Readers' Representative Journal

A conversation on newsroom ethics and standards

« Previous Post | Readers' Representative Journal Home | Next Post »

Reporter responds to those upset by Christmas cat tale

Bess_the_christmas_day_catThe Dec. 25 story of Bess the cat hit feline lovers in wildly different ways.

More than 50 readers said they were touched by the tale. But almost 40 others were quite angry -- angry enough that reporter Kim Murphy was moved to write a note to those who were upset (see below).

Reader Donn Walker of St. Louis was one who sent praise: "I want you to know how enormously touched I was by your story today about Bess. As a longtime cat lover -- with a beautiful feline who looks just like Bess -- your story just grabbed me by the throat, and the heart, and still hasn't let go. I'm so happy you found her before it was too late. I wish you -- but more importantly, Bess -- much health and happiness in the coming year."

On the other hand, reader Leslie McMichael of North Hollywood was expecting something else: "I read with great anticipation the article about Kim Murphy's cat, Bess. Christmas morning, a feel-good story about pets sounds good. What I got was a heart-wrenching story of why some people should not be pet owners. The London Rescue had it right not to give Ms. Murphy a cat. Ms. Murphy told of escapades of her other cats and their predicaments, but she never thought to look in the window seat for Bess or eveywhere and anywhere and never give up? What does it say about how Bess felt, that she could not call out for help or even try to escape, too trusting or not enough trust of her family?"

And so it went, from this sentiment: "I'm sure everyone is writing to you saying how wonderful your piece was, and how they cried unabashedly at the ending. .. count me in as one more" (from Stephanie Daniels in Signal Mountain, TN) to this: "I'm perplexed as to why The Times would publish this terrible story on Christmas Day. Is this your idea of uplifting? At what point do all these cat 'accidents' become a pattern of negligence?" (from Ari Solomon of Los Angeles).

First, the answer to the two biggest questions from unhappy readers:

How could she miss the cat meowing all those weeks? Said Murphy in her note: "This cat NEVER meowed. Not once. We sat on that window seat every single day of her disappearance, and never heard ONE SOUND until the night she was discovered." 

And why did the story run on Christmas Day? This was "a good choice for anyone who believes in unexpected blessings," as editors on the National desk said when they pitched it.

As reporter Murphy put it in her e-mail to upset readers, "I have gotten many wonderful e-mails from people about my story of Bess, and a whole lot from readers who were shocked at what happened to Bess, and my lousy record of pet ownership. Let me start by saying that none of these reactions came as a surprise to me. As a lifelong cat lover (I find I am someone who likes animals better than people in  many ways), there is no way I would have put all that in the story without knowing how many people (such as myself) would react."

"I am sending this out in an attempt to explain what happened, and why I wrote the story as I did. Many of you will dismiss this as a sorry attempt to make excuses. Well, it is."

Here's the rest of the note the reporter sent to readers who called her irresponsible and worse:

"I can tell you that none of the horrors that have gone through your mind can match those that have inhabited mine. Why didn't Bess meow? I've gone through it a million times. Did she leap in there while someone was getting a blanket out and then get hit on the head as the door was closing? Did she run quickly out of oxygen and go into a semi-comatose state? Did one of the children at the barbecue accidentally close her in a door or step on her, and then hide her in the cabinet because they were afraid to admit what happened? (I can tell you that while I described these as "blowout" parties in the story, they were not, as many of you seem to imagine, alcohol-fueled orgies. They were big dinner parties, with lots of laughter and kids and Van Morrison on the iPod, the kind of events where the cats usually get cuddled and played with and which one would hardly expect would be a menacing event.

"Why didn't I look in the window seat? I went on every possible lost-cat website, and every one of them told you to search your own house and outbuildings immediately. We looked under beds, in closets, in the kitchen cabinets, and called her name all over the house. We open the window seat perhaps twice a year. It just never occurred to me that she could possibly be in there, particularly since she had been seen the night of the barbecue. I was simply SURE she had escaped the house, because of the open window in the guest room, and I knew those coyotes were in the woods very nearby.

"As far as my history with cats, I have no appetite for making excuses, other than to tell you that I have always been a loving and careful steward of my cats. Amanda's foray hiding behind the dryer happened at the home of my friend while I was gone on vacation, and of course she was none the worse for her period of seclusion. Mario was locked out on the balcony by my husband, after I had already gone down to the car. We had an iron-clad rule in the house not to leave the balcony door open when the cats were roaming free in the house, and my husband violated that rule one evening when I was at the office, thinking Peter was asleep in my daughter's room. We got screens the next day -- miserably, lamely, a day too late. Marie was closed in the dryer by my idiot Russian housekeeper, again while I was at work (she, too, was OK despite it). Katya was allowed to go outside and did escape our yard and got hit by a bus, and I am single-handedly responsible for this. I shouldn't have let her go outside. I let her and Kolya out in our garden in London because they literally begged at the door, and seemed gloriously happy when they were let out, miserable when they were not. Nonetheless, I made a decision after that to never again let my cats go outside.

"I included the litany of cat tragedies in my story about Bess as a means of full disclosure. If I was going to write about what happened to Bess -- which happened in my house, to my cat, and which ultimately, like all of it, was MY FAULT -- then I needed to face up to what had happened in the past. I didn't include it to minimize the tragedies that had befallen our cats in the past, every one of which brought unending tears to my family -- I can't even tell you how many -- though I wrote about it in a glossed-over way for purposes of this Christmas story. I needed to include evidence of our family's past sins, I think, to show just how big a miracle happened to us. We deserved the grace of Bess' survival less than anyone I know. And yet it happened. I am humbled and awed and deeply, deeply thankful."

-- Kim

PHOTOGRAPH: Reporter Kim Murphy's photo of Bess at home in Bainbridge Island, Wash.

Post a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Comments (7)

Ms. Murphy
Your excuses above just show me that you continue to believe that you are a responsible pet owner, which you are not. I have NEVER had an incident causing injury to one of my cats, and you have had too many for you to continue to excuse them all away. I make sure all workers in my home know the rules regarding my cats, and if your husband can't handle pet ownership, then you need to do without as well. PLEASE DON'T HAVE ANY MORE PETS! And I hope that you are prosecuted for animal cruelty for not finding Bess in your home - it wouldn't have been very hard to open the bench, and you should have looked there.

Give me a break...accidents happen. It was a miracle Bess survived and I found it a heartwarming story, and very brave of Kim to write it...especially with the other mishaps included.

I've had two cats in the last 35 years or so..the first lived to age 15 and the second is turning 18 in February. I am very careful but both of them have managed to get shut into armoires, closets, bars, cupboards, etc.

It's the nature of cats to hide. We have ransacked the house any number of times without success. It's just luck and loud meowing that has turned them up.

I do agree that cats should live indoors, but Kim acknowledges that and has learned from the lessons of her animals. She was negligent not to look in the bench, but not guilty of animal cruelty.

We have subscribed to the LA Times without a break since 1960 and still do. Keep Kim as a writer.

Dear Ms Murphy,
I truly hope that Bess makes a 100% recovery. As cat lovers all over the world have responded to you - some in rage, some in anger, some in pure frustration and some in admiration and some in support - all I can say that we here in Cape Town, South Africa were deeply moved by your story. As city devellers we were also scared of racing cars, etc, so we made the conscious decision to keep our cats indoors and they are only let out to "smell the roses" under strict supervision.

I guess the moral of the stroy - look in the window seat next time :)!

Shrek and his mere mortal human beings
Cape Town
South Africa

Dear Ms.Murphy,
I read your moving article via latimes website. I moved from LA to Egypt where we lived for 2 years. I came back to the States with an adopted but rescued Egyptian Mau. So, I can relate to your story. Our kitty adapted to her new surroundings after being homed for one year. One warm summer evening round the 4th of July she disappeared. For months we looked for her in the community and hoped she'd return. It was a blessing to rescue her in Egypt and to bring her home to a better environment. I do believe that someone has her, providing her a loving home, and out-of embarassment afraid to let us know that they adopted her. Whatever,I am still blessed. I continue to be a sponsor of the Egyptian Maus and been a pet escort to bring adopted cats to the new owners in the States.
May you,your family and kitty the Best of the New Year!

Real cat lovers, those who actually care for their cats responsibly, are tired of hearing excuses from Ms. Murphy. First she allows her cat to be imprisoned for weeks, then she makes some bucks and fame off the incident by publishing a story about it. What an outrage. This cat should be removed from her home, along with any other pets and children, and placed in a more responsible setting. Shame on the LA Times for facilitating Ms. Murphy's further abuse by giving her a forum to print this ridiculous story.

I did read the story and had a difficult time believing that the cat survived in the windowbox for so long. I think that what happened instead was that the cat got outside, wandered for several days then got back in and ended up in the windowbox for perhaps a few days before being found. At least she's alive now, so remember that.

I live with a cat and do volunteer work with cats. Although there are people who neglect and abuse cats, most people do care about their pets and shouldn't be persecuted when mistakes are made. It doesn't do anyone any good when people call for pets and children to be removed when mistakes are made every time. If that were to happen, shelters would be pushed past their limits and foster care systems severely overtaxed (already happening). Education is the key, not condemnation.

Give the lady a break. Her children and cats are okay and thriving. She's learning her lessons. It was a nice story.

It just seems very unlikely that a cat would have stayed silent in a window box for nine weeks, and only meow when a stranger sat nearby. More likely the homeowners just weren't listening very well.

Yeah, accidents happen. Yes, cats get locked in closets and garages all the time. But the owners manage to find them a lot quicker than nine weeks later. Owners who know cats may jump out of windows KEEP THEIR WINDOWS AND BALCONY DOORS CLOSED! Cat owners near busy roads and bus routes keep their cats indoors. You wouldn't let your kid wander unattended along a busy road, so why would you let your cats?

This is the backup site for The Los Angeles Times. We'll post news and information if becomes inoperable or inaccessible.

this is a test breaking news post |  April 16, 2013, 1:45 pm »


Have a story tip?

Please send to

Can I call someone with news?

Yes. The city desk number is (213) 237-7847.