Pop & Hiss

The L.A. Times music blog

« Previous Post | Pop & Hiss Home | Next Post »

Grammy countdown: The ways in which we were wrong

November 24, 2008 |  7:30 am

With the CMAs and the AMAs out of the way, Pop & Hiss now officially begins its countdown to the 2009 Grammy Awards. Starting this week and leading up to the Grammy nomination announcement on Dec. 3, Pop & Hiss will be running down major categories. First up, and going live later today, will be a look at the best rock album field.

But first, a look back at our predictions from last year.

In the best rock album category, Pop & Hiss (then known as Extended Play), had picked the following as the favorites:

Daughtry's "Daughtry"
Fall Out Boy's "Infinity on High"
White Stripes' "Icky Thump"
Bruce Springsteen's "Magic"
Linkin Park's "Minutes to Midnight"

So how many of those did we have right?

Just two out of five -- Daughtry and Bruce Springsteen. Nominated albums ultimately included John Fogerty's "Revival, Wilco's "Sky Blue Sky" and the Foo Fighters' "Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace," which wound up winning.

We didn't fare much better in the album of the year field, either. Our picks:

Bruce Springsteen's "Magic"
Linkin Park's "Minutes to Midnight"
Paul McCartney's "Memory Almost Full"
Kanye West's "Graduation"
Amy Winehouse's "Back to Black

The prize went to Herbie Hancock, pictured above, for his "River: The Joni Letters." Don't try to pretend you saw that coming. While we were right that Kanye and Winehouse would get nominated, our other picks included Springsteen, Linkin Park and Paul McCartney.

So why continue? Why, that's the best aspect of the Grammy Awards, promoting discussion and debate about the past year-ish (eligibility period runs from Oct. 1, 2007, to Sept. 30, 2008) in music. And with more than 100 categories and multiple genres, handicapping the Grammys is not as easy as foretelling the Academy Awards, in which "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" and "Slumdog Millionaire" are likely to be nominated for best picture (see that, Tom O'Neil? Just did your gig).

And hey, go easy on us. After all, not one ESPN analyst had Philadelphia besting Tampa Bay in the World Series. In fact, multiple writers had the Cubs winning it all. Silly, everyone knew that the 2009 Cubs would be the team to beat. 

--Todd Martens

Photo: Bryan Chan / Los Angeles Times