Death sentence upheld for man who set Tustin bookkeeper on fire

The California Supreme Court on Thursday upheld a death sentence for a man who doused a Tustin bookkeeper with gasoline and set her on fire in a dispute about a paycheck.

Jonathan D'Arcy, convicted of the 1993 murder of Karen Laborde, appealed his death sentence on a variety of grounds, including the admission of pre-autopsy photographs of the charred victim during his trial. In an unanimous ruling written by Justice Carlos R. Moreno, the court found the photographs were relevant to support the prosecution's theory that the killing was accompanied by torture and mayhem.

D'Arcy, angry that he had not been paid for janitorial service, went to Laborde's office on Feb. 2, 1993, with a water bottle of gasoline and sprayed it on her face, arms, dress and head.

"'This is what you get when you hold my ------- money,'" the court said he shouted at her, using a profanity.

Laborde stood up and wiped her face.

"'Oh God,'" the court quoted her as saying. "'Why are you doing this to me?'"

D'Arcy then set her on fire. She suffered burns over 90% of her body and was told by doctors she was certain to die. She requested pain medication and gave an interview to police shortly before she died later that day.

Police found a check on Laborde's desk made out to D'Arcy for $159. It was dated Jan. 31, 1993.

The court said two forensic psychologists had diagnosed D'Arcy with paranoid schizophrenia and paranoid disorder, and others found him to have an antisocial personality disorder.

-- Maura Dolan

More breaking news in L.A. Now:

State inspectors force UC Irvine Medical Center to improve 'medication management'

Couple plead no contest in hit-and-run that killed USC student, injured another

3 teachers in Black History Month incident to be reassigned, Cortines says

Girlicious singer, acquaintance charged with drug possession in Glendale

State corrections officials defend new law, say violent criminals will get heavier monitoring

Linking L.A.: UCLA Undie Run could return to Westwood campus

Woman pulled from water after SUV plunges into L.A. River

SUV plunges into L.A. River

Armed men rob UCLA students studying at apartment

Home invasion robbers break into Garden Grove residence

County supervisors spend funds on chauffeurs, parties and websites. Check out the database.

USC Provost C.L. Max Nikias to succeed Steven Sample as president

Comments

[Devon]

She should have just paid the poor man! Look what it got her into!

[Benny]

A horrendous crime. This guy is demonic & most people dont care what happens to him. He will probably die in prison before Cal executes him. Tell me something…why do prosecutors even seek the death penalty when it is never used in Cal. Shouldnt the money used for these expensive death trials & then later incarceration costs be better used in the education budget?

[George]

keepin' it real

[JE40]

"The court said two forensic psychologists had diagnosed D'Arcy with paranoid schizophrenia and paranoid disorder, and others found him to have an antisocial personality disorder."

So?

[TheBigPicture]

"The court said two forensic psychologists had diagnosed D'Arcy with paranoid schizophrenia and paranoid disorder, and others found him to have an antisocial personality disorder."

you think...

but who cares...execute him...

he should have been more like the tens of thousands of other schizophrenics who didn't set someone on fire...