Tonight, the guys fought it out for the final two spots in next week's finale. And they didn't hold anything back. We were shown three great artists giving amazing performances.
Adam Lambert was the strongest and most consistent man of the night. Unless Simon's fear is confirmed and America just happens to forget to vote (don't see that happening), Adam will be a finalist. For Round 1, Simon pulled some strings and Bono personally gave the OK for Adam to sing "One" by U2. Adam (with Simon's help!?!) rearranged the song and gave us an emotional rendition with killer vocals. Classic Adam. During Round 2, Adam flat out SANG — "Crying" by Aerosmith. Adam came into the competition understanding what it means to entertain, and he gave America what it wanted from him. I don't think anyone questions his rightful spot in the final.
Now on to the real competition — will Danny or will Kris survive tomorrow night? Both guys had decent first rounds, but each of their personal song choices could be included among the strongest performances of the season.
Danny was given Terence Trent D'Arby's "Dance Little Sister" by Paula, while Randy and Kara had high hopes for Kris and "Apologize" by OneRepublic. In retrospect, both Danny and Kris played it pretty safe during Round 1. If I did have to give it to someone, it would have to go to Danny — the corny dancing tipped the scale.
Round 2 was the complete opposite. Danny gave us the perfect arrangement of the perfect song for his voice. Danny executed Joe Cocker's "You Are So Beautiful" flawlessly. After he sang, I thought there was no way Kris could overcome his first round and Danny's amazing performance — but I was wrong. Kris, in true comeback fashion, surprised us by completely revamping Kanye West's "Heartless" into a laid-back, guitar-driven groove. He put all his chips in by standing center stage with only his guitar and voice, trying persuade America to vote on his behalf. It might have worked.
Just like Ryan Seacrest, I have no idea how the results will turn out tomorrow. Danny has a strong following from the get-go and pulled out my personally favorite performance of the night with "You Are So Beautiful." Kris is the underdog and has been picking up new fans every week. He was creative and bold with an amazing arrangement of "Heartless." We shall find out tomorrow who is left standing!
On another note &mdasyh; happy 300th episode, "American Idol," and congratulations on the $140 million raised to date through "Idol Gives Back." My proudest and most meaningful moment on "American Idol" was my role during the first "Idol Gives Back." Thanks to everyone who has given to these worthy causes.
NOTE: Please join us for our regular post-game chat Wednesday, noon PT/3pm ET.
RELATED:
Richard Rushfield: Last stand in the Idoldome
Ann Powers: The boys state their cases
Buzzmeter: Who will go home?
— Phil Stacey
Photo: Top - Kris Allen and Danny Gokey. Bottom: Carrie Underwood earlier this month visits orphanages and health centers near Luanda, Angola for "Idol Gives Back." Credit: Fox