carnegie logo

Babylon & Beyond

Observations from Iraq, Iran,
Israel, the Arab world and beyond

« Previous | Babylon & Beyond Home | Next »

IRAN: Conflicting videos raise questions over missing scientist

Will the real Shahram Amiri please stand up, or at least upload something?

Two contradictory videos have surfaced within days of each other, both claiming to reveal the truth of what happened to Amiri, the Iranian scientist who disappeared last year and reportedly defected to the United States.

Picture 21 The first video, shown on Iranian state television Monday, claimed to depict Amiri recounting his kidnapping and torture by American intelligence forces in Tucson, where he says he is being kept against his will.

In the second video, posted on YouTube one day later, Amiri, or someone who looks just like him, says he is in the United States to pursue a doctorate and hopes to return to Iran after completing his studies.

Neither tape has been verified, leaving the world to speculate about the authenticity of both tapes and the possible motives behind making them. Did the Iranians forge Amiri's plea for help? Was Amiri a victim of extraordinary rendition? Did he get bored in witness protection? Is he lying on one or both tapes to protect his family in Iran?

The theories are endless, and the tapes offer little in the way of answers.

"During the eight months that I was kept in America, I was subject to the most severe tortures and psychological pressures by the American intelligence investigation groups," Amiri says in the first video, appearing to speak into a web camera.

"The main aim from this was to impose political pressure on the Islamic Republic of Iran and in fact condemning [Iran] and proving lies that America has been constantly saying against the Islamic Republic of Iran."

Amiri goes on to say he was kidnapped and calls on international organizations to take up his case.

Some analysts have pointed out that the grainy quality of the video, which was released by the Iranian government, does not match the studio-quality sound, raising suspicions that the tape is fake or altered.

Picture 19 The second video is more formal, but no less bizarre. Amiri appears to be sitting in a study, with a globe and chess board set up behind him, delivering a statement in which he denies that he is being held in the U.S. against his will.

"I do not hold any political views and have no interest in the political subjects and discussions of any state and country," he says.

"I am not involved in weapons research and have no experience and knowledge in this field," he continues, adding that he intends to get a doctorate in health physics so that he can help "increase health standards in Iran and worldwide."

Amiri disappeared last year while on a pilgrimage in Saudi Arabia and was widely reported to have defected to the United States. Iran has denied this version, maintaining that Amiri was kidnapped by American intelligence agencies.

The release of the two videos coincides with the anniversary of the disputed Iranian presidential elections, which led to widespread unrest throughout the country. The government continues to treat the opposition as a threat and has tightened security in recent weeks in anticipation of more protests.

-- Meris Lutz in Beirut

Video: Al Jazeera English reports on the two conflicting tapes. Credit: Al Jazeera English via YouTube.

Screenshots, top and bottom: Two videos, one aired on Iranian state television and the other uploaded to YouTube, purportedly show Amiri. In neither case has the identity of the man been verified.

Comments () | Archives (3)

USA and Israel are the biggest terrorist countries in the world. We would be going to war if Iran's gov't kidnapped an American from Canada and tortured him.

Well we all know that he disappeared from Saudi Arabia. The Saudi government admitted to help move him to the American custody and we admit that we have him according to Mrs. Clinton. So, what part of this is hard to understand?

What needs to be said is that who he contacted if he truly defected and if he has not, then why are we holding him and what gives us the rights to abduct him like bunch of thieves!? It is shameful that we have to stoop to such lows.

Well, to me it's pretty clear, it doesn't need a brain surgeon to discover that he is obviousely tortured by Americans and under pressure he has made the second video to counteract the first one, which sounded more genuine for the very reason that its quality wasn't studio quality.
It just makes sense when you understand the man is psychologically tortured and pressurised to the point that he sneaks and makes a video (The first one) and as soon as it's released and broadcast on the real News (Press TV, which actually tells the news in real and not perverted version of it), then straight away Americans make him produce another video, in which the speaker so obviousely reads a pre-written text.
Which one's genuine! You decide! It's not difficult is it?


Recommended on Facebook


In Case You Missed It...

Recent News
Introducing World Now |  September 23, 2011, 8:48 am »



About the Contributors