carnegie logo

Babylon & Beyond

Observations from Iraq, Iran,
Israel, the Arab world and beyond

« Previous | Babylon & Beyond Home | Next »

IRAN: Woman sentenced to death lashes out at activist, lawyers in TV 'confession'

IRAN-articleInlineNew developments in the case of Sakineh Mohammadi Ashtiani, a 43-year-old Iranian woman and mother of two who faces the death penalty for adultery and murder.

On Monday, Iranian state TV aired what it says was a statement from Ashtiani in which she called herself a sinner and said she had been "deceived" by lawyers.

On Tuesday an Iranian court official revealed that two German journalists who allegedly tried to interview her son and her lawyer were facing espionage charges 

"These two German citizens had come to Iran claiming to be tourists but their actions in Iran and in Tabriz, providing information and staging propaganda, indicates that they had come for spying," the head of East Azarbaijan provincial court, Malek Azhdar-Sharifi, was quoted as saying by Iran's semi-official Fars News Agency.

Taken together, the two developments suggest the extreme extent to which Tehran is willing to go over the Ashtiani case, which is proving to be a humiliating blemish on the Islamic Republic's already battered international image. 

Like in previous broadcasts of her alleged confessions, Ashtiani's face was blurred in the footage. She made accusations that fit squarely with Iranian hardliners' constant refrain that Iran has a fine human-rights record, and that international concern over Ashtiani's fate is all part of some Western conspiracy to defame Iran.

The seven-minute interview marked the third time Ashtiani, or someone purporting to be her, appeared on television to confess her guilt. She was originally sentenced to death by stoning for having an extramarital romantic relationship, but Iranian authorities have recently sought to recast her as a murderer, saying she was complicit in her husband's killing five years ago. She is reportedly facing death by hanging now instead of stoning.

Some Iranian legal experts have found Ashtiani's previously publicized TV appearances puzzling and have cast serious doubt over her earlier confessions.

Ashtiani spoke in her native Azeri during the interview, subtitled in Persian. 

"I didn't get anything from Hutan Kian," Ashtiani was quoted as saying in the report about her second lawyer, who became her defense lawyer after her first lawyer, Mohammad Mostafai, fled to Norway.

"He used to tell whoever he met in the prison, 'See what I've done for Mrs. Ashtiani? I'll do the same for you!' He lied to me. He used to say, 'Have you seen Ashtiani on TV? It's all because of me,'" she continued.

Kian himself was arrested last month along with Ashtiani's 22-year-old son while hosting the two German reporters at his offices in Tabriz. He had claimed that Ashtiani was badly beaten and tortured before a previous TV appearance.

In the television interview, Ashtiani lashed out at the Germany-based Iranian communist activist Mira Ahadi, accusing her of publicizing her case around the world.

The report also featured alleged statements by several other men, some of whose faces also had been blurred beyond recognition. Two of them were identified as Ashtiani's son, Sajjad Ghaderzade, and Kian. They both confessed to giving false statements to foreign media about Ashtiani's case. The other two men brought on air were said to be Germans citizens arrested in Iran last month while attempting to interview Ghaderzade, who claimed they had been deceived by Ahadi.

At one point in the report, the presenter began speaking about international reactions to Ashtiani's case and described them as a "propaganda war against Iran". A voice-over in Persian said Ahadi, the figurehead of the International Committee Against Stoning (ICAS), was trying to "take advantage" of Ashtiani's case for her own benefit.

6a00d8341c630a53ef0133f51c8411970b-120wi Ashtiani herself called on Ahadi to stay away from her case, saying publicizing her story was none of her business.

"I committed a sin," she said.

When the turn came for the man said to be Ghaderzadeh, he slammed Ashtiani's lawyers and accused them of using his mother's case to obtain political asylum abroad.

"In my opinion we do not have any respect anymore because of Mr. Mostafai," he said. "He ran away and sought a political asylum. Hutan Kian wanted to do the same as Mostafai but fortunately it didn't happen and he was stopped. He wanted us to talk to foreign media to make the case more sensitive, but it just got worse."

Earlier this year, Ghaderzade conducted a lengthy interview with a Swedish-Iranian journalist for a Swedish tabloid newspaper. During their secret meeting in a park in Tabriz, he told the reporter he is convinced that his mother is innocent and didn't have an illicit romantic relationship with the man accused of murdering his father. At the time, he also raised worries over potential repercussions for speaking to foreign media about his mother's case.

But he took it all back in his statement on Monday, saying everything he had told foreign media was "a lie."

-- Alexandra Sandels in Beirut

Photos: Demonstrators hold a placard with Ashtiani's photo at a recent protest in Rome in support of her. Credit: Agence France Presse / Getty Images. Lower image: Sakineh Mohammadi Ashtiani. Credit: Facebook.







Comments () | Archives (7)

There's so much injustice in the world. Where can anybody start?

and people wonder why we insist on separation of church and state here...

poor woman you really believe that the irenians let her come on tv and tell the real story

"Those gentleman in the judiciary and their handlers in Iran think that by coercing confessions and airing them on state run propaganda TV station they can claim legitimacy for their illegal and criminal actions."

It's a show trial. Joseph Stalin lives.

This lady comes not from the boulevards of North Teheran but from the north-eastern tribal area where local religious law prevails. Iranian law is in the process of revision, something that along with others changes might proceed more swiftly in a less demonised and externally threatened environment. While a sentence of stoning may still be passed down from religious courts, stoning itself was banned in Iran some years ago and such sentences will be overturned by a higher judiciary.

The death penalty is provided for murder in many countries and was applied to a woman in Virginia as recently as September. There is a difference between sentencing and carrying out the sentence and, between the two, clemency may have a greater role than it does in the West. However that clemency needs to be an act of ‘religious’ inspiration and cannot be seen to be the consequence of pressure from the grinding of distant axes, which are more likely to be fatally counter-productive.

Where is her lover?Why he does not stand up?

Those gentleman in the judiciary and their handlers in Iran think that by coercing confessions and airing them on state run propaganda TV station they can claim legitimacy for their illegal and criminal actions. The reality is that the more they expose this kind of behavior and tactics they keep using over and over, the more they are exposing the corruption in the judiciary and the length they are willing to go to hide injustice in Iran under the Islamic Republic's watchful eyes. Legitimacy can only be achieved by respecting the people's rights and practicing fairness in the rule of law. The gentleman in Iran must have heard of the expression "digging one deeper in the hole".


Recommended on Facebook


In Case You Missed It...

Recent News
Introducing World Now |  September 23, 2011, 8:48 am »



About the Contributors