O.C. man convicted of killing daughter, keeping body in freezer
Clarence Eugene Butterfield, 57, formerly of San Clemente, was found guilty by a Santa Ana jury of one felony count of special-circumstances murder during the commission of torture and mayhem, and one felony count of assault with a firearm, according to the Orange County district attorney’s office.On Oct. 8, he faces a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Butterfield tortured his 21-year-old daughter, Rebekah Butterfield, in 2006 by repeatedly shooting her in parts of the body that would not immediately cause fatal injury, such as the leg, foot and knee, prosecutors said.
He then tied the naked woman’s ankles together, bound her hands behind her back and stuffed her in the freezer of his RV while she was still alive.
She eventually suffocated to death in the airtight freezer. Butterfield lived in the RV with his daughter’s body in the freezer for two years after the murder, prosecutors said.
He was arrested in Orange County in 2008 for obstructing a police officer, and was subsequently sent to Nevada on an unrelated criminal warrant from that state.
Prosecutors said the investigation revealed Butterfield had a history of violence. He stabbed and shot his daughter several times in years before the murder, but the crimes were never reported, they said.
He also beat and bound his ex-wife, sometimes forcing her to remain in a closet, prosecutors said.
Butterfield, who was indicted in December 2009, denied killing his daughter. He told investigators he found her dead in the trailer and "kept her body in the freezer because he thought no one would believe him."
-- Ann M. Simmons
Photo: Clarence Eugene Butterfield. Credit: Orange County Sheriff's Department