'FNL': To recap, it's been hit and miss

First of all, what's with the goofy, soapy mid-episode recap, sponsored by J.C. Penney?

I realize that embedded advertising is the future in a DVR world. But, please, I don't need to be told what's just happened in the first half-hour of "Friday Night Lights."

The show has me at "hello"! The corporate-sponsored recaps are both no big deal and a microcosm of a sophomore jinx, demeaning a quality show with faux intrigue.

The beauty of "FNL" last year was its tableaux of small-town life, inside of which roamed these characters on divergent paths of discovery. All of this felt unhurried and naturalistic, told in quickly glimpsed gestures and flavorful shots of Dillon, Texas, as much as dramatic events.

But Dillon has been receding of late, replaced by the will-he-or-won't-he return of Coach Taylor, and the murder/will-they-or-won't-they-consummate pas de deux between high school hottie Tyra and nerd-savant Landry.

He will, and they did. Next week, "FNL" teased in coming attractions, the body of Tyra's stalker will be recovered, and Landry, who did the deed, will begin to feel that night closing in.

Didn't the show used to tell us that hardscrabble small-town Texas life got writ large on the football field? This season it's been writ large in a writers room, with the network on a notes call, wondering if there isn't some way to raise the stakes (i.e., ratings).

Football used to be the show's religion, but lately it feels like just another after-school activity. Let us, however, also go in praise of story lines. Buddy Garrity's plea to Coach Taylor to return to Dillon played out convincingly in a truck stop, setting up the payoff at the end. And Lila's born-again Christianity in the wake of her parents' separation and the breakup with Street is also a winner.

Last night, emoting jock-hunk Tim Riggins also flirted with a closer relationship with God, until it turned out he was just flirting with Lila, using God as his wingman. Too harsh? Maybe Riggins really did feel something in that church. Regardless, as he perused the worshipers and the camera followed, a missing piece of the show's spirit had returned.

Photo: NBC

-- Paul Brownfield

Comments

[DA in LA]

The shark has been jumped.

Three shows in and it is a shell of its former self.

I'm done

[-TM]

I'm not sure how you can say it's 'jumped the shark.'

The show is not all that different from last season, and the third episode, which showed the first football game of the year for the Panthers, was a solid effort, and stronger than plenty of first season episodes. The acting, and plenty of the storylines, continue to make it one of the finest dramas on network television. The murder sub-plot is indeed slightly troubling and over-dramatic, but one misguided effort to beef-up the melodrama isn't a reason to abandon the show.

[DA in LA]

It is not "one" misguided effort to beef-up the melodrama, but several.

Each scene is dripping with conflict. All the characters do now is scream and argue. Most characters are now acting completely different than the characters I enjoyed last season.

The murder subplot is just one example of a show that has gone completely off the rails.

[YMMP]

DA in LA - Have you ever had anything nice to say to anyone or about anything?