Booster Shots

Oddities, musings and news from the health world

« Previous Post | Booster Shots Home | Next Post »

Think that sheep's milk cheese comes from a sheep? DNA doesn't lie

December 30, 2009 |  1:41 pm

Who says scientists with PhD.s should have all the fun? Not us, especially after a high school class project involving DNA analysis resulted in the discovery of an invasive insect species and several mislabeled food items. Enjoying that sturgeon caviar? It might be Mississippi paddlefish.

Cockroach_th Brenda Tan and Matt Cost, both students at Trinity School in New York City, did a projected last year they called DNAHouse, collecting specimens from around their homes and nearby areas, and analyzing them via the Barcode of Life Database used to identify various species. (They had help from DNA barcoding experts from Rockefeller University and the American Museum of Natural History, both in New York City.) In an article in the January issue of the journal BioScience, the two reported they found readable DNA in 151 out of 217 items, including DNA from 95 different animal species.

Among the findings: Inside a box of grapefruit shipped from Texas was an Oriental latrine fly, considered an invasive species common to the South. In a packaged snack of dried shredded squid was DNA of the jumbo flying squid, which can grow up to 100 pounds. Tan and Cost also took hair samples from several classmates and wrote, "We were happy to report that our classmates came back as 100% human" (That must have been a relief.) A cockroach at first looked like Periplaneta americana, an American cockroach, but its DNA differed enough to possibly render it a new species or subspecies.

Among the food tested, not everything was as it seemed. A pricey bit of sheep's milk cheese was actually made from cow's milk, fish labeled smelt was really Japanese anchovy, and venison dog treats were made from beef.

In their paper, the authors wrote, "We do not know where or why the mislabeling occurred, but most cases appeared to involve substitution of a less expensive or less desirable item, suggesting the possibility of deliberate mislabeling for economic gain. We also think mislabeling is a serious problem because certain individuals have allergies or dietary restrictions regarding certain foods. ... Like a powerful flashlight, DNA exposes hidden identities of living and once-living things. We look forward to more explorations!"

Trinity has produced other sleuthing students: Last year Kate Stoeckle and Louisa Strauss discovered that one-fourth of the fish they bought at Manhattan markets and restaurants were mislabeled. The two will address the American Assn. for the Advancement of Science annual meeting this year.

-- Jeannine Stein

Photo: The mystery cockroach. Credit: Brenda Tan and Matt Cost

Post a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Comments (4)

heads should fly on this one. i'm a canadian but, like everyone else, we gotta eat food. food manufacturers and corporations just don't get it. if they want to make a profit, then stop ripping people off. WE ARE ALL FED UP with all the B.S. these greedy corporations keep feeding us. canada, the states, wherever. what a pathetic joke...


That sounds like fun. OK I admit to being a bit of a science nerd.

It's also a significant service to the community. I'd bet most of the mislabeling they found is deliberate.

This is very disconcerting. On a 'nonhuman' level, one of my dogs has irritable bowel and has to keep changing from venison to I wonder what she's getting and what I'm paying for! In another 'pet case', I switched producers of freeze-dried liver treats when the brand I was getting suddenly had labels 'Made in China'...when I called that company, they said the product was made from beef 'liver meal' in China under their supervision. I doubt the source (cattle) and the processing--if heparin and baby milk are adulterated, what about dog food?
The shock here is that US producers are basically pulling a 'bait and switch'...I'm sure those Manhattan kids did not get their 'goat' cheese at a regular grocery, but a high priced specialty store--the kind we all go to for our 'fave' treats. Guess I have to drive over to Cowgirl Creamery now when I want to know I'm getting the real deal.


The Latest | news as it happens

Recent Posts
test |  March 15, 2011, 4:00 pm »
Booster Shots has moved |  July 12, 2010, 6:02 pm »