, he'll be as big a household name as Celine Dion, trust me on this!

On another note, I like Carly but could never connect with her or her music. Sometimes she's pretty screechy. That's my other reservation. I'm going to the tour concert this Saturday so I'll see how she does in concert. It'll be interesting to see how all of them do.

The reason that I'm driving 300 miles one way, though, is only and specifically to hear David A. sing in person. I don't buy CDs but will buy everything he ever puts out. The last concert (other than the symphony) I went to was Edgar Winter in the 1980s, but I will NEVER miss an Archuleta concert from here on out if I have to crawl to it. I've never, EVER been a fan of any musician or celeb, but I am over the MOON for this kid. Love him and his beautiful, soaring, emotive voice. I'm a fan for life.

[aiman]

Syesha is the real deal... I saw the show last night and I was like WHOA... She freaking KILLED that "Listen" song. No wonder why they didn't let her sing it on American Idol. She would've won the whole thing. It was AMAZING and I never saw her get such a huge standing o while she was on the show. I mean the whole arena was screaming out of their minds and it was all because of how well she sang. I never thought somebody that good looking could sing that darn good. She's like a supermodel Whitney... I think I'm in love. Sorry Hess (or whatever her fiance's name is) She is drop dead gorgeous with the best pipes I've EVER heard on American Idol. Please people, when this show goes to your town, go and see it. You'll see what I'm talking about. It was just unbelievable. Oh yeah and there's the other 2 guys who came in 1st and 2nd too.

[rogers]

It's almost as if you type up what you think you might see and hear at an AI concert rather than what actually happened. I for one did not see one shred of tye-dye in the crowd. Did anybody else? Diehard Castro fans wear baby blue and to label them as hippies just because the boy himself is laid-back and deadlocked is bizarre and not a bit accurate. Are you a critic, or is writing fiction more your thing?

[Hannah]

I will be seeing the AI Live show when it comes to my town...St. Louis. Ihave to say that I am a 40 year old woman and I love David Archuleta, Carly Smithson and Brooke Whites music the most, but enjoy them all. David Archuletas voice is a pure quality of rare talent. Brooke and Carly also have phenomenal sounds. To think you can only attribute Davids fans to 8 year olds is a pure insult and shows you really don't know who any of the Idols fans are. You are just throwing out your own GUESS and it is a bad one so just give that up. You are entertaining but don't need to try to be rude or insulting.

[Coconutz4Jason]

Thanks for a great wrap-up of the show. I'm glad I searched out some last minute tickets and got pretty nice seats. I even had time to run out and get a baby blue T and ironed on some Dreadhead logos of Jason on the front and back. I had a feeling that everyone was going to shine at this show--it being L.A. and the Idols having a few shows under their belt.

I was not disappointed! This was a really fun show and I'd love to see it again. Chickeze sounded good right out of the gate. The crowd was really with the show. But Michael Johns really got them on fire. What a voice. Carly is just amazing, especially with that Evanesence song. Jason's set went by much too quickly for me, he was relaxed and in strong voice. Glad he too has a song we didn't see from the show. Really good rendition of Crazy. And Cook just owned it great encore of Billie Jean, my favorite of his.

Most surprising performance for me was Brook. Her Let It Be is fine but she really sounded great on Feist's 1-2-3-4 and Coldplay's Yellow. Great job Brook.

I tried to enjoy everyone, even those not my favorites. David A got the fans to their feet in an explosion of squeekage. And yes, I can confirm the huge squealing of little girls. Just the facts. David has an amazing voice.

The group numbers were skipable, use them as bathroom breaks. Would have been much nicer to fit in some duets.

Dreadhead #1856

[Wilton]

Wow. He didn't say it was ONLY 8 year olds and their grandmothers cheering for Archuleta, and his review of Archuleta's actual performance was positively glowing. Relax, Archuleta fans. There's no need to bombard everyone who doesn't say EXACTLY what you want to hear. Especially when so many Archuleta fans are so eager to make the exact same sort of generalization you're all railing against here with their stupid cougar comments regarding Cook.

[Cheryl]

Richard, once again you bring a tear to my eye. Thank your putting into words what I have struggled to define. This year, more than any other I have been touched by these Idols. I cannot wait to see the show and cannot wait to see their futures! Especially Carly.

[MARTE]

Iam also in my 50's,and i am truly a fan of David A. I Apreciate a perfect vocal sound,when i hear one.I think David will be as popular as Elvis was with the "ladies". Iam really excited to see this happening to him! I think He's the greatest singer i've heard even at such a young age. Those that have a good ear for great music,will appreciate David A. GO DAVID!!

[MARTE]

Iam also in my 50's,and i am truly a fan of David A. I Apreciate a perfect vocal sound,when i hear one.I think David will be as popular as Elvis was with the "ladies". Iam really excited to see this happening to him! I think He's the greatest singer i've heard even at such a young age. Those that have a good ear for great music,will appreciate David A. GO DAVID!!

[sherry]

And here they go again.
The Archuleta fans, proving themselves to be Claymates 2.0.
Hey, did you know that Clay Aiken's last album sold less than 200k?

[John]

Thanks for the review. I have to agree with your remarks on the Daughtry/Cook comments. My wife and I went to a Bon Jovi concert and Daughtry was the opening act. We were very disappointed in his stage presence. He seemed to work on perfecting the "pose" of a rocker, but that was not enough to carry his extremely weak vocals and slurring of the words. I, apparently, wasn't the only one who was very disappointed, no one around me was paying any attention to him at all. David Cook has the innate talent of connecting with his audience, and yet not copying or posing as anyone else. I expect great things from him.

[LBGrrl]

I attended the show, and I found David A's segment to be almost the lowest point of it (only Kristi Lee Cook's was duller). Everything he sings sounds the same--all miasma-filled ballads. Ugh! I agree that he has a gifted voice but that kid needs to learn some style that isn't closing his eyes and performing vocal gymnastics. And he's a dork. Sorry, but he is! He is so awkward and goofy. I couldnt even understand what he said last night, he just mumbles and giggles into the microphone. I am sure he is a nice boy, but I got over teen scream dreams a long time ago. His fans say "he's only 17"--well, so was Jordin Sparks, who was sweet without seeming childish and awkward. Thank God, at least he didn't ruin "Imagine" again.

The highlights of the show for me were David Cook and Michael Johns. I actually thought Michael Johns had an incredible set, and he really got the audience stirred from its Kristi Lee-induced stupor. And David Cook, he IS a rock STAR! I thought he was the most fun to watch and I see great things for him. I am so glad to have some real rockers in this show.

BTW, could American Idol possibly have a cheaper looking set? I realize this aint a U2 show but still...

[Susie]

Thanks for the great review. I can't wait to see the show when it comes near me. I'm especially looking forward to seeing David Cook, the REAL rocker! He's charismatic and connects with the audience unlike Daughtry who's always angst-ridden. It doesn't matter that Cook hasn't sold millions of CDs YET, there's the voice, stage presence and personality that can be compared and Cook wins hands down. But, don't tell the Daughtry fans, they actually think they're the hottest band in the country and the biggest superstars in the world. LOL!!!!

[Rayna]

Richard,
Many people touched on the fanbase age issue, so I'm not going to bring it up again. However, I was additionally disappointed to see that you didn't mention anything about David Archuleta's actual singing. I mean, come on. We've all seen the videos. The feeling David puts into each of his performances is incredible. Why didn't you talk about that? And from what I hear, Cook fans have even been saying that DA absolutely owned the night. I'm just saying that the boy deserves more credit.

[Becky]

Regarding Richard's response:

Perhaps the reason the young girls those age stood out to you is that children that age are completely obnoxious? Therefore, they scream from overexcitement, whereas the rest of David A's fans went to the tour to actually hear him SING.

Also, I am very disappointed at how you shoved ALL of the Idols' fans into limited categories. I would buy albums from David A., Jason Castro, and Carly Smithson. I'm a 20 year old female college student. So tell me, please... where do I fit in?

[cruzceleste]

Hi Richard, thanks for the review... I liked a lot your last article especially the conversation that you have with David Archuleta...

About the reaction that most of us have about the "8 years old and grandma"´s comment is that most of the media is dismissing Archuletas fans as little girls and only womans... so when we see a comment like the one in the article is easy to be taked for the wrong side....For my part, I´m 24 year old bussiness management college graduate...

Again thanks for your articles and keep soporting Archie, he is a sweet kid and we as his fans are kind osf overprotective over him

[Ely]

Mr. Rushfield,
It seems that you like David Archuleta but why such provocative comments about 8 year olds and grandmas? I am no 8 year old or a grandma and I am his fan for life. Why do I get this feeling each time I read a review by so-called journalists (who probably know nothing about music) that it is uncool to say wonderful things about David Archuleta's musicality on their reviews? They would always focus on his screeching and screaming fans but would never say why his fans are screaming for him. I will tell you why they are screaming. They love David Archuleta the person, his voice, and his music. David is also very humble, so adorable, and so sweet that there really is nothing to dislike about him as you pointed out.

David is so unassuming that he could care less what people like you say about him on your reviews. All he cares about is to do his best when he performs and each time he performs with his heart and soul, he is unstoppable, untouchable, unreachable. He is a true and geniune artist. For you to say that Carly is the best singer, I respect your opinion. But the reason Carly was voted off after Top 6 was she wasn't connecting with the people as much as the others. Yes, she is a good, technical singer but she lacks the spirit and the emotion that only David Archuleta can deliver. Anybody's singing is simply a noise to me, not music, when all they do is scream their songs just because they can sing high notes. David sings as if he is telling a story and he has great range. His tone and phrasing are out of this world. Have you watched "Don't Let The Sun Go Down" at the finale? The emotion and the soul that he put into that performance was so palpable even through the television screen. Never have I seen or witnessed such a thing on TV from anyone before. It was AMAZING-- for lack of a better word. His rendition of When You Say You Love Me is also in this category.

David's fans are all over the world now--from Singapore, Malaysia, Philippines, UK, Brazil, etc. Will you do us fans a favor? Before you write anything ignorant like that again, will you go to the "David Archuleta Fanblast" and NotingDavid.org? These two websites will help you get to know David Archuleta's true fanbase.

Also it is annoying, to say the least, each time so-called journalists say that David giggles like a 12 year old. Do you guys just say that to make it appear as if you're objective in your view? David laughs a lot because he said he likes to be happy. He likes to smile a lot because it makes him feel good and others around him. David laughs like a shy 17 year old, not a 12 year old. I hope you would stop the 12 year old references which you probably just picked up from other so-called journalists--because David is so mature. Have you seen his interviews after Idol? They're all in YouTube. He has so much wisdom at such a young age that would put adults like us to shame. So please do yourself a favor and us his fans a favor by doing your research before you write about someone, especially our beloved David Archuleta. You can never get away from doing a poorly written article without a backlash from us, faithful Archuleta fans.

[Kimberly]

Great review, Richard. Perfect. I had front row seats in San Diego and agree that Carly was fantastic. I have goosebumps all these days later thinking of her entrance and that song! WOW. She is officially the show-stealer.

Michael Johns, great things to await.

David Cook was great as I expected but I am, alas, as an official Cougar, over him. Maybe it was the price of those two front row tickets and my incessant screaming all season for him. One can get weary. He won, I was ecstatic, then something just changed which I won't get into now but every other Cougar out there knows what it is.

Great show, except for the intermission, the screaming 8 year olds for Archuletta and the Pop Tart guy with no Pop Tarts.

[Minnie]

I saw some DA hater up there. Why do people hate this kid?
I don't understand. He is wonderful and talented. I understand why his fan are being very active. DA is very sweet and connect with a lot of people. I know it is kinda annoying sometimes that the fans are so outspoken. But, there is no need to bash David
A lot of Cook fans get easily offensive too. I think all fan are similar. Be nice and fair people! Stop all the hating.
They are all great people.

[Bruce]

Everyone was great. Best group of talent. Overall voice, appearance, package I have to go with Kristy Lee Cook. Not a country fan, but I said she would sign, she signed and is only one of three. Although we all have opinions that is all they are, record labels know this industry better than we may although in some of our arrogance we tend to think we have so much wisdom. All were great, and fun, and appeal to a certain audience, buy have to give overall performance to Kristy.

[joey]

As a 37 year old male and father of 2 who lifts weights 5 days a week, a man that is so comfortable in his heterosexuality, let me tell you that DA has the best voice i've ever heard. My wife and I went to staples center last night just to see Archie perform in person. He sounds BETTER in person. I guarantee all that he will reach the level of fame that was occupied by Elvis Presley. During the past season of AI i made a vow to buy every cd he ever records and see him perform whenever he comes into town til my dying day!! He has motivated me to put my children in music classes. Here's praying he stays the humble gentle soul he is. His voice is once in a lifetime.

[sherry]

I had to laugh and then respond to the comment made by Kimberly three posts above.
That "thing" that happened wouldn't possibly be that Mr. Cook went (gasp!) on a date?
Seriously, that is laughable. If you are interested in someone's musical ability (and not a fantasy conjured up within your own mind that you might be the "cougar" for him), nothing has changed. It's not as if he forgot how to sing, can't recall how to play guitar, or suddenly revealed that he is from outer space.
Fans of any of these contestants (or artists in general) should be in it for the music once they pass junior high. But I digress....if that is one's mindset, a common sense perspective will most likely not change it. On the other hand, one's fantasy could be continually fed until a wedding band appears (and more often than not, even after that).
On the subject of the review, thank you, Mr. Rushfield. It seems as though Mr. Cook, Mr. Castro, Mrs. Smithson and Mr. Johns will not disappoint me in September when I finally get to see them live.

[sherry]

I'm sorry. One more comment and I swear I will be done.
In response to Minnie two posts above. I don't see any posts where anyone says they hate David Archuleta. Just because someone may not find his musical stylings or stage presence to be their cup of tea doesn't equate hatred. It simply means they don't like that type of music and they are permitted to have their own opinions and like what they like.
Also, there is a fine line between being an active fan base and being a fan base that makes a nuisance of themselves whenever they feel their favorite has been slighted in any way (even when they haven't). And, while I have seen that type of behavior on occasion from David Cook fans, it is nowhere near the level that the Archuleta fans seem to take it. If anything, the Cook fans seem to be a LOT more low key and don't seem to feel the need to comment on every single thing that is said. And, if you don't think a rabid and obnoxious fan base can do more harm than good, just ask Clay Aiken and Taylor Hicks. Those fans beat ALL fans when it comes to defending their favorite (they just don't seem to want to buy their albums - or maybe they are and it's just the rest of the world who won't).

[hanariffin]

richard, i feel sad reading as your generalizations of the crowd proved to be offensive to so many. perhaps the descriptions shouldnt include the age of people involved? i also feel that you haven't stepped away from the American Idol TV show when Simon called DA's fans as teenies and grannies. really. seriously.

however, i agree that this bunch are really special and better than previous ones.

[KathyH]

Richard, thank you for an article that was positive about every season 7 Idol. Thank you, too, for the clarification about what you think of David Archuleta's fanbase and about him, in general.

David's gift is his song. He'll get better at the speaking -- and his fans love his humility and shyness because we love him. Something happened during the season, and I became a SERIOUS fan for the first time in probably 15 years. (Yes, I'm cougar-age and a housewife -- I'm even from the Kansas City area. Although Cook is brilliant and personable, it is Archuleta who fascinates me.) I'm wondering -- I suppose I haven't paid this much attentiion to other stars and I certainly haven't often caught them at the start of their careers -- but how often do the great musicians also have a strong ability to speak in public? How often is it necessary? Certainly the Idols are expected to make a certain appearance and David Cook makes a fine spokesman for the group. Outside of the Idol world, however, stars perform on tour with sprinklings of thank you's and anecdotes in between. David handles this very well -- especially those thank-yous. At a certain level, stars are expected to appear on talk shows. David has handled his appearances well, too, in my opinion. (He's best when he's interviewed alone, because he tends to step back if he can.) No, he isn't as eloquent as his buddy Cook, nor as intentionally funny as Michael Johns, but he expresses himself with a pleasing humility and honesty. To my mind, some of the best talk show appearances are those in which the stars are the most themselves. I'm not sure I see a problem with David Archuleta, even in this regard.

[Rockin bad boy]

You hit the nail on the head with the David C/Daughtry comparison. David has the potential to rock this world. Daughtry will be remembered for alot of things...but I dont beleive it will be his voice.

Now, having said that...Brooke is my girl. Thanks

[rita]

Mr. Rushfield,
Just so you know... i'm 41 yrs old, a mom to 3 boys and i am a professional here in the philippines with a college degree. i am a BIG FAN of David Archuleta and i'm from across the planet!
to ms. sherry, i just find it strange and contradicting that you espouse the rights of people who do not find David Archueta's style to be their "cup of tea" TO VOICE THEIR OPINIONS and in the same breath call David Archuleta's fans "a nuisance" and label them "obnoxious" for DOING THE SAME THING!! It also seems weird to me that if you find us, his fans, as such, then why do you seem so interested in what we do?!

[rossrich66]

NIce Review! I saw the show and as I read this it made me smile as you we're pretty spot-on in your reviews.

This is coming from a guy who refused to watch American Idol until last year. Well my return this year was "worth the price of admission". This year's finalists as you put it, were special and it was great to watch their journey.

Definitely, the most squeekey clean concert I've ever been to, but it definitely the most unique in that it really feels like have you a bond with them...and that's what made the show so great.

[dlpf]

It sounds so wonderful. And they aren't coming anywhere near Denver because the DNC is hogging the venues for the next 2 months of convention preparations. Boo hoo.

[Ely]

Mr. Rushfield,
I owe you an apology for the last comment I made. I was in my most severe state of O.D.D. (Obsessive David Disorder) while I was furiously typing away my comment. For some reason, the computer in my brain somehow mixed up articles I've read somewhere about David giggling like a 12 year old which to me is very disrespectful and irritating, to say the least. Someone else wrote that and not you. So I am sorry for my mistake.

[maturin]

Richard, love your review, it was charming, as they have been all season.

I love David A, but boy, do I feel sorry for him about his fanbase. It's not his fault, but this year he has fallen heir to the worst of Idolfandom, like Clay and Taylor before him.

ArchiePeople: the problem is not what age you are, it's your psycho behavior. Every online discussion of the show now features:

50%: normal discussion of singers they like
50%: hysteric Archie fans working themselves into a state of sad, overwrought upset over some perceived slight.

Anyway, Mr. Rushfield, your articles reveal you had a great time with this season, like so many of us! Thanks for the funny, over the top, semi-poetic, epic reviews of America's favorite goofy, awesome singing contest.

[Faye]

Richard, I love your writing and think you did such a wonderful job with this article!

Regarding your comment about David Archleta's audiences, I believe that he was the favorite of many of the youngest and oldest voters. But I didn't think you meant that they constituted his whole voting bloc exclusively. I personally am 65 years old and my three favorites were David Cook, Jason Castro and David Archuleta (and in that order).

You are so right about this season of Idols and their greatness. I have always loved music but have never been so excited as I was watching this season of talented singers.

Please keep up the good work!!!!!!!!

[KandKL]

Good God, some fans are touchy.

I liked your review, Richard. Very honest. Don't let the sensitive Archie fans throw you off.

[Annie]

Boy, Mr. Rushfield, you sure stirred up a nest of hornets, didn't you? (Thanks, by the way, for clarifying your comments.)

It is interesting to step back and objectively read the Davids' fans reactions. They do not seem to realize that in many cases, both sides are equally provocative AND equally defensive...and, I guess, accusatory sometimes too. That little swipe just seems to creep in there somehow.

But frankly, I really don't think there was ever much of a competition between our Davids; I say this for two reasons. First, IMHO, I think David A. was only in competition with himself. It just seems that this is who he is as a person. Go to YouTube and check out his reaction to Simon’s claim that there were nineteen miserable contestants after he sang Imagine; he applauded the other contestants. Or his reaction after another of Simon’s comments that anyone would sound better than the last song. DA said, “I liked Jason’s song.” (…Yes, I have become a YouTube junkie because I cannot get enough of this year’s idols. They ARE a special group!)

Not only that, DC has told us often that he loves DA like a little brother, and it is evident in their interactions and interviews. DC is a class act who continually promotes the younger David and shares any idol adulation with him. As an aside, I LOVED reading in one review of the LA concert that during the meet and greet afterwards, the Davids were never more than 10 feet away from each other. Doesn’t it seem like our DC is watching over our Archie?

As I said, the competition may have never begun, but if it did, it is certainly over now for the Davids. So can we honor the boys and let ours end too? Notice that I have not commented on their singing abilities; that is because I think who they are as people is far more important than anything. I am a HUGE David fan...the word 'obsession' comes to mind at this moment. However, I can certainly see the greatness of the other David too. I will be a fan of both for life, but for different reasons for each.

P.S. Sherry...thanks for (maybe) clearing up that 'one thing' confusion for me. I did wonder…

[Steven Miles]

Here's my ranking;

The mighty;
Archuleta. Wow. Something takes over him & he turns into a man when he's performing. Sings through his heart & boy can he SING! He sounds better live then he does on TV. He's a pro.
Jason Castro. Fantastic set! Was in great voice. Love his tone & falsetto. Great musician, very authentic & in tune with his style. Follows his gut, I like that.
Carly Smithson & Michael Johns blew the roof off! Their vocals were on FIRE.

The solid;
Syesha. I FINALLY felt some emotion from her! Hallelujah! Vocally superb but she still lacks something...originality, genuinity...? I'm not sure.
Brooke White. Pretty voice & lovely song choices.
Eze. Full of energy. Great vocals! He's very underrated but I suppose I can see why; his style is not exceptionally original.

The ok;
Cook; I think he has a great voice but the 'rockstar' vibe he was trying to give off wasn't doing it for me. Seemed very rehearsed and unatural. The crowd loved him though.
KLK; pretty voice, sexy performer but she's no Carrie or Kellie.
Ramiele; She is cute & quirky but needs time to grow, perfect the art of projecting her voice, learn about her style etc.

Overall: Fantastic night.

[GaryK]

Come on Richard, isn't it about time that you reveal that you are actually a publicist for AI, and not really a journalist. I find it hard to belive that you could not find one neutral, let alone negative, thing to say about anyone who performed. There is more honest reporting in "Tiger Beat".

[Trish]

Even though I am a huge Cook fan, I was extemely impressed with David Archuleta. He's really grown up since the show. For all you fans offended by Richards comments of 8 year olds and grandmothers. I see it as a compliment as to the extent of his fan base which RANGES from 8 year olds to grandmothers. Really people... must everything be spelled out for you?

[Onioneater]

I'm a 43 year old with a Ph.D and I LOVE Archie! I'm neither an 8-year old or a grannie. WRONG! This kid will be (IS) a huge star.

[Sandy]

Hey Richard,

Great review. This has definitely been a wonderful AI season. But I must correct you on one issue. David Archuleta's fans are not just 8 year old and teens. VERY WRONG. I am in my mid fourties, my husband and friends in the low fifties (not grandmothers) who grew up listening to various styles of music and David Archueleta has not only captured our heart and admiration with his voice, but I have not stopped watching his videos from his live tour. He is really amazing and only 17. In case you have not seem most of the interviews, he is holding up a lot better than all the Idols. He has more fans than he ever imagined. Great job for Cook to treat him like his younger brother and the rest of the idols to protect him from all his fans of ALL AGES. We are all so lucky to be able to share all 10 Idol's talents this year. They are a tough act to follow. I have never voted before and never even wanted to go to an AI concert and I already bought tickets and was in Vegas and going to the Altantic City show as well.
I can't wait to hear those incredible voices and see the new singing younger role model to all of us David Archuleta. YEAH! They will all do very well, that is a guarantee. What a nice break to be able to take your children and see, even little ones and very old folks at an American Idol concert. WHOWHO!!

[Dan]

Aww, lay off with the claymate bashing. They were new to this Idol thing 5 years ago. The Archulettards have no excuse. They have all of the others that came before them to learn from.

All of the idols have over the top fantards. All of them have fans of all ages including very young to very old. ALL OF THEM.

[Amanda]

Archuleta fans really need to get over themeselves. Big deal, you're not eight. WE GET IT! 70 people do not need to comment on the article saying they are not eight. The article didn't even say that all of his fans were grandmother's or eight year olds. That is just what you all assumed it was saying when it mentioned that there were eight year olds and grandmothers in the crowd. Really, get over yourselves. Each of the contestants has fans of a variety of ages.
The part about Kristy Lee being better than Carrie just made me laugh. She has no where near the talent Carrie has. She may be a sweet girl with a pretty voice, but she will never be as amazing as Carrie is.

[Chris]

Great review! However, David Cook has many fans that are not just teenagers! We who are in our 30's 40's 50's 60's on up appreciate his enormous talent and were there to cheer him on.

I take issue with the person that said David Cook would no come close to Chris Daughtry. First of all I am a huge Daughtry fan and love him and have seen him in concert several times. However, David Cook has a talent and voice that not even Daughtry can match. His range is phenominal, and he does have the stage presence and personality to boot. This person was obviously not at the Staples Center Monday night nor saw any of the American Idol performances over the last few months. Cook delivered Monday night and was on point.

Has this person listened to David Cook's solo release Analog Heart from 2006? I think not. If this person had you would not have made the comment about Cook compariing him to Daughtry. Cook has already proven himself, we now as fans are just getting the taste of what is to come.

He has already been in a couple of bands before he went solo. Listen to Axiiom music the band he was with for a few years. Or his first band that he was with. He has talent and he is fast becoming a star to be reckoned with.

Once he releases is album that he is currently working on, although I have no clue why since he could re-release Analog Heart and it would sell out in a minute, it is that good, he will be rewarded by breaking his own records.

Don't get me wrong, i will go and see Daughtry every chance I get and still be a fan and buy his new CD when it comes out, but when you have the creativity and talent that Cook had to take songs and put a new spin on them or look for the most creative arangement and deliver them the way he did , well he has fan for life in me.

If anyone gets a chance go to the American Idols concert, it is one of the best! I have been to now 3 of them in the past few years and this was by far the best bar none, even the year Chris Daughtry performed and I was mezmorized. This is a very talented group of performers and artists. Enjoy!

[Roberts]

I just can't help but me amazed, or appalled, by some of the comments here:

sherry | July 09, 2008 at 01:22 AM, suddenly you're attacking a "cougar" has been, who now turns her head against Cook. Why ? Are you bitter? Cook losts one fan and maybe more Cougars.

Maturin | July 09, 2008 at 08:05 AM, didn't you know that the fans of the Beatles and Elivis Presley, they screamed as hard as David A's fans, maybe much harder. Put that is the same analogy, then what does not make David A. A superstar!!! No, a megastar.

[ymbcastrofan]

Richard,
Thanks for the article. It's good to read updates about the tour. I would like to have heard more from you about Jason Castro's performance and the reaction of the audience to his music. Jason is my favorite Idol contestant of all time. I think he has the most unique style of any of the contestants from any season, and he exemplifies what Idol was originally about - that is, finding everyday people with raw undeniable talent, who otherwise would have taken longer to get discovered. Also, it should be noted that Jason's music and carefree style appeal to more than the hippie-like Dreadheads. His fan base is much broader and deeper than that. I'm a 54 year old black woman from Georgia and I can't get enough of him. Jason's voice is very soft and pure, yet sensual and soothing. It draws you in emotionally. In addition, Jason's guitar skills are awesome and he is oh so easy on the eyes! He just needs to develop a little more confidence for live performances to boost his stage presence. And can I say again how beautiful Jason is to look at? Can you imagine the effect he will have on women of all ages when he finally realizes his true power? Wow! What a superstar he will be! Viva Jason Castro! As for the other Idols, I think David A has one of the best voices I've ever heard, however, he needs to continue to work on his confidence on and offstage. He has a more pleasing voice than David C, but David C has more confidence and showmanship. David C has a broader octave range and knows how to work the stage to connect with live audiences. I can't wait to see them all (but especially Jason) when the show comes to Georgia in August.

[sherry]

Roberts | July 09, 2008 at 06:26 PM
I think you should read the comment to which I was responding. It certainly is not I who am bitter.

[Fresh Maker]

Hi RR,

I saw the Staple show and it was 80 to 90% awesome.

Here are my crib notes-

1. Chikezie- great singing and moving
He was so happy to be on stage that you could help but like him .

2. Ramiiele- maybe I should take the advice of Thumper's mom and be quiet because I have nothing nice to say. The opening of "I Want You Back" was so bad, that I went to the snack bar. Budweiser was giving away free popcorn and soda to the designated drivers. Thanks, Bud!.

3. KLC- good idea to give away T shirts. her Cowgirl song was a tad raunchy for the kiddies.

4. Michael- good stadium rocker. He has to be careful about being smarmy.

5. Carly- simply awesome, born to sing

6. Brooke- very charming and engaging singer.

Group sing- touching

7. Jason Castro- why I bought the ticket for the show. Entertaining, so happy on stage, the crowd loved hm.

8. Syesha- serviceable pop, Broadway bound

9. David A- I can see why people like him but I don't, sorry

10. David C-excellent singing, worked the crowd

last group number- fun and spunky

[joey]

For all you haters (jealous) out there..... Archie's Army will have his back now and forever. When is the last time a 17 year old came along with the god-given voice and talent this kid has? Justin Timberlake? Ha ha ha. JT's a good performer but sounds mediocre in concert. David A is yet to hit a note off-key. Stand tall soldiers! Archie's Army unite and conquer!!!

[Daisy]

Another great review, RR. Good to know that the Dreadheads were in full force! I will respectfully disagree that Carly is the best female singer on AI, but maybe she will change my mind when I see her live. :)

Daisy DH# 1628

[Lacey]

So to the person (rogers) who commented about not seeing anyone at the AI concert at the Staples Center wearing a tye-dye shirt you are wrong. I was there and literally right in front of me sat a pre-teen girl wearing a tye-dye shirt and was absolutely in love with Jason Castro.

[mary Rizzo]

Hey Richard,

I have been wanting to write to you since this season of American Idol started. This was my first year watching the show, and feel like you do that Carly is the best singer I ever heard. I can't believe everyone doesn't think so. Where can I send a comment to you or your paper so I don't take up a lot of time here?

[Tia]

I went to the show last night in sacramento and I have to disagree on a few things!

Carly wasnt THAT great, infact my friends and I found her a little boring and her accent had dissapeard! we were like, wtf?

You obviously havent heard Daughtrys cd otherwise there is no way you could honestly say david cook is better, david cook is better than the other idol winners, but not chris daughtry. If it wasnt for chris daughtry, david probz wouldnt have made it as far as he did.

LIke someone else said, you didnt mention the band! I thought they were better than the performers!!

All in all it was a good night! Oh., but I do wnna give props to lil David, I was never a huge fan but OMG he stole the show!! He comes across as alot more confident in person than he did on tv and his set was awesome. Im like., why didnt he choose good songs on the show like he did at the concert! He was simply amazing and he stills seems insanely humble and down to earth.

[BeckyE]

I attended this concert and would like to suggest to the IDOLS tour director that if they could possibly choose more familiar (i.e., popular) songs for Chickieze, Ramiele, Kristy Lee, Carly, and Syesha, it would improve audience participation and the entire feel of the concert. These five sets of songs were boring and it was reflect in the audience response (or lack thereof).

Michael Johns set was outstanding; he hit the notes in Dream On amazingly and the audience went wild with appreciation. Except for the cutesy and unpopular second song of her set, I thought Brooke's set was also one of the more engaging performances of the night, especially her rendition of Yellow. I enjoyed Archie's and Jason's sets also, although only Jason brought something new to and unexpected in his rendition of Gnarls Barkley's Crazy; which he performed surprisingly well.

Cook's set was just outstanding; even his "Magic Rainbow" song sounded good. I thought My Hero and Hello were the superior songs of this set and he really works his guitar with the Foo Fighters hit. Although I've never watched AI before, except for this season's finale, I felt this singers put on a pretty good concert and I would more than likely go see them perform again, if given the chance.

[Sara Lou]

"Love" David Cook and "Love" Chris Daughtry...
Why the comparisons when both rockers are loved by so many??? I have been to many Daughtry concerts and Chris is amazing. His vocals are pure and intense! Fans are on there feet. David Cook is going to shine like a super star all on his own without being compared to anyone else..

[LearnToRead]

Wait a minute, here! It seems like a lot of DA Fans here are misreading the article. Now, they seem to be complaining like 8 year olds and over-reacting without further understanding of the article.

Rushfield said, "Eight-year-olds were there to screech their lungs out for David Archuleta, while their grandmothers nodded approvingly."

The author was merely describing who were the ones "screeching" their lungs out. A very young person has more capability to screech her lungs out than an older person. And of course the very young ones would likely have grandmother along with them. I don't think the author is describing the entire fanbase. He heard shrieking and he looked around and saw what looked like to be 8 year olds who were shrieking their lungs out so this makes a lot of sense. Most mature audience even the mature teens would not shriek their lungs out in the middle of the slow serious song (pop/rock song maybe but most likely not a ballad song). When I saw Archie's WYSYLM video, there were trickles of shrieks from what sounded like very young girls and I know adults have complained about their shrieking because they could not hear the song.

The author said, "Teenagers thrilled to champion David Cook's hard-rock numbers."
So again, he looked at the teens around him and described their reaction to David Cook's performance. He wasn't describing the entire fanbase of Cook as teens because we all know that David Cook have older fans. The author merely observed the teenagers who looked thrilled about Cook's hard-rock numbers which makes a lot of sense. See some stats below---

http://www.usatoday.com/life/television/news/2008-05-19-idol-davids_N.htm
Last week before finale stats below---

Age 13-19
Archuleta: 58%
Cook: 42%

Ages 20 to 29
Archuleta: 31%
Cook: 69%

Ages 30 to 39
Archuleta: 22%
Cook: 78%

Ages 40 to 49
Archuleta: 25%
Cook: 75%

Ages 50 to 59
Archuleta: 29%
Cook: 71%

Ages 60 to 69
Archuleta: 36%
Cook: 64%

Ages 70 +
Archuleta: 48%
Cook: 52%

All ages
Archuleta: 29%
Cook: 71%

Source: USA TODAY survey; analysis by Anthony DeBarros

[Joanne]

Whoa! That one line about David Archuleta seems to have ignited a stick of dynamite! As a middle-aged adult (but not a grandma), I adore David and picked him as my fave from the first week. I took no exception to the "eight-year olds" comment nor to any other comment. I believe the entire article was very well written and equally complimentary to every one of the Idols. Thanks, Richard, for one of the nicest articles I have ever read about American Idol. You are truly a "class act" and I hope you continue to treat the public with your excellent articles. I hope every Idol gets a chance to read your article because it will do them proud!

[Catherine]

On the whole, I agree with your review. But I will happily look you in the eye and tell you Carly is not the best singer in Idol history. I found her painful to listen to. She yells and pushes her voice to the limit, unnecessarily. No nuance to her performance, just one setting - loud.

[Joy]

Well...I AM a Grandma...as is my sister-in-law, and we both love DA. Although we hoped that he'd win the title, we knew that even if he didn't, it wouldn't be the last we'd hear from him. His vocal talent is so amazing that it was a given that some recording company would want to pick him up. We are both looking forward to purchasing his CD. My 38yo daughter, 17yo grand-daughter and 18yo son loved DC. It all comes down to what kind of music you like. For instance, the song that I like the best from DC is Music of The Night. I was actually shocked that he could sing so well. I downloaded it the next day and listen to it all the time on my way to work as well as DA's songs...it's my kind of music. I love BIG songs with BIG voices and a message..like Celine Dion's and Josh Groban's. I thought the review was great. I only wish that I hadn't given into my "screeching fans" phobia and gone to the AI Concert when it was here in Tacoma. It sounds like I would have been able to hear the show after all. Oh well...guess I'll have to wait until DA is touring solo.

[Gail]

This summer, like a fiendish sports fan, I’ve been tracking American Idol online music statistics. As of this writing, Jason’s MySpace page views are crazy high at over 5.4 million, well above ALL other Season 7 Idols (sorry Cookie!). Plus Bob Dylan and James Taylor.

I have a soft spot for not-yet-cynical, first-generation Americans, willing to take a risk and aspire against the odds. After graduating with HS honors and scoring 1340 on his SATs, Jason risked a full A & M scholarship to follow his musical passion. He taught himself to play the guitar and sing on a park bench across from his dorm. Unlike the other top 10, he only sang five times in public prior to auditioning for AI. Recently Variety wrote that Jason has the potential to be “Adult Contemporary Gold.” I, for one, will be tracking his success.

[Genna]

Wow, thank you so much for writing a review! I am going to the American Idols Live Concert in Philadelphia on August 13th. I am so excited to go, and I am searching everywhere for reviews just for fun :) My favorites from the beginning were David Cook<3 Michael Johns, and Carly Smithson. They are amazing. I am most anxious to see the following songs from each: The Amazing and HOT David Cook do "Billie Jean" in person, Sexy Aussie Michael John's "We Will Rock You/Champions" medley (I know he has to have an awesome stage presence) Powerhouse Carly's rendition of "Bring Me To Life", Adorable David Archuleta with the great song "Apologize", Smiley Brooke with "Let it Be" in person, Cute little Ramiele with "If I Never See Your Face Again", Soulful Chikezie with "So High", Pretty Syesha with "Listen" Laid-back Jason with his own version of Gnarls Barkley's awesome song "Crazy, and finally *my least favorite" Country Kristy Lee with "Squeezin' The Love Outta You" But I am so PSYCHED to see my favorite ten singers in person :] American Idol is my addiction, and is my favorite thing in the world. =]
-Genna

[Jim Lacey]

Just back from the Houston leg of the tour, which I'm sorry to report was not just disappointing but actually bordered on boring.

This was not the fault of the performers but of a stage set that was as unimaginative as it was insultingly cheap -- a split level affair of plywood, painted flat black. The performers accessed the stage from behind and below stage level, climbing up a set of stairs and then corralled through a set of aluminum chutes of the variety that are used to control long lines of people in line buying tickets.

Jim Lacey
In fact, that's exactly how it appeared: that the same chutes used for crowd control earlier later doubled as the the principle part of the set.

Jason Castro stole the show. The guy is not a great singer, but he is mesmerizing in an unusual kind of way. He doesn't do well in the higher registers, yet he insists on doing that high register thing he does at the end of songs, seriously damaging the otherwise enjoyable performance he puts in. He wants to be a better singer than he is, and gets credit for trying to be, but he doesn't understand we don't care about his voice as much as we do about the voices of others.. It's him we like. He could've won this thing if he'd just understood that.

Carly was a close second and easily has the best understanding of communicating with an audience. She showed a mastery of covering the whole stage, exhibiting ownership of it under absolute poise. She loved it, we sensed it, and we loved her back. Contestants, take heed! Everyone has something to learn from Carly's control of a stage -- and therefore control of an audience.

I didn't believe it was possible for Archuleta to be anything but spectacular, and on one number he did sing the b***S off some tune (a new one I didn't recognize, perhaps "Crush," his first single?), but he seemed frankly exhausted and somewhere else than aware of the 12,000 screaming adoring fans who gave him arguably the single largest ovation of the night, which registered 12 decibels above the absolute maximum threshold of pain.

In a moment of the poorest stage direction I've ever witnessed at any concert in my life, Archuleta rose from below stage on a hydrolic life, behind a grand piano. Here was this magical and magnificent kid, a one-of-a-kind human of the variety we get once every 20 years, who placed no less than #2 in the competition, and he spends his first 6 minutes absolutely hidden from the crowd.

All show long, 12,000 screaming fans, mostly waiting to see him and Cooke, get to see Archie at last, but only his head -- and that, just barely.

This very anti-climatic oversight, if it was one, was unforgivable. It seemed frankly intentional to me, designed to diminish his presence in preparation for Cooke's appearance that followed, and whose entrance by comparison was prefaced by a fanfare that all but seemed to herald the second coming.

Cooke, meanwhile, who can suffer from attacks of arrogance, suffered his worst ever.

Unlike Archuleta, he did know where he was -- exactly -- in front of 12,000 screaming Idol fans. Incredibly, he threw a monkey wrench into not only his performance but the whole rhythm of the whole show, stopping it to ask that the house lights to be turned on so he could video the screaming "for posterity" (and his ego), then pausing no fewer than 3 additional times to drink cola (long night, ya know, 4 long songs to sing, whew, did we actually expect him to get through 4 grueling tunes and no cola?).

He was also his usual unkempt self, appearing in a t-shirt that looked like he'd had it on since the tour began several weeks ago. I left during his outrageous video stunt, the onus for which I also put on the stage director who allowed it. I was totally disgusted that what should have been the top 2 performances had been dashed first by poor stage direction that played down Archuleta's initial appearance, a cheap set, and then a quick downward spiral as the champ proceeded to dethrone himself.

Others were leaving too -- and Cooke noticed. He was foolish to call it to the attention of the rest of the audience. Let's hope it serves as a wake up call to Cooke, who'd have been wiser to say nothing and reflect instead on why it happened.

An agent -- if Cooke is able to condescend to hiring one -- will correct his stage attitude and put his future focus where it belongs -> on the audience instead of on himself.

I loved Sayesha. She and Brooke and Chekezie were delights and were the glue of the show, Brook and Chekezie especially. Sayesha's got it all...great beauty, great pipes, and that knock-out figure, but she needs a voice instructor who will teach her to soften up. When you mostly belt it exhausts the listener, hard to explain. Hope she'll get a coach that corrects this because when she's on her game, she's up there close to Archuleta and Cooke.

Finally, to you, American Idol, you disappointed big time. You let your cast down. The set was abominable. The sparkles and other background stuff you ran on the rear projection screens was garbage, plain and simple. Your cast deserved more -- a great deal more.

You should be ashamed to be collecting the monies you're raking in and then sending out your ambassadors to extol you on such a pittance. Sound crew did a great job and, as always, the musicians were tops.