Olympics Blog

News about the Summer and Winter Games

Category: Evgeni Plushenko

Orser gets last word on men's skate result: 'The right winner, given the system'

Evan To all the e-mailers and commenters on this blog who think I am either 1) anti-Russian or 2) anti-athleticism in figure skating in my reasoning about why Evan Lysacek deserved the men's gold medal and Evgeni Plushenko deserved to be sent to the corner for his terrible twos tantrum: You are missing the point.

The point is that Plushenko and his coaching team did not make a serious effort to figure out how to get the most of a scoring system that has been considerably modified since it was first used at an Olympics in 2006 -- when the Russian was a most deserving champion.

Lysacek, his choreographer, Lori Nichol, and his coach, Frank Carroll, constructed a free skate program that took advantage of every point-getting opportunity, provided the skater executed his elements well. They knew that spins and footwork sequences could be as important as jumps, and they knew there was a bonus for jumps in the latter half of the program.

What always has made figure skating special is its combination of sport and art.  The new judging system tries to recognize that a beautiful spin is as compelling as a quadruple jump, even while giving a skater more than twice as many points for the quad than for the spin.

The Russians' gripe should be with the system, not the result. But rather than whining for a week about skaters without quadruple jumps returning the sport to the land before time, they should have spent more time and energy on living in the present. The system was not going to change before the Olympics.

Continue reading »

Speaking out: Let it go! Evgeni Plushenko displays his Olympic 'platinum' medal [updated]

Evgeni Russian figure skater Evgeni Plushenko shouldn't feel too bad about losing to Evan Lysacek -- after all, he supposedly won the first platinum medal ever awarded at the Olympic Games.

Well, that's according to Plushenko's website, which displays a mocked-up platinum medal next to the gold he won in Torino in 2006. Maybe it's a translation error, but something tells me Plushenko is still a bit upset over not winning gold last week.

I have to give props to Plushenko's webmaster for some fine creative bitterness, but Plushenko really needs to let this go.

The world knows Plushenko is upset, but there's no reason for him to act like a real-life Chazz Michael Michaels. Controversial results are a part of figure skating, and he needs to stop tarnishing his reputation by acting like a spoiled sport.

[UPDATED, Wednesday, 5:53 a.m.: Pluschenko's website has pulled down the "platinum medal."]

-- Austin Knoblauch

Photo: Screenshot taken from Plushenko's website.


IOC President says Plushenko's behavior only an expression of disappointment

International Olympic Committee President Jacques Rogge criticized Jamaica's Usain Bolt as being disrespectful to his competitors when the Jamaican sprinter celebrated his victory in the 100 meters at the Beijing Olympics well before the finish line.

Yet Rogge pretty much gave Russian figure skater Evgeni Plushenko a pass for repeated comments disrespectful of his opponents and his sport after losing the Olympic men's figure skating title Thursday to Evan Lysacek of the United States.

Evgeny

Plushenko, the 2006 Olympic champion, also made light of the awards ceremony and the traditional medalists' victory lap.

In the awards ceremony, he jumped up to the gold medalist's step on the podium, grinned and then walked to the lower silver medal step. He tried to avoid the victory lap and wasted no time removing the silver medal from his neck once leaving the ice.

Asked on Saturday for his reaction to Plushenko's behavior, Rogge said, "I think he was very disappointed, obviously, and some times in disappointment, you express things you wouldn't express at another time.''

Rogge said he did not know that Plushenko said a competition in which the winner did not try a quadruple jump was "not men's skating.  It is dance.''

"If that is the case, it is ill-advised, of course,''  Rogge said.

Rogge asked to be told what Plushenko said.  After hearing it, the IOC president said.

"He should respect his competitors, which I think he does. He has probably pronounced some words in the emotion of disappointment, but definitely he has to respect his opponents, of course.''

Rogge's views of Bolt's antics were much different.

"That's not the way we perceive being a champion." Rogge said in an interview with three international news agency reporters in Beijing.

"I have no problem with him doing a show. I think he should show more respect for his competitors and shake hands, give a tap on the shoulder to the other ones immediately after the finish and not make gestures like the one he made in the 100 meters.''

In Beijing, Rogge did not soften his feelings a few days later, after the Jamaican had won the 100, 200 and relay golds, all in world-record times.

"I gave Usain Bolt what I think is fatherly advice, and I stand by what I said,'' Rogge said in his final Beijing news conference. "He should show more respect for his opponents. He is a young man of 22. He has time to mature.''

Plushenko is 27.  He has competed in three Olympics, winning two silver medals and one gold. That would seem plenty of time mature.

Of course, it certainly is a lot easier to take on a little Caribbean island than mighty Russia, once an Olympic superpower and host of the next Winter Games.

Photo: Evgeni Plushenko takes the wrong route to the silver medalist's step. Credit: Cameron Spencer / Associated Press


Sarah Morris: Lysacek and Plushenko proved figure skating is a sport

Olyblog_500

Thursday night Evan Lysacek became the first American male to win the Olympic figure skating competition since the 1988 Winter Olympics in Calgary. Evgeni Plushenko, who took a 3 ½-year break from the sport, hoped to become the first man to repeat as an Olympic gold medalist since Dick Button accomplished this in 1948 and 1952 but had to settle for the silver. While able to land the quadruple jump, Plushenko lacked artistry and grade of execution on his jumps. Daiskue Takahaski captured the bronze becoming the first Japanese male to medal in Olympic figure skating. 

The Vancouver Olympics had the deepest male figure skating field in the history of the competition. Most men skated beautifully, but no one came close to Lysacek, the reigning world champion. A few men, including the silver medalist Plushenko, attempted a quad, but the difficult jump didn't guarantee a medal.  While the new complex point system that judges figure skating has been widely criticized for emphasizing the athleticism over the artistry, Thursday night the most complete skater earned the gold.

Many people don't think figure skating is a sport. Although many great performances are not winners because the judges didn't like what the common fan likes, figure skating definitely is a sport. In the past, judging was subjective. However, now every move has points rewarded. Though jumps catch everyone's eyes, the difficult footwork and fast spins are also awarded points. While most sports don't have artistry, figure skating is a beautiful sport.  The participants need to perform to the audience.  Lysacek was an artist.  Plushenko could land all of the jumps, but he didn't appear to be light on his feet while Lysacek did everything gracefully and effortlessly. 

Figure skating needs incredible endurance.  Though the long program is only four and a half minutes, it takes much energy from any skater because he can't take a break during the program.  Before the new point system was invented, most figure skaters did their jumps in the first two minutes.  Now the figure skaters get 10 percent more for a jump after the half way mark of the program.  The 2006 Olympic champion did his jumps in the first half.  Lysacek spread his difficult moves throughout his program. 

Continue reading »

Lysacek, in the celebrity whirlwind, says he plans to continue competing

Flag

 Evan Lysacek had the best sleepless night of his life.

The "Today" show had him for its opening segment Friday, which meant being in the studio across the water in North Vancouver at 4 a.m.

Next, three hours later, came a live-by-satellite appearance on "Oprah" for her Friday show, then a late morning press conference at the Main Media Center.

Before then, he finished doping control at the Pacific Coliseum on Thursday night, made a victory appearance at USA House, where the U.S. Olympic Committee entertains sponsors and other guests, packed up his room at the Olympic Village and moved into a downtown Vancouver Hotel.

Such are the immediate spoils of being the first U.S. man to win an Olympic figure skating gold medal since Brian Boitano in 1988.

Naperville, Ill's., Lysacek will undoubtedly get a boost in his appearance fee on the upcoming Stars on Ice tour, and he could likely begin to have a financially secure future as "America's Guest'' -- public appearances, working for his sponsors, etc.

But, as he left the press conference at the rink Thursday night, Lysacek told the Chicago Tribune he plans to continue competing.

"Right now, I want to keep skating,'' he said.  "I don't know, maybe one more year.  It might change.''

It doesn't seem likely Lysacek would keep going until the 2014 Olympics, given that they are in Sochi, Russia, given the reaction in Russia to having Lysacek beat their homey, 2006 Olympic champion Evgeny Plushenko.

Plushenko set the tone by claiming he wuz robbed and that no man should win Olympic gold without doing a quadruple jump.  Prime Minister Vladimir Putin said Plushenko's performance was "worth a gold medal.''  Plushenko's wife called the result a "gross mistake by the judges'' and demanded Russian officials defend the honor of their athletes.

"I don't think they would love to see me there [Sochi], to be quite honest, if I could somehow get a visa into that country,'' Lysacek said Friday morning.

Lysacek, 24, said he is almost certainly done for this year, so he will skip next month's World Championships at the Palavela in Turin, Italy, where he finished fourth in the 2006 Olympics.

"I need a little break,'' he said.

He won't get one from the celebrity circuit for a while.  The other network morning shows, plus Regis and Kelly, already have sent requests for him.

When things slow down, Lysacek can look back and see himself not only as Olympic champion but as one of the few who delivered the best skating of his life under the greatest pressure.

The scores said it: personal bests in Tuesday's short program, Thursday's free skate and, obviously, the total, for a 1.31-point victory over Plushenko, who took his defeat like a graceless churl.

"I was positive that I won, but I suppose Evan needs a medal more than I do,'' Plushenko said at the post-competition press conference.  "Maybe it's because I already have one.  I think that two silver and one Olympic gold, that's not too bad.''

Plushenko, who also won silver in 2002, was put out because Lysacek became the first man to win the Olympic title without a quadruple jump since Russia's Alexei Urmanov in 1994.

In the media mixed zone area after the competition, Plushenko derided Lysacek's accomplishment even more.

"I think we need to change the judging system,'' Plushenko said.  "If the Olympic champion doesn't know how to jump quad, it’s not men's figure skating, it’s dancing.’’

Lysacek was taken aback by Plushenko's remarks.

"I'm a little disappointed,'' Lysacek told the Tribune Thursday night.  "He has been a role model for me.''

Lysacek reiterated it Friday morning and still cut Plushenko some slack for his intemperate reaction.

"I guess I was a little disappointed that someone that was my role model would take a hit at me in probably one of the most special moments of my life, that I will never forget, regardless of what anyone says.'' Lysacek said.  "Like I said, it's tough to lose, especially when you think that no matter what, you're going to win.''

Lysacek had been relentlessly effusive in his praise of Plushenko, noting how impressive it had been for the Russian to come back after three years away from competition.

"I've admired him for many years,'' Lysacek said.  "When he was winning senior worlds and I was a junior, I was cheering along with everyone else.  I thought he skated great tonight.''

That didn't stop Plushenko from harping on the quad.

"First and foremost, I want to state that I respect my competitors,'' Plushenko said.  "My basic position is that movement must go forward, never stop, never go back.... I think people need to do lots of quads.''

Plushenko did one, although it was shaky, as were two of his other jumps.  His spins were weak, and his footwork sequences relied more on pelvic gyrations, hip shimmying and posing than anything else.

Lysacek made up a 0.55 deficit to Plushenko after the short program and created his margin of victory on the scores for his execution of spins and footwork. The scoring system implemented after the pairs scandal at the 2002 Olympics demands a skater be able to do more than jump.

"Anyone who is arguing with those judges' scores, I don't think understands the system,'' Lysacek said.  "They did a good job using the new judging system to score this event as accurately as possible.''

His advantage over Plushenko on spins was 1.36 and on footwork, 1.0.  The quality of Lysacek's jumps -- eight triples -- was good enough that he lost only 0.3 points there to Plushenko, who did the quad-triple combination and six other triples.

"I think Evgeny went up and down,'' said Frank Carroll, Lysacek's coach.  "Brilliant jumping and then down.  Evan stayed on a plane from the start to the finish.  That consistent plane and getting the pluses [for execution], it adds up.''

Lysacek was, as skaters always strive to be, the whole package. 

"For several years, I have worked on the quad, and I know how many hours and how much energy it takes,'' Lysacek said, "and that pales in comparison to the amount of time it takes to work on those spins and get those perfect and to get those transitions down and to get the stamina to put all that into 4 minutes and 40 seconds of skating.''

To get through the most important 4 minutes, 40 seconds of skating in his life, Lysacek needed a nudge from Carroll to help him keep things in perspective.

"It's hard when you're in second place at the Olympic Games to not think of a medal,'' Lysacek said.  "I started to think about the outcome.  He [Frank] could see it in me and he came up to me Thursday and said, 'You can do your absolute best and not be the best tonight.  But your job is to perform every step of your program to the best of your ability.'  I just started thinking, 'That's what I do every day in practice, so why should it be any different today.'''

Lysacek began working with Carroll after leaving Neuqua Valley High School in 2003.  After two years, he became a consistent national and world medalist, with two U.S. titles and a world title before the Olympic gold.

"Frank has a real understanding of psychology,'' Lysacek said.  "He told me you can't win until you learn to win, you can't be a champion until you learn to be a champion.  He taught me how to compete.

"I never let myself think about winning for myself because it's not a helpful thought.  I was concentrating on my work and daily grind.  I did think a couple times about winning for him.''

Carroll, 71, previously had two Olympic silver medalists, Linda Fratianne (1980) and Michelle Kwan (1998), both of whom were favored for gold.  Christopher Bowman, whom Carroll calls the most talented skater he ever coached, wasted that ability with drugs before competing at the Olympics.  Timothy Goebel, whom Carroll also coached, made the most of his ability to finish third behind Russians Alexei Yagudin and Plushenko in 2002.

So when Plushenko returned this season and began racking up high scores, it looked as if Carroll might still be looking for his first Olympic champion.  His other 2010 Olympic skater, 16-year-old Mirai Nagasu, is four years from challenging for gold.

"I never obsessed about it,'' Carroll said,  "People think it has meant so much to me, but it hasn't.

"I've had a great career, and I have really been satisfied with the Olympic medals my kids have won.  It's not about me anyway.  It's about him.  And I think coaches have got to get that in their head, that they are just a vehicle for the skaters to do well.''

Evan Lysacek would disagree.

"Winning for Frank, so far that's the best part,'' he said before rushing off to doping control.

It was just one of many stops on a long night's journey into day, after what Lysacek called the best night of his life.

-- Philip Hersh, reporting from Vancouver, Canada

RELATED: For Lysacek, celebrity whirlwind starts fast

(With the gold medal around his neck, Evan Lysacek celebrates his new glory with Old Glory.  Nuccio DiNuzzo / Chicago Tribune.)

For Lysacek, celebrity whirlwind starts fast

Evan
Evan Lysacek was about to have the best sleepless night of his life.

The Today Show has him booked for their opening segment Friday, which means being in their studio across the water in North Vancouver at 4 a.m. Pacific time.

Next, three hours later, comes a live-by-satellite appearance on Oprah for her Friday show (9 a.m. in Chicago), then a newss conference at the Main Media Center.

Between then, he was to finish doping control at the Pacific Coliseum on Thursday night, make a victory appearance at USA House, where the U.S. Olympic Committee entertains sponsors and other guests, pack up his room at the Olympic Village and move into a downtown Vancouver Hotel.

Such are the immediate spoils of being the first U.S. man to win an Olympic figure skating gold medal since Brian Boitano in 1988.

Lysacek, from Naperville, Ill., will undoubtedly get a boost in his appearance fee on the upcoming Stars on Ice tour, and he could likely begin to have a financially secure future as "America's Guest" -- public appearances, working for his sponsors, etc.

But, as he left the news conference at the rink Thursday night, Lysacek told reporters that he plans to continue competing.

"Right now, I want to keep skating," he said. "I don't know, maybe one more year. It might change.'"

Lysacek, 24, said he is almost certainly done for this year, so he will skip next month's World Championships at the Palavela in Turin, Italy, where he finished fourth in the 2006 Olympics.

"I need a little break," he said.

He won't get one from the celebrity circuit for awhile. The other network morning shows, plus Regis and Kelly, already have turned in requests.

When things slow down, Lysacek can look back and see himself not only as Olympic champion but as one of the few who delivered the best skating of his life under the greatest pressure.

The scores said it: personal bests in Tuesday's short program, Thursday's free skate and, obviously, the total, for a 1.31-point victory over defending Olympic champion Evgeni Plushenko of Russia, who took his defeat like a graceless churl.

"I was positive that I won, but I suppose Evan needs a medal more than I do," Plushenko said at the post-competition news conference.  "Maybe it's because I already have one. I think that two silver and one Olympic gold, that's not too bad."

Plushenko, who also won silver in 2002, was put out because Lysacek became the first man to win the Olympic title without a quadruple jump since Russia's Alexei Urmanov in 1994.

In the media mixed zone area after the competition, Plushenko derided Lysacek's accomplishment even more.

"I think we need to change the judging system," Plushenko said. "If the Olympic champion doesn't know how to jump quad, it’s not men's figure skating, it’s dancing."

Lysacek was taken aback by Plushenko's remarks.

"I'm a little disappointed,'' Lysacek said. "He has been a role model for me.'"

Only a few minutes earlier, Lysacek had been effusive in his praise of Plushenko, noting how impressive it had been for the Russian to come back after three years away from competition.

"I've admired him for many years,'' Lysacek said.  "When he was winning senior worlds and I was a junior, I was cheering along with everyone else.  I thought he skated great tonight.''

That didn't stop Plushenko from harping on the quad.

"First and foremost, I want to state that I respect my competitors," Plushenko said. "My basic position is that movement must go forward, never stop, never go back. . . . I think people need to do lots of quads."

Plushenko did one, although it was shaky, as were two of his other jumps. His spins were weak, and his footwork sequences relied more on pelvic gyrations, hip shimmying and posing than anything else.

Lysacek made up a .55 deficit to Plushenko after the short program and created his margin of victory on the scores for his execution of spins and footwork.

His advantage over Plushenko on spins was 1.36 and 1.0 on footwork.  The quality of Lysacek's jumps -- eight triples -- was good enough that he lost only .3 points on that component to Plushenko, who did the quad-triple combination and six other triples.

"I think Evgeni went up and down," said Frank Carroll, Lysacek's coach. "Brilliant jumping and then down.  Evan stayed on a plane from the start to the finish. That consistent plane and getting the pluses (for execution), it adds up."

Lysacek was, as skaters always strive to be, the whole package.

"For several years, I have worked on the quad, and I know how many hours and how much energy it takes," Lysacek said, "and that pales in comparison to the amount of time it takes to work on those spins and get those perfect and to get those transitions down and to get the stamina to put all that into 4 minutes and 40 seconds of skating."

To get through the most important 4 minutes 40 seconds of skating in his life, Lysacek needed a nudge from Carroll to help him keep things in perspective.

"It's hard when you're in second place at the Olympic Games to not think of a medal," Lysacek said. "I started to think about the outcome. (Frank) could see it in me and he came up to me Thursday and said, 'You can do your absolute best and not be the best tonight. But your job is to perform every step of your program to the best of your ability.' I just started thinking, 'That's what I do every day in practice, so why should it be any different today.' "

Lysacek began working with Carroll after leaving Neuqua Valley High School in 2003.  After two years, he became a consistent national and world medalist, with two U.S. titles and a world title before the Olympic gold.

"Frank has a real understanding of psychology," Lysacek said. "He told me you can't win until you learn to win, you can't be a champion until you learn to be a champion. He taught me how to compete.

"I never let myself think about winning for myself because it's not a helpful thought. I was concentrating on my work and daily grind. I did think a couple times about winning for him."

Carroll, 71, previously had two Olympic silver medalists, Linda Fratianne (1980) and Michelle Kwan (1998), both of whom were favored for gold. Christopher Bowman, whom Carroll calls the most talented skater he ever coached, wasted that ability with drugs before competing at the Olympics. Timothy Goebel, whom Carroll also coached, made the most of his ability to finish third behind Russians Alexei Yagudin and Plushenko in 2002.

So when Plushenko returned this season and began racking up high scores, it looked as if Carroll might still be looking for his first Olympic champion. His other 2010 Olympic skater, 16-year-old Mirai Nagasu, is four years from challenging for gold.

"I never obsessed about it," Carroll said. "People think it has meant so much to me, but it hasn't.

"I've had a great career, and I have really been satisfied with the Olympic medals my kids have won. It's not about me anyway. It's about him. And I think coaches have got to get that in their head, that they are just a vehicle for the skaters to do well."

Evan Lysacek would disagree.

"Winning for Frank, so far that's the best part," he said before rushing off to doping control.

It was just one of many stops on a long night's journey after what Lysacek called the best day of his life.

-- Philip Hersh, reporting from Vancouver

Photo: With choreographer Lori Nichol to his left and Coach Frank Carroll to his right, Evan Lysacek crosses his fingers while awaiting his free skate scores Thursday night. Credit: Nuccio DiNuzzo / Chicago Tribune

Evan Lysacek wins gold in men's figure skating, Evgeni Plushenko gets silver

Lysacek1_586

Trailing by less than a point heading into the free program, Evan Lysacek of the United States did his job and did it well Thursday night, performing an outstanding free program to add 167.37 points to his total, giving him 257.67 points for the competition. But would it be enough for the gold?

That put the pressure squarely on Russia's Evgeni Plushenko, who answered with a strong free skate of his own, but not strong enough, as he scored 165.51 points, giving him 256.36 points overall and the silver medal.

Daisuke Takahashi of Japan won the bronze with a score of 247.23 points. Johnny Weir of the U.S. finished in sixth place.

-- Houston Mitchell in Vancouver

Photo: Evan Lysacek performs his free skate Thursday night. Credit: Mark Baker / Associated Press


Skating federation president says Plushenko wants to be a one-note pianist

Ottavio Cinquanta of Italy,  president of the International Skating Union, thinks Evgeni Plushenko’s attitude toward skating makes him like a virtuoso pianist who wants to play only Chopin.

Whether the judges agree with Cinquanta may be a factor in the outcome of the Olympic men’s figure skating Thursday night.

"Of course, Plushenko would like to decide the gold medal only on the basis of jumps," Cinquanta said Thursday morning.   "But we have to respect the abilities of a skater like Johnny Weir as well.

"We ask a pianist to perform more than Chopin.  We ask a figure skater to do not only jumps but spins and footwork. Figure skating is not only jumping, otherwise we become guilty of the accusation we are only an acrobatic sport."

PlushCinquanta is convinced the sport’s new judging system gives skaters without a quad, like Evan Lysacek and Weir of the United States, a chance to score as many points as Russia's Plushenko, who may try two quads in his 4 1/2-minute free skate.

He noted that Plushenko, who did a quad, and both Lysacek and Daisuke Takahashi of Japan, who did not, were separated by less than a point after the short program Tuesday.  He was also pleased the top three represent three  continents.

"The people can really see three skaters with different styles in contending position because of a system that condemned a former world champion [Brian Joubert of France] and a former European champion [Thomas Verner of the Czech Republic] because they missed the quad."

Joubert was 18th and Verner 19th in the short program.

"The best restaurant doesn’t offer only the best steak," Cinquanta said. "It also offers the best wine and the best vegetables."

Both Plushenko and his coach, Alexei Mishin, have been on a soapbox about the quad, trying to sway opinion with the assertion that skaters who do not do one belong to a bygone age.

"That’s the future of figure skating," Plushenko said after his short program.  "Without the quad,  it’s not men’s figure skating."

Cinquanta feels Plushenko, the reigning Olympic champion, is "absolutely not wrong and absolutely not right."

"Plushenko cannot snob footwork and spins," Cinquanta said.  "He doesn’t like it, but I am not here to serve Plushenko.

"Everyone would like to be Michael Jordan and play basketball.  But some people are weightlifters, and they cannot be Michael Jordan."

Cinquanta said Russian skating officials were right in asking to have images of Plushenko’s weak points at the 2006 Olympics removed from instructional videos that would be used in seminars for judges.   USA Today first reported last week that Plushenko was taken off the videos.

"I believe that is an acceptable argument," Cinquanta said.  "He was saying, 'I am a skater entered in the Olympic Games.  [To] use my image in what you consider not a very positive way and show this on the occasion of a seminar is not fair to me.  It informs the judges that Plushenko is weak in this area.' "

Cinquanta thought similar problems could be resolved in the future by inviting the best skaters to perform mistakes intentionally for instructional reasons.

There has been recent controversy about Plushenko receiving overly generous marks in one of the five component score areas, "transitions / linking footwork."  The skater himself said he paid little attention to transitions to focus on his jumps.

Some of the discussion may have had an impact, as Plushenko received  about 10% lower scores in that area in the short program than he had while winning last month’s European Championships.

Cinquanta also said Plushenko wants to have it both ways -- to have a quad worth even more points than it is now but not be penalized as harshly for failure if one tries it.

"He is saying, 'I try the quad.  If I don’t make it, give me nine points; if I do, give me 15,' " Cinquanta said.  "No, no, my friend."

-- Philip Hersh in Vancouver, Canada

Photo:  Evgeni Plushenko completes a jump in the short program.  Credit: Nuccio DiNuzzo / Chicago Tribune


Connect

Recommended on Facebook


Advertisement

In Case You Missed It...


About the Bloggers



Categories


Archives
 




In Case You Missed It...