carnegie logo

Babylon & Beyond

Observations from Iraq, Iran,
Israel, the Arab world and beyond

« Previous | Babylon & Beyond Home | Next »

EGYPT: Ordinary Muslims, too, share blame for violence against Christians


Amr Hamzawy is an analyst with the Carnegie Middle East Center.

Egypt is in need of collective redemption in the wake of the Alexandria bombing.  Egyptians must separate themselves from talk of conspiracies plotted by foreign terrorists. Let them instead take a hard look within and acknowledge that terrorism has a sectarian face.

Carnegie logoTerrorism exercises violence in societies that provide fertile ground for sectarian conflicts, as in Iraq, or likewise as it is being cultivated in Egypt today.

Egyptians must discard the deceptive displays they mechanically regurgitate each time blood is shed in crimes of sectarian violence. Championing national unity and flaunting it with kisses of priests by sheiks is baseless. Muslims who speak of their Christian brothers often do so incredulously.

Copts’ refusal to accept the condolences of government representatives to senior members of the All Saints Church is not an act to be feared. Rather, it is an explicit expression of a frustration gripping many Christians who are ruled by a government resigned to their discrimination.  Public institutions fail to soberly consider the root causes of such vehemence, and are lax in their responsibility to provide them with protection.

It is true that with the absence of democracy, the regime oppresses Egyptians of every color and creed. All citizens, Muslims and Christians alike, are subject to political marginalization dependent upon on the whims of state bodies and influential people. Yet, in claiming that Muslims and Christians share the same fate, Muslim Egyptians are denying the fact of that Copts confront legal, religious, and political discrimination that is unique to them.

Some laws have been recently introduced with the goal of promoting equality regardless of religious affiliation.  Despite these measures and other attempts by the authorities to shut down satellite channels accused of fomenting sectarianism, the government remains impotent to combat sectarianism. 

Conversely, some are mistakenly shifting the blame solely onto the government for its failure to build a society free of sectarian tension, and where all citizens are created equal. Indeed, the government bears a share of the responsibility in perpetuating discrimination. All Egyptians, however, particularly the Muslim majority, have come to generally accept the idea of Copts as inferior and as second-class citizens. 

In fact, discrimination is not only ignored, it is flourishing to the point of damaging the national fabric.

As the overwhelming majority, Muslims bear most of the responsibility to preserve the values of diversity, tolerance, equal treatment and coexistence. Yet the Muslim majority seems either unwilling or unable to assume this role. Positive signs do sometimes emerge, as when Muslims protected Coptic churches on Jan. 6, Christmas Eve, a week after the attacks at All Saints.

Amid Egypt’s increasing religiosity, however, broad segments of Egyptian Muslims have become overwhelmed by unfettered extremist discourse in the media. It should come as no surprise when Copts respond to such aggression with the equally exclusionary message, “Egypt is our country and Muslims are guests.”

Copts struggle against legal restrictions on the construction and maintenance of churches while Muslims are freely allowed to build mosques. Coptic representation in parliament -– only a handful of Copts were elected in November 2010 elections to the new 508-seat People’s Assembly -– is close to zero despite comprising an estimated 10% of the population. The president’s ruling National Democratic Party named only 10 Copts as candidates out of a total 800 running in the parliamentary race. The government and ruling party have come to accept Copts’ systemic marginalization.

Acts of sectarian violence are on a terrifying rise across Egypt. Those in power make arrests and reproduce the customary speeches. The regime focuses on foreign conspirators as the culprits, and extols national unity without introducing any real policy changes that affect the Christian population. Judicial bodies in Egypt are empowered to bring those guilty of violent crimes to justice, but the courts have often failed to render conclusive verdicts. Such outcomes offer the public the tragic impression that Christians and their places of worship are legitimate targets for hatred.

If they truly seek to rescue Egypt from sectarian violence and restore the humanity of their society, their treatment of Copts as second-class citizens must stop. 

The regime must introduce political, legal and procedural changes to guarantee Copts’ security and religious freedoms, as well as to increase their representation in government.  As part of a long-term society project, civil society organizations and liberal media must work to restore Egypt’s heritage of tolerance and secular citizenship.

-- Amr Hamzawy in Beirut

Editor’s note: The post is from an analyst with the Carnegie Middle East Center. Neither the Los Angeles Times nor Babylon & Beyond endorses the positions of the analysts, nor does Carnegie endorse the political positions of The Times or its blog.

Photo: Egyptian activists hold a banner with a crescent and a cross representation reading in Arabic 'one god, one dream, one destiny, one population' during a June 7 gathering in Cairo. Credit: Ahmed Khaled/European Pressphoto Agency 


Comments () | Archives (25)

using your analogy, all of us Americans are should be held responsible for all the lives lost in Iraq, Afghanistan. since few of us opposed those invasions and never spoke out about prosecuting those responsible for those misadventures.

Why must our comments for this article be censored. This is America and we have free discourse here. It is in the Islamic countries that people are not free to say what they think. This procedure of censoring peoples comments before they are posted is truly unbelievable.

Nedal Wrote:
"Give them freedom and true representation than blame them should they fail to provide protection to any of the citizens regardless of the cause"

We have 2 muslim middleastern nations (Iraq, Gaza) that got their true representation and still failed to protect none muslims. Unfortunately Freedom and democracy proved fatal mistake for Islamic countries, unless of coarse you have an example for a single succesful Islamic democracy? The problem lie deep within Islam itself, unfortunately not many Muslims accept the fact Islam needs to be reformed.

An "overwhelming majority" does not bear responsibility for such heinous acts unless they have a say of who is running their country. You can NOT deprive the majority of any true representation of how their country is run and hold them responsible for the failure of the system to protect a minority. Regardless of weather the failure is a law enforcement failure or even the failure to defuse the sectarian divide. Give them freedom and true representation than blame them should they fail to provide protection to any of the citizens regardless of the cause.

In my opinion, the immediate issue that needs to be addressed is dealing with people who incite hatered and violence against Copts. Top of the list are Selim Alewa and Almesryoon electronic newspaper with it's editors the 2 brothers Mohmood & Gamal Sultan, these people are responsible for the death of 60 Iraqi Chistians, and 32 Coptic Christians by spreading false rumors about the Church imprisoning Muslim women. These people are still free inciting hate against Copts on a daily basis without being even questioned by Egyptian Authorities! I wonder why?

« | 1 2


Recommended on Facebook


In Case You Missed It...

Recent News
Introducing World Now |  September 23, 2011, 8:48 am »



About the Contributors