Show Tracker: What you're watching

Main | Yelow »

'Gilmore Girls': Maybe now stupid Cupid will leave these girls alone

12:38 PM PT, Feb 14 2007

There was no love lost on Tuesday's episode of "Gilmore Girls," which culminated in the moment die-hard fans of the show have been waiting for since the fall -- the moment Lorelai would finally give Christopher the boot.

Still, in what should have been at least a bittersweet ending between Lorelai and Rory's come-and-go father, there was only relief. Not because she could go comfortably back to longtime love and fan favorite Luke, but because now there might be redemption for her character, who used to be defined by her quippy intelligence but lately has become a dull vehicle for romantic angst.

The show's truly fatal flaw -- one which extends well into last season when creator Amy Sherman-Palladino was still at the helm -- is that Lorelai (Lauren Graham) and Rory (Alexis Bledel) have become functions of their romances and little else. And worse, the men in their lives are not worthy of the Gilmores' attention.

Christopher (David Sutcliffe) was doomed from the beginning. His marriage to Lorelai couldn't last, considering that the writers never let him develop into anything more than the anti-Luke.

Luke (Scott Patterson) wears plaid and hangs with the quirky locals. Christopher hails from a J. Crew catalog and counted Lorelai as his one friend in town. Luke has a small TV in his apartment. Christopher outfitted Lorelai's house with an HD. Luke stalled in planning his nuptials with Lorelai. Christopher pushed her to elope in Paris.

Instead of a person unto himself, Christopher was only a perfect foil to the guy the series has built up as Lorelai's love interest since season one.

It also makes no sense for Rory, once earnestly ambitious, to be smitten with Logan, a trust-fund baby whose defining characteristic is his wealth. He's barely a shadow of Dean or Jess, flawed boyfriends with less sheen and more substance.

There are small signs the show could be shifting away from painting the Gilmore Girls as lovesick know-nothings. Rory's got eyes for a teaching assistant more her speed -- a sign that Logan might also hit the road? And Lorelai is single once more.

Del.icio.us!

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/816965/17830938

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference 'Gilmore Girls': Maybe now stupid Cupid will leave these girls alone:


Add a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In






ADVERTISEMENT


About the Blogger
Our Bloggers

Mary McNamara is a Los Angeles Times TV critic who tracks "Grey's Anatomy," "The Sopranos" and "House."

Richard Rushfield is a Los Angeles Times staff writer who tracks "American Idol."

Matea Gold, Maria Elena Fernandez, Lynn Smith, Greg Braxton, Kate Aurthur and Martin Miller are Los Angeles Times staff writers who track news.

Robert Lloyd is a Los Angeles Times TV critic who tracks reviews and other television oddities.

Scott Collins is a Los Angeles Times columnist who tracks news.

Denise Martin is a freelance writer who tracks "The Hills," "Ugly Betty" and "Top Chef."

Sheigh Crabtree is a Los Angeles Times staff writer who tracks news and "America's Best Dance Crew."

Stephanie Lysaght is a Los Angeles Times staff writer who tracks "So You Think You Can Dance" and reports on "American Idol."

Claire Zulkey is a freelance writer who tracks "America's Next Top Model," "30 Rock," "So You Think You Can Dance," "Dexter" and "The Office."

Geoff Berkshire is a writer for Metromix.com who tracks "The Shield" and "Rescue Me."

Patrick Day is a Los Angeles Times staff writer who tracks "Big Love," "24" and "Lost."

Jevon Phillips is a Los Angeles Times staff writer who tracks "Battlestar Galactica," "Heroes" and "America's Best Dance Crew."

Paul Brownfield is a Los Angeles Times staff writer who tracks "Friday Night Lights."

Margaret Wappler is a Los Angeles Times staff writer who tracks "Project Runway" and "Mad Men."

Lora Victorio is a Los Angeles Times staff writer who tracks "Project Runway."

Chris Barton is a Los Angeles Times staff writer who tracks "The Wire."

Sarah Rogers is a freelance writer who tracks "Dancing With the Stars."

Enid Portuguez is a Los Angeles Times staff writer who tracks "Gossip Girl."


Subscribe
to Blog:
MyLATimes
More RSS Readers