Jacket Copy

Books, authors and all things bookish

« Previous | Jacket Copy Home | Next»

Hindu activists protest professor Wendy Doniger's book

HinduNational Book Critics Circleprotest


The organization Hindu Janajagruti Samit gathered before a reading of finalists for the National Book Critics Circle awards Wednesday night in New York. At issue was the book "The Hindus: An Alternative History" by Dr. Wendy Doniger, a finalist in the nonfiction category.

The group led a protest against Doniger's book, which they say contains "factual errors, mischaracterizations and hatred for Hindus." Her book, they say, "is a work that promotes bigotry, racism and intolerance. No civilized or decent human being, organization or society will ever support such a book given Dr. Doniger's persistent verbal violence against Hindus." Despite the strong language, the protest was cordial and peaceful; protesters planned to have samosas afterward.

Doniger, a professor at the University of Chicago, did participate in the reading, along with more than 20 other finalists. On the National Book Critics Circle blog, Eric Banks writes:

For all its historical sweep, The Hindus is a surprisingly personal text, written with vivacious pluck and playful verve. Doniger switches back and forth between a lens wide enough to pack in the panorama of several centuries of subcontinental dynastic history and conquest and one microscopically sharp enough to sort through the granular life in the hoariest myth. Whether writing on bhakti devotional practices of the South or the complicated aftermath of Raj Orientalism, Doniger never misses the bigger picture for the intimate or allows the broad view to get in the way of the key detail. Much as the dynamics of exclusion are a central — maybe the central — part of her interpretation and understanding of the religious complexes of South Asia, The Hindus is acutely sensitive to delve into much in addition to the canon of revered texts. (“To the accusation," she writes, "that I cited a part of the Hindu textual tradition that one Hindu ‘had never heard of,’ my reply is: Yes! and it’s my intention to go on doing just that.”)

The Hindus is the passionate distillation of a career’s work by one of the most accomplished Sanskritists of the past century, a generous and ambitious and gregarious book. As she writes about placing the Ramayana in its historical context, she amply shows how “the human imagination transformed the actual circumstance of the historical period into something far more beautiful, terrible, challenging, and elevating than the circumstances themselves.” At a moment when fundamentalisms of all stripes make absolutist demands on the imagination, Wendy Doniger’s gift of The Hindus stands as a blessed alternative.

The National Book Critics Circle awards are Thursday night in New York. Doniger is joined in the nonfiction category by Greg Grandin for "Fordlandia," Richard Holmes for "The Age of Wonder: How the Romantic Generation Discovered the Beauty and Terror of Science," Tracy Kidder for "Strength in What Remains" and William T. Vollmann for his book about the California county, "Imperial."

-- Carolyn Kellogg

Photo credit: Carolyn Kellogg

Comments () | Archives (6)

The comments to this entry are closed.

I support Professor Wendy Doniger's right to her interpretation. That is what academic and literary freedom is all about. The judges should have the freedom to decide on winners based on the merit of the work. Those who are protesting also have the right to do so in a democracy.

I fully comprehend the feelings of my Hindu brothers, but the same brothers were rejoicing when Salman Rushdie was discrediting, ridiculing, mocking, fabricating stories, vilifying and insulting the tender feelings of 1500 million Muslims by his filthy and factually and historically erroneous book and the Hindu Fundamentalist parties such as Rashtra Sevak Sang and Bharatiya Janata Party secretly produced Hindi Translation of Salman Rushdie’s book in India even though India had banned the book. No one has any right to insult any religion Hinduism or Islam for that matter. I would agree with many views expressed by Dr. Doniger but still I feel that the book should not be allowed in India because it is an insult to Sanatana Dharma of Hinduism, the philosophy that my forefathers followed before converting to monotheistic Islam in India. After all my ancestors were Hindus too. Change in ideology does not make me not to love my nation India


There are abundant proofs available from Wendy's work which are outright factual errors. You can reward someone for different interpretation but rewarding someone for factual errors put huge question mark on the rewarding body itself.

Sreemoti, you sound like a Marxist Bengali--of the likes of Tagore, Sen, and maybe even Nussbaum. But, it is not your fault - it is what you are taught to think. Which one of us isn't? I am taught to think like an Orientalist or maybe even a right wing Hindu fundamentalist. In which case, Doniger isn't to blame. People, such as yourself, taught her to think like that - Khakar, Sen, Roy--encourage her.

Doniger has the right to write what she wants. Penguin, as a somewhat responsible publishing house, has the responsibility to publish responsibly. But then again, you can get them to publish anything you want, if you can hit as hard as Doniger.

The book is a joke. When you read it, you realize that after all these years her intent is no different that of the Christian Missionaries and Max Muller. Then again, they are the only ones that survive in our polemic world, no? No wonder no one cares to remember Schopenhauer!

Proof once again, there is no such thing as bad publicity.


Recommended on Facebook


In Case You Missed It...


Explore Bestsellers Lists





Tweets and retweets from L.A. Times staff writers.