Booster Shots

Oddities, musings and news from the health world

« Previous Post | Booster Shots Home | Next Post »

People with common thyroid cancers may not need immediate treatment, study says

May 17, 2010 |  4:21 pm
Most people with small, barely detectable tumors of the thyroid gland do not need immediate treatment, and their survival rate is nearly as good as the rate for those who do seek such treatment, researchers reported Monday. Critics of the study conceded that watchful waiting is, in fact, appropriate for many such patients but noted that even a small decrease in survival can mean many additional deaths when translated over large numbers of patients.

The diagnosis of thyroid cancer has been growing markedly, with a three-fold increase over the last three decades. Almost all of that increase is the result of the detection of such small, localized tumors, that are not normally apparent by palpation but that can be observed with sophisticated imaging techniques.

Autopsy studies also show that small thyroid cancers are present in most people who died from other causes, a finding similar to the observation of small prostate tumors in most men who die of other causes. Such findings suggest that most thyroid tumors (and prostate tumors) are a benign side effect of aging that can be safely ignored unless they suddenly start growing. Dr. Louise Davies and Dr. H. Gilbert Welch of the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice in Hanover, N.H., and the Veterans Affairs Medical Center in White River, Vt., compiled data from a national registry on 35,653 patients who were diagnosed with such small tumors, called papillary thyroid cancer, between 1973 and 2005; 440 of the patients did not undergo immediate treatment, which generally involves surgical removal of all or part of the thyroid gland.

Davies and Welch reported in the journal Archives of Otolaryngology--Head & Neck Surgery that, after six years of follow-up, 141 of the treated patients, less than half a percent, had died, compared to six of the untreated patients, or 1.4%. They projected that the 20-year survival rate for treated patients would be 99%, while that for untreated patients would be 97%. They concluded that "papillary thyroid cancers of any size that are confined to the thyroid gland have no lymph node metastases at presentation and do not [reach beyond the thyroid gland] are unlikely to result in death due to the cancer." That increase in deaths, they said, is offset by the increased risk of side effects from cancer surgery, which can include permanently low levels of thyroid hormones and significant damage to laryngeal function.

In an editorial accompanying the report, however, Dr. Erich M. Sturgis and Dr. Steven I. Sherman of the University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center said, in effect, "Hold on just a moment!"  While 2 percentage points is a very small difference, they agreed, when extrapolated to the 35,000 patients diagnosed with thyroid cancer each year, that could mean an extra 500 to 700 deaths. "Certainly, most of those hypothetical 500 to 700 people would have wished their physicians had offered them the treatment that had 'statistically' better survival." Some people can be simply observed, they said, but they have to be very carefully selected.

-- Thomas H. Maugh II

Post a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Comments (5)

A Frustrated Radiologist Says : Turn Off the Ultrasound Machines

An exasperated radiologist, John J. Cronan, MD says in the June 2008 issue of Radiology we should "turn off the ultrasound machines". Cronan questions this entire medical enterprise of detecting thyroid nodules, and small cancers with ultrasound guided biopsy. "From the patient perspective, we have hung the psychologic stigma of cancer on these patients and the dependency for daily thyroid supplementation...We accept all these consequences to control a cancer with a 99% 10-year survival."

For More:

jeffrey dach md

i am 31...i was diagnosed thyroid cancer back in 2003, while i was in the Navy. The few doctos who treated me where/are some of the best in the Midwest. They aggressively treated the cancer...and i went on my way. That was then

My current doctor, after reviews years of follow ups, told me they over aggressively treated me. After a long talk...i tend to agree with him.

Since, so many doctors have over treated me, im now stuggling to find a right balance of thyroid hormone...To much slows me down, to little makes it worse.

Interesting Dr Jeff - but what about the people who are daily thyroid meds already (mind you no cancer)? Just wondering...The meds helps, but not totally.

Unfortunately, thyroid cancer is not a "side effect of aging" as it is most common in young women.

It is overtreatment to put patients with microcarcinomas (tumors less than 1cm in size) through a thyroidectomy, RAI, etc. Most physicians cannot biopsy a thyroid nodule less than 1cm and will just watch it to see if it grows. Despite that, there are many stories of people with miniscule tumors who have had the entire menu of treatment and later experienced the side effects from radiation damage and TSH suppression.

People rarely die from papillary thyroid cancer, but the side effects from TSH suppression, radiation, and thyroidectomy surely can bring down one's quality of life, and no one ever tells the terrified, newly-diagnosed thyroid cancer patient that piece of information.

I had several tumors, some quite large, that were not felt by any doctor and were just beginning to show a few symptoms (slight cough,), for what they say was probably 20 + or - years, when I had an ultra sound for other reasons. The biopsy I had as a result of the ultra sound could not tell if I had cancer or not. I did have what is called Tall Cell papillary cancer, also in 11 lymph nodes. Biopsy said likely stage 4. Fortunately it hadn't spread beyond lymph nodes, so was stage 3. When I asked about my 45 yr old daughter being checked, my doctor thought it might be a good idea and she had very small tumors that would not have been biopsied except for my having had cancer. She had cancer also, with tall cell tendencies, spread to one lymph node. What if we had waited? Tall cell is a very aggressive type of papillary cancer. If my cancer had spread before being caught, my outlook for survival would be much poorer than it is now.


The Latest | news as it happens

Recent Posts
test |  March 15, 2011, 4:00 pm »
Booster Shots has moved |  July 12, 2010, 6:02 pm »