« Previous | Culture Monster Home | Next »

Berlin Philharmonic by way of the World Wide Web

November 23, 2009 |  4:37 pm

Want to see the Berlin Philharmonic this week at Disney Hall, but finding the tickets limited and pricey? Wish that Hulu could stream Rachmaninoff along with “30 Rock”? In either case, the Berliners, who appear tonight and Tuesday at Walt Disney Concert Hall, have the solution at what they call their Digital Concert Hall.

The 127-year-old band is no stranger to technological advances -- in 1980, the Berlin Philharmonic (under the baton of Herbert von Karajan) recorded the first classical CD.

Introduced earlier this year, the Digital Concert Hall was the brainchild of Olaf Maninger, a principal cellist and member of the orchestra’s Media Board. Wanting to reach a new audience and improve the Philharmonic’s profile online, Maninger worked to get the support of Deutsche Bank to install cameras in the Philharmonie, the orchestra's home concert hall, and support the webcasts.

Entry into the Digital Concert Hall isn’t free: A single performance goes for 9.90 Euros ($15), up to a “Season Pass,” a whole year of all-you-can listen to concerts for 149 Euros ($223).  Besides simulcasts, healthy selections of the orchestra’s concerts since August 2008 are also available for streaming in the archive (a real find is Gustavo Dudamel conducting a Stravinsky program from March).

“It’s not making money yet,” says Berlin’s PR Chief, Elisabeth Hilsdorf, who is in Los Angeles this week with the orchestra, “but it’s not just an experiment; the goal is for it to go on forever.”  Hilsdorf says that the orchestra has been averaging about 2,000 people per event and needs 6,000 to 7,000 people to break even.

After I saw artistic director Simon Rattle conducting the Berlin Philharmonic three nights earlier this month at Carnegie Hall, the joy of the Digital Concert Hall was seeing the video:

It offered high-resolution close-up views of harp plucks and timpani rolls that you couldn’t see even from that hall’s choicest seats. The downside—and with an orchestra as strong as Berlin, it’s a real downside—is the feel of the musicmaking. For streaming audio, the Concert Hall sounds clear, but what can’t be captured digitally is the force of the sound waves.  At Carnegie Hall, at one point during the orchestra’s playing of Brahms’ Third Symphony, it felt as if the rhythms of my own body—my heartbeat and breathing—were succumbing to the pulse of the music.

Even if the Concert Hall's ’s next “live” event (Zubin Mehta conducting on Dec. 6) shakes the Philharmonie’s rafters in Berlin, its unlikely to provide the same frisson for someone watching on a home system. Still, for far less than a plane ticket, it does allow Angelenos a chance to experience Arnold Schoenberg’s beautiful, spiky rarity, “Accompaniment to a Cinematographic Scene” (heard in New York, Boston and Ann Arbor—but not on the schedule at Disney Hall). It’s on a program from earlier this month alongside Schoenberg’s fascinating orchestral rendering of Brahms’ Piano Quintet No. 1 (an old Rattle favorite, which he conducts live tonight at WDCH). 

What YouTube is for fans of cat videos, Berlin’s DCH is for fans of serious—and expertly played—German music.

-- James C. Taylor

Related story:

Simon Rattle wins over the Berlin Phil and its fans

Comments () | Archives (5)

Brahms lovers will cringe to see the mistaken reference to a Piano Quintet No. 1. There's just one such work, Opus 34. The work Schoenberg orchestrated is the Piano QUARTET No. 1, Opus 25.

The Digital Concert Hall, even experienced via a laptop and headphones is a slice of classical music heaven. The LA Phil should do something similar.

I have never understood this fixation with watching musicians, they arent pop music videos. Who cares what they look like? But in Euro musics, it is all spectacle and about control. When it should be about the music. When I listen to jazz, I often just close my eyes, whats to watch?

Miles used to turn his back to the audience, as in jazz you must listen to one another, its intertwining without some metronome up front keeping all enslaved and in time. And Miles would leave the stage when not playing. Its music people, instead of watching a buncha penguins in seats on TV, go download a concert, and play on good audio equiptment. Exactly how good will it be over TV, unless a recording quality sound miking is installed?

Weird. Its not Cirque du Soleil, or is it?

art collegia delenda est

The Berliners have pros set up the mics and pros to run the remote-controlled articulated high definition cameras. The sound is exceptional and the video direction is thought through beforehand so the viewer gets the experience of being there with an orchestra at the top of its game. So much so that it makes little sense to go downtown no matter how nice Disney Hall and the Phil may be. And then there are the archives where you can skip the silly and get to the good stuff.

But let me not confuse you with the facts.

I still want to hear music live, just not watch it on TV no matter how good. It is still not the same, so why not just buy a CD and listen at home? If not a musicians mother, why would I want to see them sitting all nice and pretty in organized rows? It is irrelevant, musically, but not for shows of power and the illusion of control.

art collegia delenda est


Recommended on Facebook

In Case You Missed It...


Explore the arts: See our interactive venue graphics


Tweets and retweets from L.A. Times staff writers.