Entertainment Industry

« Previous | Company Town Home | Next »

'Twilight': What does Catherine Hardwicke's exit bode for 'New Moon'?

Hardwicke_2 By now, Sunday's sudden and stunning news that "Twilight" director Catherine Hardwicke would not return to helm "New Moon" has had time to sink in.

Consider what her departure means for the franchise.

Hardwicke was key in casting Kristen Stewart and breakthrough star Robert Pattinson as the young lovers in Stephenie Meyer's romantic vampire saga, and she's got a proven track record in dealing with themes and issues concerning young people ("Thirteen" and "Lords of Dogtown.")

Perhaps more important, Hardwicke, who in fact is still on the promotional tour for the film, which has grossed almost $140 million in the U.S. alone, is something of a "Twilight" fangirl herself. The night before the Los Angeles premiere, she visited fans in line -- many of whom had been there for a couple of days -- posing for pictures and signing autographs. She was also at least partially responsible for getting the film's initial script, which she compared to "Charlie's Angels," nixed in favor of a more faithful telling.

Now she's gone and fans what to know what happens next. There are few schools of thought:

Not to fret, different directors can keep a series fresh. Just look at the "Harry Potter" movies, which began with the straight-forward adaptations of Christopher Columbus, went through a darker if more emotionally powerful period with Alfonso Cuaron ("Prisoner of Azkaban"), got an adrenaline boost from Mike Newell ("Goblet of Fire"), and have matured under David Yates ("Order of the Phoenix" and the upcoming "Half-Blood Prince.") Ditto other successful franchises such as "James Bond," the "Bourne" movies.

Movie watchers have already begun discussing who should take over. RopeOfSilicon.com has five female suggestions, among them Kimberly Pierce, who directed "Boys Don't Cry," and Mira Nair from "The Namesake." Earlier this month, Film.com weighed in with its top choices, including young upstart Sarah Polley and long-shot Sofia Coppola.

It doesn't matter who's behind the lens, as long as screenwriter Melissa Rosenberg sticks around. Rosenberg is credited with condensing 500+ pages of story into a two-hour film, helping to eliminate some of Meyer's clunkier passages of prose and injecting more humor into Meyer's story (i.e. the exchanges between Charlie and Billy, the dialog among Bella's human pals, details such as the wall of graduation caps.) Critics who had positive things to say about the film were grateful.

On the flip side, taking such liberties infuriated some Meyer devotees, and could do so to an even larger extent in "New Moon." Rosenberg reportedly achieved a way to squeeze in more screen time for Edward, even when he's supposed to go MIA for the majority of the second book.

The cast will be back -- what could go wrong? Pattinson and Stewart aren't going anywhere. Does anything else matter?

We have a problem, Forks. Whether or not you fell in love with Hardwicke's vision, the director's finger was on the pulse of "Twilight" fans. She relentlessly scoured Oregon for Bella's and Edward's perfect meadow, the pivotal scene for most readers. She made sure Stewart and Pattinson would steam up the screen -- on her own bed, no less. She made sure the book's many characters were all accounted for, even arguably expendable folk such as Eric.) She even went so far as to film a scene from "Midnight Sun," Meyer's as-yet-unfinished retelling of "Twilight" from Edward's perspective, which will be included as a bonus for fans on the film's forthcoming DVD. Will Summit Entertainment be able to find another director so in touch with teens and just as passionate about the source material?

What do you all think? Is Hardwicke's exit a good or bad thing for "New Moon"? Does it make a difference? Who do you want to see take over? 

-- Denise Martin

"Twilight" sequel "New Moon" gets the green light from Summit
Complete "Twilight" Countdown coverage

Photo: Catherine Hardwicke. Credit: Getty Images

Comments () | Archives (105)

Michael Bay for Twilight. I'd like to see slow mos and awesome special effects.

i agree COMPLETELY with kristen
the movie was HORRIBLE everytime i see it, it makes me mad.
I don't care if the same cast and crew are in for the next film thats great and all, i just REALLY hope new moon doesn't suck! i want to see a movie that actually HAS TO DO WITH THE BOOK. people who saw the movie and didn't read the books liked it. people who read the books were VERY DISSAPOINTED, and we all know that probably HALF the country read the books. alsoo i think Bella's character in the movie didn't show as much love for edward as she does in the books, every other character compared very well as the books. In the books, Bella's personality is funnier and more sarcastic and stubborn.
In the movie she seemed very dry and boring. I really hope her lines for New Moon and her screen directions are accurate for New Moon. AND i really hope they don't leave out details that have to be shown or do SO MUCH close up on their faces (show the setting a little more) . and the script should come from the BOOK pleasee.

I thought Catherine Hardwicke's movie was way better than I thought it would be. It's sad to hear she's going, but I try to remain positive that this new director, whoever it is, will do a great job. It would break my heart if they didn't... Many fans would be crushed.

As far as the movie "Twilight" I wasn't too pleased with the choice for Edward but when I saw the movie, I was baffled. He did an impressive job! I'm VERY glad they're keeping the same characters because if they changed them, that would just ruin EVERYTHING! So, heads up new director, you should keep the same characters as before and I'd try to keep it flowing along with the first movie. Don't let us fans down!

I think Hardwicke's exit would really affect the movie because some fans really wanted her. But if the next director will follow hardwicke's footsteps in making the film it won't affect to the quality of the film anymore. I hope that the next director will make the film more interesting and enjoyable to watch.

I definitely look forward to a new director because hopefully The New Moon will be a little more like the book. After watching Twilight, I realize that there were some missing from the book.

« | 1 2 3 4 5


Recommended on Facebook

In Case You Missed It...

Photos: L.A.’s busiest filming sites