Southern California -- this just in

« Previous Post | L.A. NOW Home | Next Post »

State appellate court backs release of Scouts' 'perversion files'

December 13, 2012 |  4:17 pm

A state appellate court has denied the Boy Scouts of America’s request to reverse a Santa Barbara judge's order to turn over confidential files on alleged sexual abuse spanning two decades.

The Boy Scouts will appeal the decision to the California Supreme Court, a spokesman said Thursday.

Lawyers for a former Scout, who was 13 when a volunteer leader sexually abused him in 2007, contend that the files will expose a "culture of hidden sexual abuse" in Scouting and the organization’s failure to warn boys and their parents.The lawsuit alleges that a local Scout official tried to keep the boy's mother from reporting the crime to police, citing that as an example of efforts to conceal abuse in Scouting. The youth group denies the allegations.

FULL COVERAGE: Inside the 'perversion files'

In January, Santa Barbara County Superior Court Judge Donna Geck ordered all files dating to 1991 turned over to the boy's lawyers but not made public.

In April, the Scouts filed a writ with the California 2nd District Court of Appeal, seeking to reverse Geck’s order. The group contends that the records must remain confidential to protect the privacy of victims, those who report abuse and those wrongly accused.

"The BSA believes confidentiality of the files helps to encourage prompt reporting," spokesman Deron Smith said. "The files are only one component of BSA’s established Youth Protection program."

DOCUMENTS: A paper trail of abuse

In October, more than 1,200 of the confidential files from 1965 to 1985 were made public by order of the Oregon Supreme Court, a decision that did not have a direct bearing on the California case.

Timothy Hale, the family's lawyer in the Santa Barbara case, denounced the Scouts’ efforts to keep more recent files under wraps. By shielding the identities of "thousands of perpetrators who are roaming free in society," he said, the Scouts are putting children at risk.

"If their first priority is child welfare, then stop the secrecy game – stop fighting for it," Hale said.


Pedestrian struck and killed by car in Highland Park

First Vietnamese American mayor of Westminster sworn in

Angeles National Forest mountain roads reopen after overnight snow

-- Kim Christensen